Gransnet forums

Health

Abortions

(46 Posts)
Caleo Fri 04-Oct-24 11:43:26

It is a rare bit of good news that Melania Trump had published in her book that she supports and always has supported women's rights to control of their own bodies, and therefore supports women's right to abortion.

eggplant Fri 04-Oct-24 18:25:21

I despised her to the bottom of my soul and still do

I'm sorry you had this experience, it sounds awful. That person you despise may have been econimical with the truth.

Smileless2012 Fri 04-Oct-24 18:26:04

Wethertomorrow (((hugs))) and flowers.

Grantanow Fri 04-Oct-24 18:27:53

It's Trump's strategy to appeal to women for their votes. I hope they are not fooled.

LovesBach Fri 04-Oct-24 18:28:01

It must be so hard to make this decision, and even harder to go through with it, and then live with what has happened. A friend had an abortion when she was seventeen, under intense pressure from her family - the father had walked away, uninterested. I met her years later when we were both regularly waiting at the school gates, and she eventually told me that it had been the worst day of her life, and she thought about that child constantly. What a burden to carry.

TerriBull Fri 04-Oct-24 18:31:49

Whether tomorrow so sorry for your traumatic experience flowers

SueDonim Fri 04-Oct-24 19:02:20

I’m sorry you had that sad experience, Whethertomorrow. flowers I’m guessing you didn’t have any counselling at the time? If that’s the case, it’s never too late to talk to someone about it and maybe make peace with what happened.

Despising someone for making a decision you wouldn’t make isn’t helpful, though. It won’t matter to the other woman what you think, it only hurts yourself. I think if someone makes a decision like that it’s better to consider that perhaps they didn’t have the ability to take any other path, perhaps because of their upbringing or lack of imagination.

Cossy Fri 04-Oct-24 19:33:17

whethertomorrow

flowersflowers

Cossy Fri 04-Oct-24 19:35:06

Doodledog

I think that anyone making the decision to terminate a pregnancy deserves understanding rather than judgement. The only person who can know if it's the right decision for a woman is the woman herself.

flowers
👏👏👏

Cossy Fri 04-Oct-24 19:36:10

TerriBull

Life is never straightforward, it can be messy, some people can become pregnant very easily, it's not always planned, not always conducive to their lives, sometimes it will be ruinous, they're too young, they're too old, they're too ill, too addicted, too abused, too downtrodden, too poor, maybe a mother to too many already, it may break them, may affect them both physically and mentally, sometimes that pregnancy has been forced upon them. Lets not judge our fellow women for having to make what is no doubt a very hard choice.

Well said! 👏

Deedaa Fri 04-Oct-24 19:48:01

When I was a teenager we lived next door to a single man who we presumed to be gay. He never had a girl friend or even a female acquaintance. We eventually found out that he had indeed once had a girlfriend. They both had dictatorial mothers who both wanted to keep their children tied to them and wouldn't permit any sort of relationship. Of course the girl got pregnant, dared not tell her mother, and went to a backstreet abortionist which was the only option in those days. When it went wrong she was dumped on her own doorstep to bleed to death. Whatever one's feelings about abortion, no one deserves to die like that.

Doodledog Fri 04-Oct-24 20:59:37

Cossy

Doodledog

I think that anyone making the decision to terminate a pregnancy deserves understanding rather than judgement. The only person who can know if it's the right decision for a woman is the woman herself.

flowers
👏👏👏

Thank you for the flowers, but I'm not speaking abut myself here.

I feel for anyone who has decided not to go through with a pregnancy, and as someone who worked with young people for years have spoken to several who came to that decision. Their reasons were varied. Sometimes they appeared to be cloaked in bravado, but who knows - we can't see into the minds of others, and even if we could we'd have to realise that their minds don't necessarily work in the same ways as our own.

Franbern Sat 05-Oct-24 09:10:32

Surely, abortion must be preferred to bringing an unwanted life into the world.
In a world that is already overpopulated, every baby born should be a loved and much wanted one,

Aveline Sat 05-Oct-24 09:15:58

All previous Republican party presidents' wives have been pro abortion. In Trump's case Melania's statement is probably just a political attempt to increase potential Democrat voters' chances of voting for repulsive Trump.

Vito Sat 05-Oct-24 09:46:37

weathertomorrow 💐

Cossy Sat 05-Oct-24 09:58:06

Deedaa

When I was a teenager we lived next door to a single man who we presumed to be gay. He never had a girl friend or even a female acquaintance. We eventually found out that he had indeed once had a girlfriend. They both had dictatorial mothers who both wanted to keep their children tied to them and wouldn't permit any sort of relationship. Of course the girl got pregnant, dared not tell her mother, and went to a backstreet abortionist which was the only option in those days. When it went wrong she was dumped on her own doorstep to bleed to death. Whatever one's feelings about abortion, no one deserves to die like that.

That’s utterly horrifying and very sad

Cossy Sat 05-Oct-24 09:58:31

Franbern

Surely, abortion must be preferred to bringing an unwanted life into the world.
In a world that is already overpopulated, every baby born should be a loved and much wanted one,

I completely agree

Shelflife Sat 05-Oct-24 15:30:33

Whethertomorrow, my heart aches for you. Clearly the trauma has remained with you . I sincerely hope that by telling us your story you now feel less distressed. 37 years ago and I bet it feels like yesterday! You were in a shocking situation and made the correct decision - I send you big hugs and hope you are ok . 💐💐💐💐

Wheniwasyourage Sat 05-Oct-24 17:20:34

Whethertomorrow, I hope the support you have had here has helped you. Hugs and flowers from me too.

Whethertomorrow Sat 05-Oct-24 19:20:59

A heartfelt thanks to everyone for your kind and thoughtful words. They have meant the world to me. I have taken photos of your lovely comments and will keep them to look at when my soul needs soothing.

Many thanks. 💖💖💖

MissAdventure Sat 05-Oct-24 19:24:34

That's so lovely to read.
Please add my support to your list - I didn't comment before because I didn't know what to say.

I'm glad to know that others' thoughts have soothed your soul. smile