Gransnet forums

Health

Misleading packaging

(42 Posts)
Eloethan Mon 05-Oct-15 15:09:04

I've just seen a news item regarding packaging of medical products.

I was aware that generic medicines - such as paracetamol - may be almost or just as effective as much more expensive, branded items. I was not aware that the constituents of some of these products were exactly the same, the only difference being the packaging and, of course, the price.

One painkiller was described on the packet as "fast acting" but it was no different from a product under the same brand that had no such "fast acting" description. One painkiller was labelled "for the treatment of migraine" and the very same painkiller was labelled "for the treatment of period pain".

People are paying up to four times more for a product which is exactly the same except for the packaging and the claims made on it.

I think it was Heath who talked about the "unacceptable face of capitalism". This is surely such an example - along with the much more serious car emissions scandal that is increasingly involving more and more car manufacturers. Apparently there is also some concern that the energy ratings on some electrical items have also been rigged.

I'm beginning to think that almost all companies will behave very unethically or even illegally if they think they can get away with it.

harrigran Tue 06-Oct-15 13:47:25

I always buy the cheapest paracetamol tablets available from supermarkets, at the end of the day they work exactly the same as the expensive tablets. I rarely use painkillers so generic is fine. Long term users of painkillers tend to get used to them and will not get the same relief from the same dosage.

annodomini Tue 06-Oct-15 13:59:17

At the moment the cheapest paracetamol caplets I can find are from Aldi at 19p for a packet of 16. Panadol, with exactly the same contents, costs more than 5 times as much. Why does anyone buy it?

petra Tue 06-Oct-15 14:51:22

Soontobe. You haven't heard anything about car emmissions!!!! Are you serious. There's this little car company called Volkswagen that's been lying to the whole world and is so serious that it could bring down the German government and you haven't heard of it. Words fail me.

Nelliemoser Tue 06-Oct-15 15:37:19

Eloethan "fast acting" . Or "nothing acts faster than X" is just what it says. It is not claiming it's the fastest or how fast so it is not legally misleading advertising.

It is question of "caveat emptor" buyer beware!

A prime example of why we should always read any adverts that catch our eye carefully and think about what exactly they are implying.

Also if we are taking medication we should always read the instructions to get an idea how they work which is usually simply explained. It pays to be aware of what medication we are stuffing into our bodies and what they are supposed to do.

To be sceptical of such claims is important if we want to keep informed about anything. Newspaper spin and speculation included.
They should teach these skills in schools along with financial skills about pay day loans and such like. Inform our kids and get them to question things.

rosequartz Tue 06-Oct-15 15:39:53

Or as DH always says 'Nothing acts faster than A*****n so take nothing!'
grin

soontobe Tue 06-Oct-15 15:49:18

No petra, not heard of it.
I do bury my head about all things car related[I tell DH if there is a warning light, and that is it]. Oh and triple check that I dont get mixed up with petrol and diesel.

I willo google about Volkswagon.

Nelliemoser Tue 06-Oct-15 15:50:18

The NHS clearly need a good information campaign about generic drugs.
It would upset the big Pharma companies though.
Pfizer spent $1.1 million dollars advertising drugs last year.

Nelliemoser Tue 06-Oct-15 15:52:17

Soontbe Do you never listen to the news?

soontobe Tue 06-Oct-15 16:05:37

Not on a regular basis.
Read newspapers on an irreglar basis.
I see news channels from different countries on an irregular basis too.
The car emissions thing I obviously missed.
Occasionally celebrities or famous people die and that passes me by too.

petra Tue 06-Oct-15 16:20:05

Soontobe. Do I take it that your Husband is the same, ie, doesn't listen to news. Because when the shit hit the fan about Volkswagen it was HUGE.
Now if I'd been on another planet all day and not heard the news (wouldn't happen) my OH would have mentioned it. Or do you both inhabit this strange bubble.

soontobe Tue 06-Oct-15 17:57:34

He listens to more news than I do. And different news.
He hasnt mentioned Volkswagen.

I just asked him if he has heard of it, and he said yes.

Is it really that big of a deal?
I really dont think that big corporations are spotless. Sad, but there we are.
And sometimes scandals bring down governements. Again, not that unheard of.

soontobe Tue 06-Oct-15 18:01:03

petra. I like you smile
I wonder if I have annoyed you in some way with something I have written?
Would you like to say what? Can we sort it?
Happy to try.
Perhaps you have misunderstood something I said?

Ana Tue 06-Oct-15 18:03:41

'...so serious that it could bring down the German government...'

A more than slight exaggeration, I think! grin

thatbags Tue 06-Oct-15 19:43:05

I guess it depends what they mean by fast-acting, eloethan. Also, charging more than what? The generic kind? No, I don't think it's misleading but I do think the intention is to grab people's attention and money, for instance the attention of someone with a migraine headache, or period pains, so they mention those on the box. That's just marketing. That's how it's done. I reckon all adults should be able to suss that companies will try to get as much money out of them as they can. My dad used to say, the cost of something is "whatever the suckers will pay". Don't read that wrongly; he was saying it bitterly. I'm not saying it's totally acceptable. I'm just saying it's reality and if the companies doing it aren't breaking the law (i.e. lying to us) there's no point whining about it.

Re your point about being able to 'trust' what it says on the box, I'm sure they would be prosecuted if they were saying anything actually untrue. We do have some standards and laws to hold marketeers to.

Elegran Tue 06-Oct-15 20:12:07

Some tablets are rock hard. Maybe the way they are manufactured makes others softer and they really do break down faster and get to work sooner, although they contain the same amount of the same drug? I know nothing about how they are made, so that is very much a maybe.

NanKate Fri 09-Oct-15 07:04:37

I was recommended to take Imodium for IBS by my doctor. I paid in the region of £5.00 for a packet, then we found in Sainsbury's an identical number of tablets with the same ingredients for 99p - a result. smile