Gransnet forums

Health

Carpal tunnel in both hands

(30 Posts)
labradorlinda33 Tue 13-May-25 16:28:11

Hello everyone, I have recently been diagnosed with Carpal tunnel in both hands.
My left hand is worse (I'm left handed)..I had nerve conduction tests and was told it is stage/level 3 on the left and 2 on the right.
I'm seeing the hand consultant next Monday.
Has anyone had surgery? Was it successful? A friend had it years ago and has it again in the same hand.
T I A for any advice and experiences...smile

tanith Tue 13-May-25 16:44:20

Had the surgery about 4 yrs ago I had some numbness in my little finger for about a year after but otherwise it’s been fine since. Good luck with yours.

Marydoll Tue 13-May-25 16:44:48

I have RA and had a carpal tunnel op, 9 years ago. I could not believe the instant relief. It had become unbearable.

The nerve conduction tests were negative, but when the surgeon opened up my wrist, he could not believe how severe it was.
I was unable to have general anaesthesia, nor sedation and instead had a nerve block.
It was the weirdest feeling, being fully compos mentis during the op.
I was fortunate to have it done by a plastic surgeon, rather than a general one.
The only issue was that the stitches were so tiny, that the nurse struggled to remove them.

I hope all goes well for you.

V3ra Tue 13-May-25 16:50:35

My daughter had both wrists operated on, with good results.
Prior to the surgery she found acupuncture was by far the most helpful treatment.

crazyH Tue 13-May-25 17:02:52

For the past few months, I have problems with my little finger and ring finger. …numbness and unable to fully straighten my little finger. I have asked to see a GP, but some new triage system even to see a GP. 😫 I think it’s a nerve compression issue because I tend to lie on my side propping up my head with my left hand , when I read my iPad. It’s not painful so I can wait.

Grannynannywanny Tue 13-May-25 17:18:24

I had both hands done at separate times about 25 years ago. Very successful outcome and no further problems. I opted for a nerve block and I didn’t feel a thing after the injection quickly took effect.

Good luck with your surgery.

Macadia Tue 13-May-25 17:21:16

I wouldnt have surgery. It sometimes goes away on its own with some lifestyle changes. My DD had it, one side, all the way to her shoulder. It disabled her for a year but it's completely gone now. I had it in both hands - very painful. I changed my lifestyle and it healed after about six months.

I have not heard of anyone being damaged from surgery but you should look at success rates.

aggie Tue 13-May-25 18:00:05

I had both hands operated on as day cases , not both on the same day !
I was warned that I had let it go on too long so I only had improvement in less pain , but I still have the numbness in my finger tips
It won’t go away , so I always tell anyone who asks … get the surgery sooner rather than later

BlueBelle Tue 13-May-25 18:03:56

Had both hands done years and years ago in the 90s Never had a moment trouble since My eldest daughter also had both done and no further problems
It’s magical all the pins and needles and pain gone in a flash

choughdancer Tue 13-May-25 18:40:51

I had both hands operated on for Carpal Tunnel Syndrome nearly 40 years ago, and then 2 operations for Trigger Finger about 30 years ago. Before that I had had various injections into the thumbs and later the fingers with no improvement. The operations sorted both out with no side effects. Now, at 70, my wrists and hands are weaker than normal, but that has only been over the last 5 years. I think it is definitely worth it; the operations must be better now too! Good luck shamrock

M0nica Tue 13-May-25 19:47:46

There is little or no operation to it these days. I have had both hands done in the last few years.

The first one was done under local anaesthetic and sedation and has left a half inch scar, just about visibleon my right wrisst.

The second 'operation' was done in December, using a new piece of equipment just being introduced. No sedation, just local anaesthetic, a long needle like instrumnt was inserted in my arm guided down an inch or two to the carpal tunnel, snip, snip and it was done. meanwhile I was chatting away to the nurse. Up and on my way home 15 minutes later, no incision, no recovery time needed, I just got on with the days activities, no scar and instant relief.

labradorlinda33 Tue 13-May-25 22:27:24

Thank you everyone for sharing your experiences with me. The tingling, numbness and pain seemed to come on quite suddenly and I now wear splints when I go to bed which do help .I'll see what the consultant says on Monday ...

Homestead62 Wed 14-May-25 03:23:56

Macadia, what lifestyle changes did you make?

M0nica Wed 14-May-25 07:20:29

labradorlinda33

Thank you everyone for sharing your experiences with me. The tingling, numbness and pain seemed to come on quite suddenly and I now wear splints when I go to bed which do help .I'll see what the consultant says on Monday ...

If the carpal tunnel came on quite suddenly, a contributing feature may be that you have problems with your upper spine as well.

The carpal tunnel problem in my right arm developed over 30 years. That in my left arm very dramatically. So much so that my doctor thought I might have had a stroke, although that has now been proven otherwise.

When I finally had the nerve conduction tests, the specialist asked me if before the sudden onset I had been doing something where my hands were folded in towards the wrist. I had been, and as a result I was told the cause was damage to the top of my spine, nothing exceptional, just the ordinary wear and tear of life.

