Gransnet forums

Legal, pensions and money

UK pensions lowest in developed world!

(117 Posts)
Nonnie Mon 12-Feb-18 15:44:51

Just opened Yahoo and this was on the front page.

UK retirees receive lowest pensions in the developed world
Mark Dorman,Yahoo Finance UK 5 hours ago
Reactions Like Reblog on Tumblr Share Tweet Email

British pensioners are near the bottom of the league table for what they can expect to be paid on retirement (Getty Images)
Pensions in the UK are the least generous in the developed world, new analysis shows.

Workers earning the average £26,500 salary can expect to be paid less than a third of that – about £122.30 a week – on retirement.

That level of 29% is below the likes of Mexico, Poland and Chile and well under the world average of 63%.

MORE: Two out of three UK pension schemes are in the red to the tune of £210bn

The pension rate was assessed by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD).

It reports that in contrast to the UK, Holland replaces 100% of a typical worker’s wage when they retire.

Portugal, Italy and Austria pay above 90% of a worker’s salary on retirement, while in France it is 74.5%, Germany 50.5% and the US 49.1%.

The UK is right at the bottom of the scale for pensions (OECD)
Pensions and retirement pots have been a hot political potato for years, with a succession of reports warning millions of people in the UK are set for a tough time in their twilight years.

MORE: 1 in 8 workers thinking of quitting their pension scheme

Few have saved anywhere near enough to supplement their state pension. Young people setting out on their working lives today are also facing the prospect of having to work well into their 70s before they can quit.

From later this year, the state pension age for women will rise from 63 to match men at 65, and will reach 66 for both by 2020.

The government’s economic forecasters, the Actuary’s Department, believes it will become 70 in the 2050s and 71 in the 2060s.

MORE: Millions of British workers are sitting on a six-figure pension lump sum without realising it

Former pensions minister Baroness Altmann said: “Those with no other private pension or savings will face a much bigger drop in spending power than pensioners in all other countries.

“What’s even more shocking is that the Government Actuary says the costs of paying UK state pensions are unaffordable.

“In the past, our low state pensions were supplemented by generous final salary-type pensions from employers, or by an earnings-linked part of the state pension.”

newnanny Mon 12-Feb-18 16:04:38

This sounds grim however it is taking the basic state pension only. Most sensible people will have heeded the advice from government that everyone should contribute to a private pension which they should contribute into throughout their working life and consider the state pension as a top up product. I have throughout my working life made a conscious effort and choice to pay into a private pension which my employer has also paid into and in addition to this to take out a stakeholder pension as well. This has meant less disposable income during working years but will mean I will have a decent but (not generous) pension pot from my 3 separate pots. In addition my mortgage will be repaid by then. It is no good refusing to take personal responsibility during our working lives and then complain we don't have a big pot in retirement. Most people will be working for over 45 years so even if can't contribute much extra when children are small they can make up by contributing extra as they grow up. Personal discipline is needed. We have to consider income tax is higher in many countries. We have low tax so should use disposable income wisely.

Norah Mon 12-Feb-18 16:21:45

newnanny is spot on. Responsibility during earning years to contribute to private pensions.

Nonnie Mon 12-Feb-18 16:21:46

newnanny not everyone is as sensible as you! I have a relation who sold her private pension at the age of 55 so that the state can look after her in old age. The pension freedom now available is, imo, a ticking timebomb as many will do the same. It is easy at 55 to think that by the time your are of state pension age you will be so old you won't need much money but it is a very different situation when you reach that age.

I have a Dutch friend who recently retired. She has sold her house and moved into social housing, a flat. The rent is determined by her income which seems very sensible to me. Her house can now be used by a family so a win win situation.

However, not everything is better there, she will have to do some very clever things with the money from the house because any savings above about £40k are taxable in NL. Also we have much better maternity and paternity leave.

Fennel Mon 12-Feb-18 17:03:45

" Two out of three UK pension schemes are in the red to the tune of £210bn"
I paid into my professional pension scheme when I was working . We used to get regular reports about how our payments were invested - often in oil, minerals etc industries in expanding countries. Such as Africa. Now other bigger nations (eg China) have competed successfully for this income.
I pray thankfully each month when my pension comes in on time.

gillybob Mon 12-Feb-18 17:26:06

I sold my pension too. I put the entire amount ( not that it was much) into help keep my business going and my 7 employees in a job . I wish people wouldn’t be so judgemental . I didn’t see a penny of it for myself . Oh and I will probably be working until I drop dead . State pension at 68 which will mean I will have worked for 52 years !

starbird Mon 12-Feb-18 17:38:35

The new UK state pension is £159. 55 a week, for those on the old one if they qualify, they will get pension credit which would top it up to that level.

