Gransnet forums

Food

Melting chocolate with butter and water for an Oreo cake

(21 Posts)
teabagwoman Mon 27-Oct-25 12:27:09

My dgd has asked for an Oreo cake at Christmas. I’ve just looked up the recipe and it says to melt the chocolate with the butter and 200ml of water. I’m sure I’ve heard that letting water near melting chocolate causes it to seize. Can anyone enlighten me?

Chocolatelovinggran Mon 27-Oct-25 12:47:10

This is so- you need to melt it in a bowl over a pan of just - simmering water, making sure that the bottom of the bowl doesn't touch the water.
You can use a microwave on a low setting, stirring every 10 seconds, alternatively.
Chocolate, as you can see by my name, is an area of interest to me !

Oreo Mon 27-Oct-25 13:07:15

And an Oreo cake is of interest to me 🤭
The water doesn’t mix in with the ingredients it’s just used in the pan beneath the chocolate and butter to melt them, you get a lovely shiny mixture doing it this way.

Norah Mon 27-Oct-25 13:26:46

Perhaps the recipe would clarify? Post the recipe, please.

Oreo Mon 27-Oct-25 13:34:53

Yes, you could be right, maybe the water is part of the recipe?

teabagwoman Mon 27-Oct-25 13:52:23

This is the recipe.

www.bbcgoodfood.com/user/786855/recipe/oreo-chocolate-cake

OldFrill Mon 27-Oct-25 14:09:22

If you read the comments below the recipe a couple recommend leaving out the water, that's what I'd do. Cake looks great.

Oreo Mon 27-Oct-25 14:12:47

There’s a great looking Halloween cake on that site too, which I think I’ll make if I have time.

Maelil Mon 27-Oct-25 14:14:03

The chocolate will seize if you put water in after it has been melted. It won’t seize if it’s melted WITH water and butter as the butter stops that happening. It means you end up with liquid chocolate (rather than chocolate which will reset once cool) which may well be very important for the recipe.

teabagwoman Mon 27-Oct-25 14:20:13

Thank you Maelil, I knew there would be a Gnetter who knew the answer.

Esmay Mon 27-Oct-25 17:19:18

I prefer to melt chocolate over steaming water,but I have followed recipes which call for it to be melted in water and butter .
I think that it's OK.

Norah Mon 27-Oct-25 17:55:57

teabagwoman

This is the recipe.

www.bbcgoodfood.com/user/786855/recipe/oreo-chocolate-cake

Thank you. Lovely recipe.

I've a similar recipe, butter water mix melts chocolate well.

WithNobsOnIt Tue 28-Oct-25 22:06:22

Just buy a decent cake from Sainsbury or M&S..Or a Cadbury's Chocolate Cake.

Don't like Oreo products. American chocolate YUK!!!

Allira Tue 28-Oct-25 22:51:21

It looks delicious.
Rich, dark and chocolatey! Unfortunately OH doesn't like chocolate cake.

The lemon drizzle looks good,too

Allira Tue 28-Oct-25 22:52:57

How unkind, WNOI 😲

Don't be upset Oreo, we like you.

teabagwoman Wed 29-Oct-25 06:11:06

Oh Allira, that’s a shame. I think it might be grounds for divorce here!!!

I’m looking forward to trying out this recipe but have to get half term over first and then recover from it. Doesn’t help that I had a THR a month ago though being without pain at last is wonderful.

Norah Wed 29-Oct-25 15:25:41

WithNobsOnIt

Just buy a decent cake from Sainsbury or M&S..Or a Cadbury's Chocolate Cake.

Don't like Oreo products. American chocolate YUK!!!

No.

Her GC asked for it, sounds lovely!

Allira Wed 29-Oct-25 19:55:42

teabagwoman

Oh Allira, that’s a shame. I think it might be grounds for divorce here!!!

I’m looking forward to trying out this recipe but have to get half term over first and then recover from it. Doesn’t help that I had a THR a month ago though being without pain at last is wonderful.

😁
It is seriously weird, isn't it 😁
I might have to find a recipe for a microwave chocolate mug cake.
I haven't made a chocolate cake since the DC left home!

Allira Wed 29-Oct-25 19:56:46

Doesn’t help that I had a THR a month ago though being without pain at last is wonderful.

You're doing well!

teabagwoman Wed 29-Oct-25 20:07:30

Allira, I would bake a chocolate cake and freeze it in slices. I’ve never found a chocolate mug cake recipe that was really satisfying and frozen cake takes very little time to thaw.

Allira Wed 29-Oct-25 20:08:58

Tempting!

I do have a slice occasionally when one of the family has a birthday 😀