Gransnet forums

Gardening

Help! which plant is this?

(44 Posts)
Wyllow3 Tue 14-Apr-26 08:45:58

I potted these up from somewhere in the garden and have clean forgotten what they are, anyone?

Casdon Tue 14-Apr-26 08:48:15

It looks like a hosta to me.

Esmay Tue 14-Apr-26 08:49:33

Not sure until it unfurls !
I also have mystery plant which I'm not sure about .
I've put it in a pot until it blooms .

lixy Tue 14-Apr-26 08:49:44

Oooh, if it’s a hosta the slugs and snails will soon let you know!

I wondered about lily of the valley?

MaizieD Tue 14-Apr-26 08:49:53

It looks like a hosta to me, too.

Basgetti Tue 14-Apr-26 08:50:24

Yep, hosta.

ExDancer Tue 14-Apr-26 08:51:13

Are they bulbs? Tulip or lily perhaps? It looks as though there may be a bud hiding in the middle so you'll soon know with a bit of luck.

MaizieD Tue 14-Apr-26 08:51:46

I enlarged the photo and looked at the largest leaf. The veining on it is very hosta like.

Esmay Tue 14-Apr-26 08:52:12

That's it - a hosta !
Not one left in my garden due to slugs .

Luckygirl3 Tue 14-Apr-26 08:52:53

Do you use google on your phone? Just to the right of the bar in which you write your search there are tow icons, one a mic for recording and the other a little square with rounded corners and a dot in the middle - that is Google Lens. If you click on that a camera screen appears that you can use to photograph the plant and it then goes on to give you detailed information about the plant. It is very helpful when deciding which are weeds and which are not!

Luckygirl3 Tue 14-Apr-26 08:53:26

I never plant hostas - they just attract slugs!

Magenta8 Tue 14-Apr-26 08:54:48

I don't think it is pointy enough and the leaves look too wide for lily of the valley. Could be some other sort of lily.

Please post a picture on GN when it finally emerges. I hope the slugs don't get to it first.

Casdon Tue 14-Apr-26 08:57:15

I’ve got several hostas in stone pots Luckygirl, the slugs don’t like the rough texture, so they stay slug free.

I thought I recognised what they were, because my hostas are at exactly the same stage, with the leaves curled up ready to unfurl.

keepcalmandcavachon Tue 14-Apr-26 09:05:15

Lovely hosta, will thrive in damp shade. As do slugs! Start keeping and crushing your egg shells Wyllow3.
Gotta love a free plant, I am finding a few Ladie's Bonnets and Lady's Mantle popping up at the moment, thrilling!

MaizieD Tue 14-Apr-26 09:40:40

Slug and snail pellets!

Modern ones aren't lethal to pets and birds...

J52 Tue 14-Apr-26 09:44:14

I put gravel around my Hostas, then spray with garlic water ( doesn’t leave a smell).
I make garlic water by putting a couple of crushed garlic cloves in water, leave for a bit and then spray. A litre lasts all season.

Cressy Tue 14-Apr-26 11:07:06

I think it’s a hosta. I saw a reel on Instagram ( Anya the Garden Fairy) this morning which said the leaves are edible ……

Allira Tue 14-Apr-26 12:06:17

Luckygirl3

I never plant hostas - they just attract slugs!

I have a long row in a shady spot, they do get nibbled a bit but seem to do fine and flower each year. We do have a hedgehog which visits regularly, perhaps she keeps the slugs and snails down!

Allira Tue 14-Apr-26 12:07:12

MaizieD

Slug and snail pellets!

Modern ones aren't lethal to pets and birds...

What about hedgehogs? If they eat the snails?

Shelflife Tue 14-Apr-26 13:33:02

I amnot an expert but looks like Lily of the valley.

Wyllow3 Tue 14-Apr-26 13:38:17

Well either way will pop in some organic slug pellets.
And look out for further posts as unfurls here!
Ps, thank you for the camera tip, appreciated! Will also try and take a shot sort of down the middle asap 😊

Davida1968 Tue 14-Apr-26 13:54:24

Coffee grounds also are good to deter slugs. The Google search mentioned by Luckygirl should identify the plant. Good luck!

Wyllow3 Tue 14-Apr-26 14:46:00

Oh, I didn't know about coffee grounds, I have always wanted to find a use for them. Are there no snags as regards using them?

Will do search later I want to use it for a few things! In and out right now, but here is looking down the plant and its not really helpful.

Allira Tue 14-Apr-26 14:56:46

Davida1968

Coffee grounds also are good to deter slugs. The Google search mentioned by Luckygirl should identify the plant. Good luck!

Google Lens says probably hosta!

Oreo Tue 14-Apr-26 15:05:01

Luckygirl3

I never plant hostas - they just attract slugs!

My hostas are in pots and never get any slug damage.
Yes the mystery plant looks like a hosta but not many stalks coming up as yet.