Gransnet forums

Health

I feel worse now.

(93 Posts)
morethan2 Thu 25-Apr-19 17:18:22

I’m a big listener of radio 4 while I’m doing housework. I’ve just listened on catch-up an interview with Clarke Carlisle (who I’ve never heard of) talk about depression and his attempted suicide. It was really interesting and he mentioned something called the Goldberg depression test Out of interest I googled it and up popped a questionnaire. So I did it, I answered the questions truthfully. I thought my answers were fairly positive so thought I’d get a your reasonably ok result, but no the result was Your moderately to severely depressed. I’m really shocked. I don’t really feel depressed or rather I didn’t before I took the test now I want to cry! I wonder if anyone of you fancy taking the test and sharing your result and how you feel about it. Ps I also bought the children’s dvd mentioned in the radio so maybe I’m just gullible.

CrazyGrandma2 Fri 26-Apr-19 14:36:01

Gone Girl Hope you feel better soon. It's a hideous illness. No need to hide. I'm sure many of us have experienced it and eventually come through it. flowers

Neilspurgeon0 Fri 26-Apr-19 14:29:51

It reports that I am moderately depressed but the wife told me I am fine, so that’s ok then! When I was off work severely depressed she told me I should “Snap our if it”. Great tonic my missys !!!!

dianetheartist Fri 26-Apr-19 14:02:54

I scored 67% severe depression,,, not surprising really..had to stop the antidepressants I was taking about 2 months ago ..Initially, I had them to stop nerve pain but because they caused severe and I mean severe sweating from head to toe, all day and night I stopped them.. I cut down gradually and the sweats stopped. But the depression has come...back to the docs for me,

Tiggersuki Fri 26-Apr-19 13:50:51

Took it out of interest and scored 3. Feel a bit disappointed I didn't score higher. No idea how you got such a high score if you feel fine. Sit outside ( if it's not raining) and listen to the birds singing. I think that would cheer up anybody.

Nannyme Fri 26-Apr-19 13:41:45

I scored 11% - depression not likely !!!!

rascal Fri 26-Apr-19 13:33:42

Thank you for the link Gonegirl I took the test as morethan requested. Score 0% Depression Unlikely. I didn't think I was depressed anyway. flowers

madmum38 Fri 26-Apr-19 13:22:02

Trouble with these tests is no leeway with answers as with the sleep one, yes I am always tired but I take enough medication to knock a horse out, not because I am depressed.
Think you know your own instincts as to whether you are or not

Gonegirl Fri 26-Apr-19 13:06:06

Thanks KatyK smile

KatyK Fri 26-Apr-19 13:01:59

No need Gonegirl it's best to share.

Gonegirl Fri 26-Apr-19 12:59:05

I will shut up now before I bring everyone down.

Gonegirl Fri 26-Apr-19 12:58:35

When I wake up in the morning my first words (after good morning to DH) are "oh dear!". Done the test several times now. It's always between 50 and 56%. And that's with my fluoxetine.

A lot could be down to tiredness with aging. Tiredness, and lack of strength, takes away so much of the joy in life.

Annaram1 Fri 26-Apr-19 12:53:40

I could not load the questionnaire so I have no idea if I am depressed or not.

Frannygranny Fri 26-Apr-19 12:45:44

I scored 11% and unlikely to suffer from depression. Obviously my medication for clinical depression is working!
Excellent last sentence, Crazy, really sums it up when you’re in the grip of depression.

KatyK Fri 26-Apr-19 11:41:34

Your last sentence is a great way of explaining it Crazy.

CrazyGrandma2 Fri 26-Apr-19 11:39:10

I shouldn't worry morethan2. Are you old enough to remember the song "My word You do Look Queer?" The song ended with the person feeling so much better when someone told them they looked well!

0% for me. I used to suffer badly with depression when I was younger. A good indicator would have been a question asking if your first thought on waking was something along the lines of, "Oh not another day to face!"

KatyK Fri 26-Apr-19 11:27:51

is not us

KatyK Fri 26-Apr-19 11:27:22

Depression is an illness the same as any other. I was in the 'pull yourself together/you bring it on yourself' camp until it hit me like a ton of bricks (severe anxiety rather than depression). Please don't assume depression etc us self induced. Difficult lives/events can break even the strongest camel's back.

Hollycat Fri 26-Apr-19 11:25:23

I scored 5 - no depression likely. So I’ve decided not to slit my wrists after all!! I think these tests really have to be done by a clinician, don’t read too much into them. My daughter found one on Asperger’s syndrome and we all did it completely honestly. Turns out I’m the only one who’s not on the spectrum!! I’d often wondered about the others ?

blueberry1 Fri 26-Apr-19 11:11:51

89% Severe.And I am on the highest dose of my anti-depressants!

quizqueen Fri 26-Apr-19 11:07:55

I just took the test and got 22%- mild-moderate depression. It's a total joke. I'm someone who thinks people who claim to be depressed, anxious etc. are of weak character and need to just get on with stuff without being a moaning minnie and I am, in no way, depressed myself. I'm just a strop, and an honest one at that, but that's something entirely different!

A lot of life's mishaps are generally bought on by the person themselves (weight issues, bad choice of partner, falling out with their families, choosing the wrong job etc.) so, if they changed their ways somewhat, they would see things improve without medication. There's too much reliance on what people see as a free health service, and a benefits system which really should only be a temporary safety net and not a way of life.

cathieb Fri 26-Apr-19 10:58:36

What a pointless and possibly dangerous test! It doesn’t reflect the ups and downs of mood in the everyday life of a normal well-rounded person. As someone else said... poor sleep, not concentrating well on reading etc do not necessarily have anything to do with depression. The test is angled to show that if you are not perfectly happy, speeding cheerfully through life and firing on all cylinders then something is wrong with you and you are probably ‘ill’. There are much better and more subtle tests out there, but I think most people know themselves when low mood is consistently stopping them functioning, which could be classed as depression.

libra10 Fri 26-Apr-19 10:49:13

Score 6% - depression unlikely. What I expected, though I feel some of the questions are biased towards a positive depression response.

LJP1 Fri 26-Apr-19 10:41:30

I suspect that mild to moderate depression is the other side of 'some to quite a lot' of contentment / happiness so probably on the good side of normal.

Try reviewing your perception of the 'result'.

Sheilasue Fri 26-Apr-19 10:38:40

I just went in and did the test, I got 13 which they said would apply to a lot of people. I have had counselling after the death of my son, I would recommend it. It was cognetic behaviour therepy.
My son has been dead for 11 years but I still get depression and grief so counselling has helped me to manage it.

Sparklefairydust Fri 26-Apr-19 10:38:06

94% severe depression, correct!