Gransnet forums

News & politics

Would this be your reaction?

(29 Posts)
petra Sat 14-Sept-13 21:38:27

Just been reading the story in the news about the 17yr old who has left home to live with his ex Teacher.
The Mothers reaction was that her and her family's life was over and so was her son's.
I agree it was wrong of the teacher to have sex with one of her pupils. But the Mother should surely have seen it for what it was/is. He was 17 with raging hormones. I asked my OH what he would have done if a young pretty teacher had come on to him. He said he would have done what any 17 yr old would do.
If she really thinks that this is the worst that can happen, she has led a very charmed life.

Eloethan Sun 15-Sept-13 19:08:48

Though the age of the boy is a major issue, another aspect is that a teacher is in a position of authority over her/his pupils, and to embark on a sexual relationship with someone who is under one's authority is an abuse of power. There will no doubt be plenty of nudge nudge wink wink jokes made about this but I see it as no more acceptable for a pretty young female teacher to have a sexual relationship with a male pupil than it is for a handsome young male teacher to have a sexual relationship with a female pupil.

I agree with other posters, though, that the mother seems unduly hysterical about it, and publicly airing her own grievances in such a hysterical manner doesn't seem to me to be the best way to support her son. On top of no doubt feeling embarrassed about the exposure of this relationship in the media, this young man may now feel that he is partially responsible for "ruining" his parents' lives.

FlicketyB Sun 15-Sept-13 20:03:36

The knowing what people should or should not do comes before they fall in love. When I was young I consciously avoided getting too close to anyone where I could see the relationship would cause problems. Teachers known what the rules - and the temptations are, so they should be in a position where they can protect themselves from inappropriate emotional involvements with pupils.

Penstemmon Sun 15-Sept-13 20:13:17

I think there is always a space of time when it is possible to pull back and put the brakes on any relationship. Especially in a school setting! Even if a line has been crossed on a Monday you can say no on Tuesday!