Gransnet forums

News & politics

Were you offended?

(610 Posts)
petra Thu 30-Jul-15 20:15:02

When David Cameron used the word 'swarm' in relation the the migrants in Calais.
The media are doing their best to make me think that I should be. I keep thinking about it, and I'm not.

soontobe Fri 31-Jul-15 12:53:42

I will leave Eloethan to answer your question Ana.

Ana Fri 31-Jul-15 12:55:53

hmm

FarNorth Fri 31-Jul-15 13:07:28

I think that whenever the word swarm is used, whether insects, people, anything else, it means that those in the swarm are being regarded as a mass.

I happened to look at a globe of the world this morning, though, (yes, really) and was struck again by how very tiny the UK is.
We don't have room for huge numbers of incomers but clearly something needs to be done other than just putting up the barricades.

whitewave Fri 31-Jul-15 13:11:49

If the EU would get it's act together and make a solid joint decision about all these souls we could perhaps have a handle on managing the situation.

jinglbellsfrocks Fri 31-Jul-15 13:14:32

It was the context he used the word in that was unfortunate. I'm not sure whether it was through carelessness or by design. I think it could have been the latter. He wants to get support for his negotiations in the EU. Not a good way to go about it if that was the case. We don't want a lot of immigrant hatred being encouraged. And I am a Tory supporter.

Sometimes I think DC is simply the best of a bad bunch.

jinglbellsfrocks Fri 31-Jul-15 13:17:30

We need to get their own countries into a better state. And that means more foreign aid for governments that are do-operative, and troops and bombing for those that are not. But who really wants to go down that road?

jinglbellsfrocks Fri 31-Jul-15 13:19:45

The offence lies in over-magnifying the numbers by the use of the word. Scaremongering in other words.

Elegran Fri 31-Jul-15 13:43:44

A swarm of bees are trying to find a new home. That is exactly what this swarm of people are doing, so it is a far more appropriate word than some people seem to think.

What a storm in a teacup!

Anniebach Fri 31-Jul-15 13:43:48

We have men bombing Syria with the Americans - after parliament voted against bombing Syria - and some of these asylum seekers are from the very country we are bombing . We bombed Afghanistan and there are asylum seekers from there too

FarNorth Fri 31-Jul-15 13:45:03

Well said jbf.

Anniebach Fri 31-Jul-15 13:45:15

Bees are not human beings though

Eloethan Fri 31-Jul-15 13:59:14

No one in my family is or has been an asylum seeker (at least, not so far as I am aware).

I don't think terms that are generally used to describe insects should be used to describe people, particularly in this context. Swarms of insects are often seen as a threat and something to be afraid of, and to link that sort of imagery to this situation is, I feel, wrong.

jinglbellsfrocks Fri 31-Jul-15 14:03:16

interesting article here from BBC News.

Eloethan Fri 31-Jul-15 14:07:59

petra Your last post said "I had a feeling in my water that this would happen. I'm sure some of you will understand to what I refer."

Who are the "some of you" to whom you are referring and what exactly are you getting at? If you don't like some people's responses, then don't ask the question.

nigglynellie Fri 31-Jul-15 15:05:36

Any dictionary you care to consult for a definition of the word swarm will, among others, refer to a gathering of people in large numbers whoever they are and wherever they may be. It is not a derogatory term for any particular group of people and never has been. It's a perfectly acceptable expression to use in the relevant context and doesn't have different connotations in different parts of the UK. To try and pretend that this is the case as a stick to beat the prime minister is blatantly absurd, and smacks of desperation by those who clearly know better. Bearing in mind the seriousness of the immigration situation these people should be ashamed of themselves at this deliberate attempt to stir up trouble over something completely irrelevant at such a difficult time when the country is beset by such an enormous problem. Offering ideas for a solution would be more helpful instead of this pathetic bleating.

petra Fri 31-Jul-15 15:30:22

Eloethan. My post was not meant as you seem to think.
I have sent you a PM to explain.

thatbags Fri 31-Jul-15 15:35:24

Anyone who doesn't want to use the word swarm of people because they think it is wrong to do so don't have to use it. What they do have to do is tolerate its use by people who don't think it's wrong to use the word of people. It really is that simple. There is no absolute right or wrong on this. It's a choice, a preference. That's all.