I would love to know how these other countries can afford to pay so much - where do they get the money from?

Our population is barely replacing itself. The figures don’t add up to support the number of pensioners there are going to be, let alone the health service, carers etc.

The worst thing the govt did was to allow people to spend all of their pension pots - I think it was a cynical way to boost the economy with consumer spending.

Nonnie Mon 12-Feb-18 17:41:22

Sorry Gily if you think I was being judgmental, perhaps I should have given more detail. The person concerned did not spend it on anything as good as you did, it was frittered away and the point I was making was that it was a deliberate act so that they would get more from the government when they were older.

Norah Mon 12-Feb-18 17:44:54

gillybob, selling your pension to keep you business is a smart thing. Never bothering to contribute is what is not wise to me.

Also, I think as years pass in these centuries we are healthier to work longer than when retirement age was lower.

Norah Mon 12-Feb-18 17:47:09

starbird, I think income tax is high to those countries.

Telly Mon 12-Feb-18 17:52:59

I think you will find that many of these countries who pay these pensions have severe financial problems as a country. Equally do they have free healthcare at the point of delivery? I know it's not great but I think without insurance, people are in serious trouble with medical bills in some of these countries. I knew of someone in the US with MS and a heart condition who was in debt to the tune of 100,000 dollars and not a hope of paying it. So pluses and minuses. Equally I wonder how many expect to rely on just the state pension?

Peep Mon 12-Feb-18 18:01:53

I remember reading that in Italy workers contributions to state pension are very much higher than we pay here, that is possibly the case in other countries. I wish when people think that the government can pay for them they would realise that it's the rest of the population that is paying for them through taxation.

mcem Mon 12-Feb-18 18:05:53

Being sensible is one thing but I think of a dear aunt who was just unable to pay into a private pension and in retirement relied on her state pension and help with rent for her council flat. All her life she worked hard in low-paid catering jobs. The rest of my family has been more fortunate as well as sensible and we do have pension income apart from DWP.
Gilly pointed out a different but equally difficult scenario so perhaps we should be a bit less ready to condemn.

MissAdventure Mon 12-Feb-18 18:07:53

I'll probably be on just the basic pension. My work record has been somewhat patchy in the last few years.

Norah Mon 12-Feb-18 18:17:49

mcem, you are right, no condemnation is helpful.

Preparing to work many more years. Taking as much personal responsibility as possible. Not wasting income available to save on splurge spending would be helpful choices.

MissAdventure Mon 12-Feb-18 18:19:50

They haven't helped me.

TwiceAsNice Mon 12-Feb-18 18:44:11

I paid into 2 pensions when working but as I worked in the public sector and didn't earn a high salary after tax when combined they only pay out £328 a month . I claim my state pension as well but I still have to work part time as all my earnings come to less than £1000 a month and three quarters of that goes on bills so I'll have to keep working or I wouldn't survive. Having worked hard all my life it doesn't work out as a luxurious retirement ( or in my case part retirement) at all.

Jalima1108 Mon 12-Feb-18 19:40:31

How are these pensions funded in other countries?
I would like to know a lot more before I could judge.

In Australia the state pension is means-tested so if your assets or income are above a certain amount, it reduces pro rata until at a certain level you get nothing.
However, for those with no other income and no assets, the pension rate would seem to be generous by UK standards.

marpau Mon 12-Feb-18 20:25:28

The state pension of £159.55 is only payable if you have a full 46 years contributions a reduction is made for any missing years

MissAdventure Mon 12-Feb-18 20:29:06

I shall have to turn to a life of crime, I think.

gillybob Mon 12-Feb-18 20:32:34

My DH had 49 years but was robbed by SERPS contributions that have been stolen!

gillybob Mon 12-Feb-18 20:33:35

I’ll be your “look out” missadventure

MissAdventure Mon 12-Feb-18 20:36:13

Thanks gilly I haven't decided what crime i'll commit yet. I need to see a crime advisor I think. grin

gillybob Mon 12-Feb-18 20:39:43

I was thinking maybe pulling off a massive fraud.... there’s plenty seem to get away with it wink

Chewbacca Mon 12-Feb-18 20:45:31

I know just how your DH must be feeling gillybob. I too contributed to SERPS for mnay years. Nowhere to be seen now so that was a waste of money.