Gransnet forums

Health

Illness, mental and physical

(57 Posts)
thatbags Wed 18-Nov-15 12:19:39

Why is it deemed offensive to tell someone to go to a doctor (psychiatrists are doctors) if they have a mental illness? Asking because I don't think it is deemed offensive to tell someone with an injury to go to A&E or someone with a chronic physical condition to go and see their GP.

I regard our brains as part of our physical bodies so if things go wrong with them (i.e. we get a mental illness), surely we need to go and see a doctor who might be able to help us deal with it, or even cure it? Why do we persist in making mental health something quite separate from other health? That is what makes a stugma about it, not the illnesses themselves. They are just illnesses, like measles or mumps.

soontobe Thu 19-Nov-15 18:56:42

But the whole thing is more than a "win" or "lose" situation.

Sometimes in life it is better to "lose", than to not speak out.

thatbags Thu 19-Nov-15 19:21:47

I'm not sure I understand what you mean, soon. I know I used the word loser but that was no a summation of the whole episode.

thatbags Thu 19-Nov-15 19:22:43

not a

soontobe Thu 19-Nov-15 19:51:55

The paragraph about the scout leader and the paragraph before that, speak to me of you not wanting to "lose".

But someone losing a point or being seen to be "losing", is not as important an issue, as KJ acknowledging or whatever, the insult. Else, how can the insult be dealt with? And the insulter be dealt with?

WilmaKnickersfit Thu 19-Nov-15 21:01:21

Apologies POGS for getting the wrong sister's name - despite checking it before posting!

thatbags as poster with long term problems depression, if someone made KL's comments to me, I would be too shocked to say much back. I think I would have to excuse myself. If the comments were made in the hearing of others, I would like to think someone would speak up. I would decide what to do next based on the circumstances, but I not let it go. I am done with pushing down anger and making excuses for people. Thank goodness we're living in a more enlightened age and the behaviour of dinosaurs like KL's have no place in the public service of this country.

I am not sure if I agree with the idea that some people will always be insulted, at least not those with depression.

thatbags Fri 20-Nov-15 09:33:37

soon, I thought I explained what I meant by the scout leader being the loser: he lost my respect for a time because of his gross misjudgment of me.
When it became clear that he was sorry for being an arsehole, he regained my respect.

wilmak, no problem with people expressing their anger at stuff. See above.