swarm
swɔːm/
noun
noun: swarm; plural noun: swarms
1.
a large or dense group of flying insects.
"a swarm of locusts"
a large number of honeybees that leave a hive en masse with a newly fertilized queen in order to establish a new colony.
synonyms:hive, flight, flock, covey
"a swarm of bees"
a large number of people or things
"a swarm of journalists"
synonyms:crowd, multitude, horde, host, mob, gang, throng, stream, mass, body, band, army, troop, legion, flock, herd, pack, drove, sea, array, myriad, pile; More
a series of similar-sized earthquakes occurring together, typically near a volcano.
ASTRONOMY
a large number of minor celestial objects occurring together in space, especially a dense shower of meteors.
verb
verb: swarm; 3rd person present: swarms; past tense: swarmed; past participle: swarmed; gerund or present participle: swarming
1.
(of flying insects) move in or form a swarm.
"swarming locusts"
(of honeybees, ants, or termites) issue from the nest in large numbers in order to mate and found new colonies.
"the bees had swarmed and left the hive"
2.
move somewhere in large numbers.
"protesters were swarming into the building"
synonyms:flock, crowd, throng, stream, surge, flood, seethe, pack, crush
"reporters and photographers were swarming all over the place"
be crowded or overrun with (moving people or things).
"the place was swarming with police"
synonyms:be crowded with, be thronged with, be overrun with, be full of, abound in, be teeming with, be bristling with, bristle with, be alive with, be crawling with, be infested with, overflow with, brim with, be prolific in, be abundant in; More

thatbags Fri 31-Jul-15 15:38:31

I think it is lack of tolerance that drives all the offendedness that one hears about nowadays. Intolerance, pure and simple. And not nice.

TerriBull Fri 31-Jul-15 15:43:12

I accept Soontobe's comment that she hadn't heard the expression before, although I'm surprised because I thought it was pretty commonplace, but nevertheless there have been occasions when I have heard individuals state they are not au fait with sayings that are well used.

"Swarming", teeming, heaving would certainly be terms I would use to describe the sheer volume of people feeding in and out of the London underground system at rush hour. Maybe these expressions resonate with those of us who live in or near heavily populated areas and commuters have often been compared to say ants. Most would know the analogy being made is all about repetitious movement which personifies not only some species of insects but also people going about their daily rituals. I don't think the inference of the word "swarming" suggests that any mass of people are synonymous with a large number of insects.

An over analysis of an everyday expression.

Elegran Fri 31-Jul-15 16:01:00

Tolerance is in short supply recently. There are so many campaigns to draw attention to "real offensive behaviour and expressions that sometimes people get over-enthusiastic in taking offence unnecessarily.

Slightly off-topic, but relevant - the original meaning of "enthusiastic" was not the same as it is now used. It meant fanatical obsession, to the point of madness, from the Greek word ἐνθουσιασμός , from ἐν and θεός and ουσία, meaning possessed by god's essence, applied by the Greeks to manifestations of divine possession, by Apollo (as in the case of the Pythia), or by Dionysus (as in the case of the Bacchantes and Maenads) Some of those enthusiatically espousing being offended are fanatically obsessed.

Elegran Fri 31-Jul-15 16:01:34

Should have typed real

petra Fri 31-Jul-15 16:11:54

And now we have the reporter who asked 3 black asylum seekers "Are you going back to the jungle" being pilloried.
The jungle is the name of the camp in Calais, for those who have never heard the term.

Anniebach Fri 31-Jul-15 16:21:35

Who named the camp - the jungle ?

Eloethan Fri 31-Jul-15 16:33:02

Good point Anniebach.

Gracesgran Fri 31-Jul-15 16:59:26

Of those who had a negative view - and of course I may have missed some - I thought it was careless and JBF thought it was unfortunate in this context. I would hardly call that "a lack of tolerance". However, the rest of the four pages haranguing those who think it was not the best choice of words in the circumstances could well come into the "lack of tolerance" category.

I can't remember who referred to "droning on" but I would think that has more to do with bagpipes than bees.