Gransnet forums

News & politics

Channel 4 Dispatches - Momentum Party

(513 Posts)
POGS Mon 19-Sept-16 21:58:40

Well that was interesting. I should say Panarama was also enlightening but not as forceful and uncompromisingly direct in it's reporting content as Dispatches.

I'm not going to simply post on the Lib Dem Thread which has turned into a Labour Thread as I think this programme summed up exactly what I have thought and have been posting since the formation of Momentum , it is a ' Party within a Party.'

I will say now to those who will see it as propaganda and take umbrage at my post you cannot argue with what you see and hear from the horses mouth, no matter how hard you might try and no doubt will.

The fact Momentum are doing all they can to play down the Momentum name in connection to the ' Jeremy for Labour ' Campaign , the use of the Unite Union office are significant, the way the reporter was paid is serious stuff and I hope there is further investigation into that. Will anybody take it up I wonder?.

Has anybody 'Cicked' on the ' Jeremy for Labour ' Campaign or answered questions on the phone in connection with it. The reason I ask is if you have you are, as I understood it, on the data base on the Jeremy For Labour Services?. Listen to what is said about it , you may not be too happy, or maybe you will of course.

There is to be fair a Momentum explanation and statement at the end of the programme but it is worth viewing to make your own mind up if you didn't catch it.

Anniebach Mon 26-Sept-16 15:42:37

I repeat - I do not have ALL the answers but I do have experience of canvassing in constituencies which are considered target seats and I know the responses when asking for their vote . I also live in a constituency which was labour for many years, untill the boundary changes, since it has gone then Tory, Libs , Tories, Libs, it is now Tory . I think next time it will go lib, some labour members have left the party and are goIng lib .

If anyone wants the views of voters get out into Tory and Lib marginals , best not to accuse the voter of ranting if they don't fall to their knees at the mention of the name Corbyn

There is also the threat of UKIP

Anniebach Mon 26-Sept-16 18:39:11

Corbyn has angered the Welsh Labour Party, he has refused to allow our leader to choose a Welsh person to sit on the NEC . Revenge for not having the support of the Welsh government during the leadership election perhaps, he and Caerwen do not get on anyway

JessM Mon 26-Sept-16 19:09:06

Maybe time to stop stirring it now anniebach and respond to the calls for unity?
I am not aware of anyone in my CLP who has joined momentum. But we do want to stop the squabbling and get on with fighting the tories.

Anniebach Mon 26-Sept-16 19:14:52

Because I speak of the snub to the Welsh .government I am stirring ?

Who mentioned Momentum and the CL P?

Talk of the north of England is permitted but mention Wales and it's stirring

Very controlling, mmmmm

Anniebach Mon 26-Sept-16 19:17:18

Unity? when the only country in the UK which has a labour government isn't allowed to be spoken of

obieone Mon 26-Sept-16 19:29:30

Calls for unity from the group that caused the problem. I know the scenario well.
Next step - there will be calls from them to say that they can be trusted.

And fancy asking Anniebach if she is really a Labour Party member. What a cheeky post.

Anniebach Mon 26-Sept-16 19:33:25

rather amusing Obieone, demanding unity, new definition of democracy ! We demand unity , very Putin

durhamjen Mon 26-Sept-16 19:41:05

The Welsh Labour leader also appeared scornful of suggestions from within Labour in recent months that the party could form electoral pacts with other left-of-centre parties, including Welsh nationalists Plaid Cymru.

“Politics in Wales is not as tribal, because the nature of the Assembly’s electoral system means we have to work with other parties in a way that isn’t really required most of the time in Westminster,” he said, but added: “Electoral pacts are tougher. Who would have an electoral pact with? Making coalitions and arrangements after an election is legitimate. The public would expect parties, if they don’t have a majority, to talk to other parties.”

This is Carwyn Jones talking to Labourlist.

It's quite strange, really, because the only reason he is the leader of the Assembly is because of a pact with Plaid Cymru.

durhamjen Mon 26-Sept-16 19:43:32

'John McDonnell and several Owen-Smith backing Labour figures such as Chuka Umunna have called for party unity.

At last night’s LabourList rally Umunna, former shadow business secretary, emphatically encouraged Labour MPs and members who didn’t support Jeremy Corbyn in the leadership election to stay in the party. Umunna said a split would not solve Labour’s problems. His thoughts were echoed by Wes Streeting MP who said Labour must find a way to come together.'

Can't see the word 'demand' here.

Anniebach Mon 26-Sept-16 19:44:33

The leader of the Welsh government didn't support either Corbyn or Smith in the leadership contest, this is how fair Welsh Labour leader is , seems England could learn from Wales

Anniebach Mon 26-Sept-16 19:46:16

You are breaking new rules speaking of Wales , it's now considered stirring

Anniebach Mon 26-Sept-16 19:49:52

Little englanders yet again

durhamjen Mon 26-Sept-16 19:50:06

Strange new rules. You are allowed to talk of England, but I am not allowed to talk of Wales.
Some of my family live there. They would be most upset if I wasn't allowed to talk to them about politics.

Anniebach Mon 26-Sept-16 19:51:35

English Corbyn supporter new rule

durhamjen Mon 26-Sept-16 19:53:55

Who is a little Englander?
You are getting pathetic now, Annie.

What are you going to do if there is a snap election next year? Corbyn will still be leader.

Are you a closet Labour member, obie?
You seem to know a lot about the party.

durhamjen Mon 26-Sept-16 19:55:27

I am a European, Annie. I am not telling Welsh people they can't talk about other parts of the UK or the EU.

petra Mon 26-Sept-16 20:04:29

"Corbyn will still be leader" true, but will still be leader of the opposition.

durhamjen Mon 26-Sept-16 20:07:53

I was asking Annie if she would go out and knock on doors for the Labour party, knowing he was still the leader. Of course he would still be leader of the opposition. I don't think paarties change in between elections.

Anniebach Mon 26-Sept-16 20:14:13

by asking if I would canvas for any particular party you are realy asking me how I will vote, not the correct way to garner votes, a cavasser asks for support not asks - who are you voting for. Being polite may have become alien to some

grumppa Mon 26-Sept-16 20:22:40

If dj and Anniebach fall out, there is no hope for the Labour Party.

Ana Mon 26-Sept-16 20:26:56

IF...???

Anniebach Mon 26-Sept-16 20:38:43

DJ and I have not fallen out, our posts show how the Labour party is truely divided.

the far left and left of centre at their best - or worse ?

Ana Mon 26-Sept-16 20:44:48

Oh, good to know you and durhamjen haven't fallen out, Annie. It's sometimes hard to tell...

trisher Mon 26-Sept-16 20:49:49

Why when I ask about policies do you fall back on calling Corbyn names Anniebach I am really interested to know what the right wing of the Labour party want to do. Surely if you knocked on my door canvassing you would have a reply ready.

whitewave Mon 26-Sept-16 20:57:21

That is what I am really really interested in knowing, because policies are the bedrock of ant political party.

Can anyone from the Labour Party who would prefer a different leader to Corbyn please explain the differences in the policies each side would support?

This in my view is the most important issue, so I so hope someone can compare and contrast the two.