After my last procedure, I saw a spinal specialist who confirmed that the remaining numbness and pain in both arms and hands were not carpal tunnel symptoms but symptoms of cervical spondylosis. patient.info/bones-joints-muscles/neck-pain/cervical-spondylosis. Usually this causes people pain in their neck, but it can also cause pain down the arms and numbness in the fingers and most people over 60 have it to some degree or another, even if it is symptomless.

Petula Wed 14-May-25 15:04:28

Surgery on both hands simultaneously (yes two doctors) with local anaesthetic. My pain had been severe in both hands and arms especially at night. The pain went straight away. Quite difficult for a couple of weeks as I lived alone, but I am so pleased that I got this done just weeks before lockdown. That is my experience.

suzybe Wed 14-May-25 15:15:43

I had carpal tunnel following a broken wrist. When I saw the surgeon he said it had come on so fast he didn't want to wait as he thought I could lose the use of three fingers permanently. No space on the fracture clinic surgery list so he saw me on Friday and I was operated on the following Wednesday on a general surgery list. Had the stitches out Christmas Eve and fortunately it all seems to be fine except for the odd twinge if I put pressure on the scar area. I wouldn't have rushed to have surgery but as I had no previous problems I had to believe the surgeon when he said it was the result of the accident and a very poor outlook if I waited. Thank heavens that we have the NHS for emergencies although I am still on waiting lists for other problems

labradorlinda33 Wed 14-May-25 15:18:54

Monica, that's very interesting.. I've been suffering with bladder spasms for a while now and have been prescribed medication. It does seem to be helping.
Reading about Cervical Myelopathy, it mentions, apart from the problems with tingling in fingers etc, about problems with bladder function.
I'm going to write down questions to ask the Consultant when I see him on Monday.
Thanks for that..

BluebirdAL Wed 14-May-25 16:11:54

I was a potter for almost 40 years and had carpal tunnel in both hands. I never had the operation. After a little research and speaking with other potters, I tried vitamin B6 100 mg. It gave me over 10 years pain-free relief. You have to take one every day, but it is water soluble so it doesn’t accumulate In your body. Give it a shot. It might just help you too.

vintageclassics Wed 14-May-25 16:36:52

I've had it in both hands TWICE - first ops were done by GP in their surgeey - lasted about a year then came back - 2nd op on each hand was at the hospital with incision further up the wrist - both successful though I have been left with a little numbness in both palms but no pain at all. I was advised I could have both done together or seperately I opted for the latter as I don't know how you'd do anything with both hands out of action!

pen50 Wed 14-May-25 21:00:13

I had the surgery in 2020 and 2021 - the second time was unpleasant because the consultant - who thought he was God - did t give me sufficient local anaesthetic, despite me saying my hand wasn't properly numb. Bastard. However, aside from that, both surgeries were successful and I've had not recurrence.

labradorlinda33 Tue 20-May-25 14:43:20

Hello everyone, thank you so much for your advice and experiences. I saw the hand consultant yesterday and am now waiting for a date for surgery.
I'm pleased as it is getting worse...

labradorlinda33 Sun 01-Jun-25 14:07:17

Hello again, I am due to have surgery on 19th June on my left (dominant) hand.
We're going to France 11 days later and am now wondering if I should postpone it until I get back...
I'm just thinking about showering, dressing, toilet etc which could be awkward initially because of the surgery.
I'm also expecting a date for my hip surgery, late July/August so I was hoping to get hand sorted before my hip...
I'm dithering.... Advice/ experiences very welcome..TIA..

Coops74 Sun 01-Jun-25 16:05:14

I had mine done many years ago but I had both operated on the same day which was a mistake .I couldn’t go to the toilet myself etc.But it was very successful.

Petula Sun 01-Jun-25 20:35:03

Labradorlinda33 I had my stitches removed 2 weeks after surgery. I was unable to get my hands wet up until that point, going away would not have been possible.
I had both hands operated on at the same time. Doing anything at all was tricky but I managed to look after myself, I live alone. I ate toast, peanut butter and bananas for a few days, I couldn’t open the ready meals that I had bought in advance. The washing up piled up for a few days until I could stack the dishwasher. After a couple of days I managed to sit in the bath and had to let myself dry naturally without a towel. It was certainly a challenge but I was pleased to get it all over with so quickly.

M0nica Sun 01-Jun-25 20:41:12

I went on holiday the day after my first carpal tunnel op. You only have sedation for the op and the scar only requires it most 2 stitches. I had no difficulty in using my hand normally when dressing, undressing, in fact it was back to normal life the day after, except for a sling for 2 days and not being able to use the swimming pool and spa facilities.

The first op was 7 years ago. At the end of last year I had my other wrist done. No operation, just a 'procedure, a needle was thread into my wrist and down half an inch to the carpal muscle, it was snipped, the needle was withdrawn. A bit of lint and plaster was put over the 'wound', rather like after a blood test, no sedation, just local anaesthetic, within 15 minutes I was on my way home, and life went straight back to normal.

11 days after your op/procedure, everything will be back to normal and you will already have forgotten you even had the op. Enjoy your holiday.