Gransnet forums

House and home

Toilet Rolls - soft but not strong

(72 Posts)
Granny23 Thu 13-Mar-14 01:53:05

Sorry to lower the tone of the forum but can anyone point me in the direction of decent toilet paper that does not disintegrate as soon as it gets wet? blush I thought I had cracked the problem by buying the Aldi, Aloe Vera rolls but they have changed and are now softer but decidedly not as strong. I have worked my way through all the brands, buying whatever is on special offer but each one is as bad as the others. I became so fed up of finding bits of paper stuck to the DGCs' bottoms and pants that I supplied them with baby wipes instead but now we are warned that wipes are not to be flushed down the toilet, not even singly.

Does anyone else have the same problems? Can anyone recommend a soft but STURDY loo roll?

Elegran Sat 15-Mar-14 09:36:04

I replaced the flushing mechanism inthe cistern of a close-coupled toilet that is only about ten years old. The old one flushed 10 litres. This one flushes 6 litres. Doubtless very good for conserving water, but not for giving it a good whoosh through.

jinglbellsfrocks Sat 15-Mar-14 09:21:21

The cisterns used to be higher. (pull chain ones) Perhaps the water went through with a bigger woosh. And, of course, newspaper disintegrates fairly easily.

durhamjen Sat 15-Mar-14 00:32:27

Bigger diameter pipes, Tegan?

Tegan Fri 14-Mar-14 21:05:40

Those Nicky ones came out top in a comparison on the tely but no one knew where to buy them from. I still don't understand why it is we used to use newspapaer when I was a child but the toilets didn't block.

rosequartz Fri 14-Mar-14 20:54:29

I don't flush them even though it says they are 'flushable'. I wrap them in some koala toilet paper and bin them.

Probably 'too much information' as DH would say.

newist Fri 14-Mar-14 20:35:35

Nellie please keep up the good work with your testing, I have a septic tank and have to be so careful as to what I flush

judidoo Fri 14-Mar-14 20:30:17

Yes Jinglbellsfrocks, I agree about size of Cushelle rolls . I used to get Velvet though and didn't like it after they made it softer. _Came to pieces too easily. So Cush is one up at present.
By the way, HATED the scented Cush. I got them by mistake and they spent months in the spare room , airing!

rosequartz Fri 14-Mar-14 19:29:42

Nelliemoser, I was just wondering if you were my neighbour, but I don't live in Cheshire! Neighbours had a problem with Andrex 'disposable' wipes so she has been doing some experiments!

Culag Fri 14-Mar-14 18:43:00

Brilliant Nelliemoser grin

jinglbellsfrocks Fri 14-Mar-14 18:14:09

You only need to use half a one of these at a time. After using ordinary toilet paper. So it will not block drain.

Velvet and Cushelle are neck and neck in my opinion. But Cushelle make huge rolls that you don't have to change so often. So it wins.

Nelliemoser Fri 14-Mar-14 17:36:58

Culag I have been experimenting with the solubility of disposable wipes and bog roll.

I filled two pots with 500ml of tap water at tap temperature.
At midday I put three sheets of ASDA "Shades so soft" toilet paper into one pot and did the same with an Andrex "disposal" toilet wipe into the other one.
I stirred them both around the same number of times each, every 10mins or so. In about 40mins the toilet paper had disintegrated into slush in the jar.
After 5hrs 20mins the Andrex wipe is starting to disintegrate, but
has a way to go still.

For the sake of their domestic plumbing does anyone else want to play scientists, with another brand using these same conditions? I am particularly interested in seeing how long the cushioned ones take to go totally into mush.

Blame Culag posting that link for this strange request. wink

I must get a life!

durhamjen Fri 14-Mar-14 17:04:29

Our toilet was always blocking when we first moved here. One year my husband had to wait here for the drain engineer on Christmas Day, so then we had a camera put down. Am I the only one who has a DVD of their drains?
The grandchildren have been taught not to put wipes down the toilet, but granddaughter sometimes forgets.
I told you that you should buy recycled toilet paper!

judidoo Fri 14-Mar-14 17:00:14

I go for Cushelle - at present. The trouble is you just find one that's good and they go and "improve" it. I did like the one that had the ad. with bears using it, but they filled it with THIRST Pockets. These made a layer of dust all over the floor AND gave me blocked sinuses. Can't remember its name, or maybe it was Cushelle? Whatever! I've been trying so many in recent years. .

goldengirl Fri 14-Mar-14 16:45:34

When ever I needed tracing paper to do my homework I would raid the Bronco! For its 'proper' use my mum showed me how to scrunch it to make it softer. These day I use Waitrose Essential and have no complaints smile

seasider Fri 14-Mar-14 07:36:08

My first after school job was in Woolies. I had to write the price in individual rolls of Izal and build a pyramid!. I think Nickyelite is also sold in Home Bargains.

kittylester Thu 13-Mar-14 18:11:49

Andrex with Aloe Vera - DH insists - he has a very sensitive botty!! grin

Anne58 Thu 13-Mar-14 17:46:19

I recommended Nicky Elite on the first page, similar price to yours pamelaJEAN the packs I get are £1.99 for 9 rolls.

annodomini Thu 13-Mar-14 17:30:06

I have been buying Waitrose's own brand, but next time I am near Home Bargains I will invest in the Nicky Elite ones. I share a drain with two neighbours and when it was blocked it overflowed over my patio. Not at all nice. The reason for it was that my neighbour's son and girl friend had been flushing wipes and condoms.

pamelaJEAN Thu 13-Mar-14 16:44:15

I use Home Bargains Nicky Elite 18 rolls, for £3.99 ....what a bargain... it has a baby lotion smell... so gives the bathroom a lovely delicate scent. It is far superior to any other toilet paper I have used... I used to buy Cushelle... but they seem to have changed it... and it is very thin now.

Culag Thu 13-Mar-14 16:22:34

Do let us know how you get on, Nelliemoser , grin

Nelliemoser Thu 13-Mar-14 16:16:00

Culag Your link is interesting. I am tempted to experiment.

oznan Thu 13-Mar-14 16:12:20

Andrex Skinkind with aloe vera is brilliant.I have to use lots because of colitis and will go out of my way to buy it!

Joelise Thu 13-Mar-14 15:38:34

Andrex quilted

Pamaga Thu 13-Mar-14 15:16:31

Andrex Touch of Luxury enriched with Shea Butter. Their Washlets are good too.

Gally Thu 13-Mar-14 14:24:37

Izal and Bronco only had one good use - for tracing maps of the world for Geography lessons wink

In Oz the loo paper is just right - soft and doesn't integrate. I have yet to find anything which compares, although I quite like the one which has 'hello Vera' in it - can't remember the make.