Differing DNA results, My Heritage & Ancestry.

I've never been tempted by DNA tests - they're far too general and not specific enough.

A few hours on a genealogy website and you've found hundreds of ancestors and current family members - and lots of information about where they lived, what they did etc. Much more satisfying in my opinion.

I think this is still an inaccurate science because it's based on data which is not yet fully available. It depends on how many people have signed up, and it seems that different companies will produce different results based on their available data. I do know that Ancestry updates its findings when more data becomes available which is a good thing.

If you type 'How accurate are DNA geography tests' into the YouTube search bar, there are several scientists on different videos talking about how small the fragment of DNA can be that they take assumptions about and how much guesswork is involved.
There is also an article online about identical triplets who are on a US TV programme (one of those home improvements in a stupidly short time kind of programmes) who had this test done. Two of them were similar but the other was totally different although they must have had an identical heritage.
They are fun and seem accurate on kinship but the geographical ones not so much.

I wouldn't trust My Heritage. I did it for myself and got the expected results so I bought a test for DH. His grandmother was French, father English but Portuguese way back. His results were rubbish. Being him, he phoned them up and got stuck in. Eventually someone he spoke to admitted that the French apparently won't let their DNA records be used so anyone with French blood will get a false result. Shame they don't tell people!! He got a refund!

There was some doubt as to whether one of my great-grandfathers was the man named on my grandfather's birth certificate (the marriage was seven months after the birth, in 1890.) However Ancestry has linked me to distant cousins who could only be related via that lineage. So one little query is sorted. It also shows me as 7% Scots-Irish which is in line with the birth-place of another great-grandfather.

Unfortunately the great-grandmother who "got into trouble" continues to elude me. I can't find any record of her from prior to my grandfather's birth, and the DNA matches haven't thrown up any obvious lines of enquiry either.

Edithb when you say 'straight to Ancestry' what do you mean? Ancestry is one of the best websites for research so I would go there to research my family. That is nothing to do with DNA which is another matter altogether. You can either research through Ancestry, or have a DNA test through Ancestry, or do both! The DNA test helps you find relatives but it is no substitute for researching your own family.

My Heritage they are just after your money,my Son did his DNA through them and the results were very sparse no follow up at all.I did my DNA with Ancestry and had a very good result, giving lots of details about the areas in Ireland my family came from, I was very satisfied, My Heritage gave my Son the percentage of where he comes from nothing else, very disappointing. Do not trust My Heritage is my advice.

I wouldn’t trust that Ancestry place. I’ve heard their results are not accurate- read it and heard radio phone in on the subject. I’m sure you had to pay for the result?

I saw an American version of “Who Do You Think You Are?” and in both cases shown they didn’t need to bother with any research, it was straight to Ancestry and relatives were immediately discovered. Must be pretty comprehensive now.

BluebellGran looking at your original post your experience is similar to mine in that your Ancestry test seemed more in line with what you know of your family origins. And both our MH tests have produced strange results. I know it's impossible to be certain of our origins and some of the DNA can trickle down the centuries from someone way back, so I can accept that maybe someone got washed ashore from the Spanish Armada, or there's a bit of Viking there somewhere, but when MH says 1% Middle Eastern then I'm sorry, that is ridiculous. Especially when there was 0% in the Ancestry test!

I have used “23 and me” which was recommended as reliable by Dr Michael Mosley.
I was interested in finding out my medical inheritance which was hugely reassuring (e.g. I don’t carry the breast/prostate cancer gene or the Alzheimer gene)
By contacting some of my closest cousins I was presented with a full family tree from my paternal grandmother’s side of the family which makes me keen to research the rest of my family once I retire.
I just wish that all these companies would merge their databases in the interests of their customers.

Well according to this page Ancestry has 14 million DNA tests sold worldwide and My Heritage is the top choice with 100 million users.
Best DNA Test Kits
Having had different results from both of them I can't say what the answer is, although My Heritage gave me some very strange results which I wasn't expecting and which didn't show on Ancestry!

The Ancestry is very comprehensive and will pick up relatives that you don’t know about, remember that works both ways. Relatives find out about you, more than a few family secrets have been revealed.

As I understand it, your results are compared with those of everyone else who has tested with that same company. A big company such as Ancestry has many other results to compare yours with with, while a smaller company will have relatively few. If My Heritage is a smaller company they will have fewer results for comparison.

Have you looked at www.lostcousins.com? They have very good info about dna testing.

However, they do link you up with cousins and there are definitely some relatives on the Ancestry site so that part of the DNA analysis does work. I haven't contacted anyone on the My Heritage site yet.

I did exactly the same thing. The Ancestry test was fine, but this recently got 'updated' and was different. I found that confusing so I took the My Heritage test as it's supposed to be good. But the results came back completely different again.?
So now I can choose out of three different options, presumably whichever ancestral line I prefer. I'm now confused and disillusioned. ?

It makes you wonder how reliable any of these tests are.

My family and I had our DNA done by ancestry and seems to be pretty accurate. It has shown me a number of 2nd 3rd and 4th cousins who are related to my ancestors and have found the links myself. I personally trust Ancestry but do not know anyone who has used My Heritage