Gransnet forums

Menopause

Ladies who decided not to take HRT...how has it been?

(107 Posts)
Lia173 Thu 09-Jan-25 19:43:01

Hello all. I'm new here and interested to hear from ladies who have gone through the menopause without HRT. I'm 52 and have had about 4 periods over the last 2 years. I feel I've lost my 'verve' a little and I am having sleep trouble. It's not too bad but I could use a pick me up! I don't really want to take hormones if possible. A lot of people in my family having had cancer is one of the reasons. To come to the point, I have a young son and basically want to try and stay as healthy as possible for as long as possible...don't we all. I feel there is a push to take hrt as it will keep you younger / fitter / stronger etc as well as alleviate symptoms of menopause. I am aware of the benefits but reading forums, it can come across that you'll age so much worse if you dont take it. I'm really interested in hearing from those who are past menopause and didn't take hrt. Have you stayed fit? Do you feel healthy and strong? Did you feel better post menopause? Also, have any alternatives to HRT helped. I am aware that the risks of taking / not taking HRT are different for individuals but just really interested in the experiences of those who haven't taken it. Thanks!

nanna8 Sat 11-Jan-25 00:59:46

I was told there was a link between that and cancer so I never took it. I had an early menopause in my early 40 s and just coped with hot flushes etc. The worst thing for me was a tendency to overthink things and worry about trivia.

Grammaretto Sat 11-Jan-25 01:06:58

I refused HRT as I had rejected contraceptive pills I did have 4 babies
I wanted to be as natural as possible.
My periods were always heavy and the best thing ever was when they stopped when aged about 52.

However I developed a prolapse and had a hysterectomy to cure that. I had never been told the advantages of HRT. Later when prolapse symptoms returned I was prescribed oestrogen cream which I still use.

So as a wrinkly at 76, yr old, I have a form of HRT.

Annoyingly, my friend aged 80, had the HRT, is superfit and looks about 60.

Good luck whatever you decide.

BlueBelle Sat 11-Jan-25 06:48:54

I never even knew I’d had the menopause apart from my periods stopped mid 40s I never had any problems at all I don’t know what a hot flush is Neither of my daughters had any trouble either like me they just stopped None of us took HRT

BlueBelle Sat 11-Jan-25 06:51:39

I should add I didn’t decide to NOT use HRT it just didn’t enter my life as I had no problems

Grammaretto Sat 11-Jan-25 07:02:46

One of my DDiL suffers greatly from menopausal symptoms which is sad.
I don't think there's a lot of sympathy in the workplace.

It's not called the change or the change of life for nothing.

You are entering a new stage which is not all bad Lia. Embrace it if you can!

Allsorts Sat 11-Jan-25 07:16:30

We just got on with it, like the very heavy periods and pains when young, we talked between each other but got on with it, you would never take time off work or visit a doctor,

Bellasnana Sat 11-Jan-25 07:32:56

Both my sisters died relatively young from breast cancer so I had already made up my mind that I wouldn’t be taking HRT. As it happened, I didn’t need it as my periods were regular until they just stopped when I was 55. No hot flushes, thankfully, just terrible insomnia for a couple of years but that was it. I know others who suffer terribly and for them HRT has been a blessing.

Sara1954 Sat 11-Jan-25 07:58:19

I always planned to take it, my dear friend, older than me swore by it, and I wanted to stay as young as possible for as long as possible.

But like some of the ladies above, my periods just literally stopped, never had a hot flush, or any other symptom, so I didn’t think I could justify it.

I am 70 now, still working, helping with my grandchildren, infact doing pretty much everything I did when I was fifty.

Of course if I’d taken it I might look ten years younger, but I’ll never know.

AGAA4 Sat 11-Jan-25 09:33:16

I didn't take HRT and didn't really notice my menopause. I had few symptoms, only irregular periods for a while before they stopped completely.

Maggiemaybe Sat 11-Jan-25 10:28:09

I had no menopause symptoms at all other than my periods stopping, so I never thought to ask for it and was never offered it. I’m fit and well apart from some osteopenia, for which I take daily calcium tablets. Whether this would have been prevented by taking HRT, I’ll never know. If I’d needed it, I wouldn’t have hesitated - the menopause can be dreadful and it’s been a life saver for some.

There used to be some horrendous scaremongering on any HRT thread from a couple of posters who thought they were so much better than the wizened old crones who didn’t use it. I’m glad to see posters are more supportive now.

jusnoneed Sat 11-Jan-25 11:00:14

I started menopause in my mid 30's, never took anything. I carried on having hot flushes for years (probably my OH would say mood swings!) but nothing that I noticed apart from them.

OldFrill Sat 11-Jan-25 11:16:36

If the benefits of HRT are to be believed you'd be foolish not to take it as early as possible. But are they believable? Only time will tell if osteoporosis, dementia and heart disease etc rates drop significantly as women on HRT age.

Romola Sat 11-Jan-25 13:59:30

Lots of good advice here. I just wanted to say, if you do get annoying menopausal symptoms, I know that HRT can be a great help. I'm certainly not against it.
(I have noticed that women with younger husbands/partners do put more effort into keeping a youthful look. HRT does seem to help.)

silverlining48 Sat 11-Jan-25 14:20:14

I never considered hrt as menopause wasn’t a problem and apart from a bit if flushing and some bleeding a year or two later I was ok.
I only know one person who took hrt, only briefly.

