Gransnet forums

News & politics

Jeremy Clarkson

(689 Posts)
merlotgran Wed 11-Mar-15 13:35:59

Quite rightly he's being suspended but should the BBC be cancelling episodes of Top Gear?

If a man working in a factory punches a colleague he would probably be sacked but I doubt they'd remove the product he was making from the shelves.

Ana Fri 10-Apr-15 10:15:13

Well, it looks as though Clarkson has pulled out of presenting HIGNFY after all!

soontobe Fri 10-Apr-15 12:38:57

From what little I have read, it sounds to me like he is man in a bit of a personal crisis. Some of it of his own making.
I suspect that he is actually going through some suffering.
Unless a person makes some apologies, personal or otherwise, I always think that they then end up carrying around a burden.
If you dont apologise, you cant get over what you have done.
Has he apologised to anyone? I dont remember seeing that he has.

Jane10 Fri 10-Apr-15 12:52:34

He went round to that guys house to apologise but apparently wasn't let in. Don't know more than that.

Eloethan Fri 10-Apr-15 13:00:49

Even if JC is experiencing a personal crisis, I doubt that he is suffering as much as the young producer who said that it had been the worst few weeks of his life - he having received much abuse and some death threats.

Meanwhile, JC has painted himself as a "victim" who has been unfairly treated by the BBC, has received huge support from the general public and more offers of work, and the police say that because their policy on charging is victim-led and the producer was unwilling to make a complaint (who could blame him in the circumstances) no further action will be taken.

soontobe Fri 10-Apr-15 13:19:03

Victims often dont have enough courage.

NanKate Fri 10-Apr-15 13:58:17

I read a sad letter in the paper recently about a fan of JC who was in his latter years. He saw JC in a pub and went up to say how he loved the show and how he found his advice on different cars very useful. However one of JC's reviews of a car this old gentleman did not agree with.

At this point JC got very narked at having his opinion questioned. He said something to the effect 'Go away little man I don't give a f* what you think'.

The man was devastated and would never discuss the incident with his family.

I know it must be annoying for celebrities to be spoken to when they are off duty, however this the price of fame.

Years ago I stopped Rudolph Nureyev in the street, he couldn't have been more charming. Perhaps JC needs to learn a little humility.

granjura Fri 10-Apr-15 14:20:06

The police should take action when the facts are clear and the victim has been subjected to intimidation and even death threats- it is clear the producer is not pressing charges due to said intimidation!

So now JC thinks he can play cat and mouse with the BBC too. Must say that does not surprise me. I sincerely hope they never ever give him another chance to return and play his stupid narcissic, games.

Soutra Fri 10-Apr-15 14:26:10

Jeremy Clarkson a victim? Now I have heard everything!! grin
#rudeuphimselfoverpaidgit

soontobe Fri 10-Apr-15 14:31:56

The police should take action when the facts are clear and the victim has been subjected to intimidation and even death threats- it is clear the producer is not pressing charges due to said intimidation

hmm. Tricky. Do they ever? Could they?
Without the main witness. And without someone's permission?

granjura Fri 10-Apr-15 15:50:31

Soutra, hmmm, no Clarkson is DEFO NOT THE VICTIM here- it is the other guy that has received death threats and more! The police cannot force him to, but they can certainly give him encouragement and support- and there were witnesses, including the person who pulled him off to stop the assault- which could have been a lot more serious had he not been stopped, as he had 'totally lost it'.

Eloethan Fri 10-Apr-15 17:39:38

In the case of domestic violence, where it is thought that the injured person may be reluctant to press charges for fear of repercussions, a charge can be brought without the victim requesting it, provided there is thought to be sufficient evidence.

Surely the same should apply to a non-domestic situation where there is strong evidence that a person has been verbally and physically abused? Or does the police's decision not to bring charges arise because they know that, in a high profile case such as this, they will not have the ability to protect the victim from further threats and intimidation?

I suppose, though, that the young man in question just wants to try and get his life (and career) back to some sort of normality, and perhaps the police are reluctant to put him under what would undoubtedly be even more pressure.

It is saddening to me to see such a significant number of the British public rushing to a bully's defence - and yet worthy causes often have difficulty in generating any interest or support.

granjura Fri 10-Apr-15 17:55:59

My thoughts exactly Eloethan- why do so many people cheer for the violent bully? It is beyond me. Surely the fact they like his programme or some of his jokes or thinking on some issues - should be totally irrelevant? Do we say it is OK for a rapist to rape, because he is good at scoring goals for your local team? Just don't get it. I thought the days when violent bullies were loudly cheered were long gone- how sad it is to see they are not sad especially when the cheers come from intelligent people you normally respect.

granjura Fri 10-Apr-15 18:43:53

And some of those people bitterly complain about fat cats and bankers, etc, and yet don't seem do be concerned but this obscenity:

Mr Clarkson was paid £8.4million for his stake in a joint venture with BBC Worldwide which exploits Top Gear's global brand, on top of a £4.86million divident payment. He was also paid £1million for his salary as a presenter.

bibibetti Thu 07-May-15 21:58:24

Good riddance to show of .

granjura Tue 23-Jun-15 19:00:20

Drives me mad- so he was sacked for violent behaviour- and now the Beep is advertising every few hours the return of Top Gear on BB2.

I mean, how on earth do they get away with that. The hypocrisy and stupidity of it all drive me bonkers!

granjura Tue 23-Jun-15 19:01:12

and how much is he being paid now???

Ana Tue 23-Jun-15 19:03:59

What are you on about? Clarkson hasn't been re-employed to front top Gear. Chris Evans is presenting the new series.

jinglbellsfrocks Tue 23-Jun-15 19:06:02

Apparently the Beeb sounded him out on returning to Top Gear but he wouldn't. He was too disgusted with being compared to Jimmy Saville.

He's got a new motoring show in the pipeline. Don't know which channel.

jinglbellsfrocks Tue 23-Jun-15 19:06:42

I think it's funny how they are showing the repeats. Not exactly principled are they? grin

granjura Tue 23-Jun-15 19:14:54

Oh I see, repeats, thanks- could not quite understand what was going on!

Yep- totally wrong imho- repeats or not sad

Jane10 Tue 23-Jun-15 19:25:41

They're not repeats they're the ones recorded prior to the 'incident'. Too expensive to throw away.

Ana Tue 23-Jun-15 19:28:52

The BBC denies that they even considered having him back, though.

Who knows what the truth of it is...? hmm

jinglbellsfrocks Tue 23-Jun-15 19:30:39

Oh! Sorry. Thanks Jane. Yes, can understand they have to be shown.

granjura Tue 23-Jun-15 19:40:30

still glorifying him after saking him- so wrong I feel.

merlotgran Tue 23-Jun-15 19:44:15

They're advertising an up and coming programme which has already been made with license fee payers' money.

That's all.