Gransnet forums

Health

Does 'venting your spleen' do any good?

(34 Posts)
annodomini Tue 31-May-16 10:10:57

As this is a public forum and can be accessed by 'outsiders', I would be very wary about venting my spleen - if I had any - where I might be identified. However, I do agree with you, Anya about the venting. When it's over, that should be it. If it goes on and on, it ceases to be venting, because the very word is a metaphor for letting go of harmful emotions and grudges.

Juggernaut Tue 31-May-16 10:07:28

I've only 'vented my spleen' once. A cousin was behaving in a wholly unacceptable way to my mum. There was an almighty shouting match, the air was cleared, a problem was stopped from becoming insurmountable and when it was over, it was over. The subject has never been mentioned again and the relationship is stronger than ever.
I don't hate my cousin, there's no bitterness, but I wasn't prepared to sit back and watch her upset my seriously ill mum repeatedly!

TriciaF Tue 31-May-16 09:46:36

Maybe there's a difference between venting on a public forum, and with the person who is actually upsetting you?
Like you,*Anya*, thank goodness I don't have this depth of hatred or bitterness, too placid in fact.

ninathenana Tue 31-May-16 09:41:01

smile thatbags

thatbags Tue 31-May-16 09:27:17

Not talking about the sort you mentioned nina.

thatbags Tue 31-May-16 09:26:20

I think venting in the manner mentioned is supposed to be cathartic, so once you've vented you should be on the road to recovery from whatever angst was eating you, I would have thought. If one repeatedly sounds off on a particular subject I think it can be seen as corrosive, bitter, and unforgiving.

ninathenana Tue 31-May-16 09:24:09

I think most of you know that I use the forum to rant about D's estranged husband. I've never "vented my spleen" over this (or anything else, that I can remember) in RL but just ranting about his treatment of D to all of you makes me feel a whole lot better.

whitewave Tue 31-May-16 07:50:35

Well I am as is well known a wimp.

But I will confess to venting my spleen only once in my life. That was at my sister. I do not need to go into details but it was very traumatic both for me and her I think. However one of the issues I was most worried about was resolved which in effect was influencing everything else, so it did work but at a great personal -at the time -cost.
It took about a year for us to be comfortable with each other again.

Anya Tue 31-May-16 07:43:35

I've been pondering this as there are threads when it would seem that rather than 'getting it off your chest' it has the opposite effect and encourages anger and a general splenetic condition.

Perhaps in a one-off situation having a good vent might clear the air and dissipate the anger,. but when strong feelings, against a family member or a politician, as example, are embedded it would seem that this kind of behaviour just feeds on itself. This is especially true when others feel equally embittered and pour fuel in the fire it would seem.

I can't understand this depth of hatred myself, nor do I want to, and I wonder what harm it does to,those who do.

If possible I'd hope this discussion would focus, not on the two examples given but more generally on the question in the subject heading.