Gransnet forums

Gardening

Cutting down one of my trees

(83 Posts)
Furret Sun 20-Apr-25 17:46:48

My next door neighbour is moaning again about a tree in my garden casting shade on hers. Yes, it’s a tall conifer BUT it is home to so man birds; sparrows, goldcrest, blackbird, wood pigeon etc..

Clearly it’s too late to fell it during the nesting season. We did it cut it back a bit last year, at a cost of £300, and we’ve already cut down a conifer in the front garden to keep the peace.

I appreciate it keeps the sun off part of her garden but we have very big gardens so it’s not as if hers is in shade all day every day. There’s still plenty of sun gets through.

Looks like I’m going to have to fell it in the autumn but the thought of all those birds wondering where their homes have gone to upsets me.

What do I do?

Etoile2701 Thu 24-Apr-25 17:52:59

Oh dear .... neighbours! Have just finished watching The Feud on Channel 5. Don't be bullied by her.

ayse Thu 24-Apr-25 18:00:21

My daughter has a garden with conifers on all the borders. The previous owner made a Japanese garden. She’s gradually going to replace most of the conifers with native trees. She’s already bought a rowan, hawthorn and hazel. She’ll do it gradually.

Witzend Thu 24-Apr-25 18:01:14

A neighbour of ours has complained bitterly about a mature beech tree in the corner of our very small garden - it does partly overhang his even smaller one. However it’s protected, so even to get it thinned a bit we need permission. We offered to do it if he’d go halves (it’s a lot of £££) but he didn’t want to pay, so that’s it.
It was there when they bought the house, decades after we bought ours - maybe they didn’t understand that trees shed leaves, and beech trees attract squirrels, who will be busy scoffing the nuts and dropping the shells in autumn!

keepingquiet Thu 24-Apr-25 18:09:46

Why not plant a replacement tree? Although it may take a while to grow, birds will nest elsewhere if the conifer goes.

You can plant any kind of tree to attract wildlife and plant it where it won't disturb the neighbours.

Most birds love shrubs and hedgerow plants more than conifers anyway.

If it was me I would replace the offending conifer and create a different kind of wildlife haven... and keep the neighbours happy.

NotSpaghetti Fri 25-Apr-25 08:30:14

keepingquiet some neighbours are never quiet. There will always be something wrong.

Unless it was dangerous, I'd only remove it for them if they were paying.

keepingquiet Fri 25-Apr-25 08:40:53

My neighbours are quite noisy too. I have to put up with it. Luckily they go away a lot so that's very considerate of them and affords me some peace.

It's just a fact of life that we have to compromise in order to live side by side with other humans...

nanna8 Fri 25-Apr-25 09:02:14

We’ve got a fussy,whiny neighbour too. Always looking for something to whinge about. All I can say is they must have unhappy lives, though it is sometimes hard to feel sorry for them.