Ilovedogs22 Sat 11-Jan-25 14:23:09

I wasn't allowed to take HRT because I had high levels of oestrogen which had caused breast cancer (told my husband I was too womanly.)
The hot flushes were a faffing nuisance, together with just more than the usual rattycow mood- swings.
I do worry about my bones though, which HRT is said to protect.
To be be honest I'm a bit ratty & jealous of those who can take it!
Especially my irritating, big- headed tarty sister! 🙄

Lia173 Sat 11-Jan-25 18:47:20

Ilovedogs22

I wasn't allowed to take HRT because I had high levels of oestrogen which had caused breast cancer (told my husband I was too womanly.)
The hot flushes were a faffing nuisance, together with just more than the usual rattycow mood- swings.
I do worry about my bones though, which HRT is said to protect.
To be be honest I'm a bit ratty & jealous of those who can take it!
Especially my irritating, big- headed tarty sister! 🙄

Hope all is good now. The comment about your sister made me laugh 😃.

Jaxjacky Sat 11-Jan-25 18:52:48

Romola my husband is seven years younger than me, I didn’t take HRT, 18 years later he’s still here!
I had few symptoms other than my periods stopping.

Ilovedogs22 Sat 11-Jan-25 19:50:06

nanna8

I was told there was a link between that and cancer so I never took it. I had an early menopause in my early 40 s and just coped with hot flushes etc. The worst thing for me was a tendency to overthink things and worry about trivia.

Yes, yes nanna8, I too found that the menopause made me extremely nervous & anxious.
I was (still am!) extremely tense & wittily, which I wasn't previously!
I began to get very stressed about travelling too. The hot flushes I can cope with it's the anxiety that's the problemo for me It just doesn't stop.

Lia173 Sat 11-Jan-25 20:39:33

Romola

Lots of good advice here. I just wanted to say, if you do get annoying menopausal symptoms, I know that HRT can be a great help. I'm certainly not against it.
(I have noticed that women with younger husbands/partners do put more effort into keeping a youthful look. HRT does seem to help.)

I think my symptoms are not too bad at the minute, apart from the lack of sleep, energy and mild anxiety. I've had those symptoms before without being menopausal! I do wonder if I'm missing a trick with staying youthful though as the opinion it keeps you looking younger does come up a bit. I guess it makes sense too. I met my friend who is turning 60 the other day and she doesn't take hrt and looks at least 10 years younger so there's hope smile. She recommended bone broth I will give that a go.

Lia173 Sat 11-Jan-25 20:40:59

Jaxjacky

Romola my husband is seven years younger than me, I didn’t take HRT, 18 years later he’s still here!
I had few symptoms other than my periods stopping.

Good to hear 😊

Dempie55 Sat 11-Jan-25 21:06:35

I’m 69. Started HRT in my late 40s, but only took it for about 6 months, didn’t feel “right” while on it, and husband said it was affecting my personality- severe outbursts of anger! (Whether this was the menopause or the HRT, I will never know.) Anyway, stopped taking it and went down the route of high dosages of Evening Primrose Oil and Black Cohosh. Also remember some sort of hormone cream which I rubbed in! Symptoms calmed down, periods finally stopped at 56!

V3ra Sat 11-Jan-25 23:50:05

My Mum developed osteoporosis, apparently caused by her oestrogen levels dropping during the menopause.
She was put on HRT and told to warn her daughters they would need to take it as well.
Mum then developed breast cancer and had a mastectomy.
She was taken off the HRT.
Later she developed Alzheimer's, which she died with.

(Along with all this she also developed diabetes, which my sister had warned her had been identified as a risk factor for the blood pressure tablets they both took).

Neither my sister nor I have taken HRT.

NotSpaghetti Sat 11-Jan-25 23:59:34

I also "sailed through" az someone else said. My youngest daughter who was a teenager at the time says I was a bit "up - and - down" though.
I say I admit that I may have been up and down but then she was the fourth of five teenagers so I may have just been dealing with my teenagers!

I previously had years of very heavy and very long but not particularly uncomfortable periods (since a teenager). I did have a several weeks of bleed in the menopause which was not fun to deal with but was stopped with tranexamic acid. I suppose if I'd asked for help sooner it would have been stopped sooner!

I developed a liking of soya milk during the menopause so maybe I was benefiting in some way from the phytoestrogen.

Hope this helps.

Lia173 Sun 12-Jan-25 19:34:59

V3ra

My Mum developed osteoporosis, apparently caused by her oestrogen levels dropping during the menopause.
She was put on HRT and told to warn her daughters they would need to take it as well.
Mum then developed breast cancer and had a mastectomy.
She was taken off the HRT.
Later she developed Alzheimer's, which she died with.

(Along with all this she also developed diabetes, which my sister had warned her had been identified as a risk factor for the blood pressure tablets they both took).

Neither my sister nor I have taken HRT.

Sorry to hear all your mum went through V3ra flowers. You just never know what to do for the best do you? That's why I started thread as I've read so much about the benefits of hrt in relation to certain conditions, you wonder if they outweigh the risks. Life really is a lottery sometimes but we can just do our best.

Lia173 Sun 12-Jan-25 19:36:44

NotSpaghetti

I also "sailed through" az someone else said. My youngest daughter who was a teenager at the time says I was a bit "up - and - down" though.
I say I admit that I may have been up and down but then she was the fourth of five teenagers so I may have just been dealing with my teenagers!

I previously had years of very heavy and very long but not particularly uncomfortable periods (since a teenager). I did have a several weeks of bleed in the menopause which was not fun to deal with but was stopped with tranexamic acid. I suppose if I'd asked for help sooner it would have been stopped sooner!

I developed a liking of soya milk during the menopause so maybe I was benefiting in some way from the phytoestrogen.

Hope this helps.

One teenager is enough to send you up and down! 😁. Your post is helpful, thanks.