Gransnet forums

News & politics

A bad day for the world

(851 Posts)
Jane10 Wed 09-Nov-16 05:53:51

Trump. How could all those people vote for him?
Ochone ochone (Gaelic lamentation)

nigglynellie Thu 10-Nov-16 16:17:16

dj, how many more times do people on here who voted for Brexit have to explain themselves? We have on threads going back four months with one explanation on top of another, (yawn!) Is it, in reality, the fact that you and others just will not accept our reasons no matter how much we explain again and again and again and yet again?!! If you want to know our reasons I suggest you re visit these threads and you will find your answer then perhaps you can stop saying that no one has given a valid reasons for their democratic vote which they are (and this bit may surprise you!) actually allowed to demonstrate without fear or favour from anyone.

granjura Thu 10-Nov-16 16:50:17

niggly - she wasn't asking again per se- just comparing the reasons for those who voted Brexit and those who voted for Trump.

Whether you want to see it or not, there are massive parralels between the two votes- and the whole wild world has seen this and is discussing it. As so often- perhaps sometimes it is difficult to see things when you are just too close.

I am fully aware that you don't give a monkey's about what the rest of the world sees or thinks.

Ana Thu 10-Nov-16 17:00:07

^Did you vote Brexit?
What was your real reason?^

Sounds like asking (again) to me.

nigglynellie Thu 10-Nov-16 17:03:29

I'm well aware that you voted purely from a position of self interest as you constantly tell us ad nauseam.

durhamjen Thu 10-Nov-16 17:05:50

I was asking luckylegs, responding to her post.

'Whatever we think personally, America voted for Trump, the way some of you are talking it is as if you don't believe it. That is what the country wanted. Brexit keeps coming up, as if the majority if people didn't for for that either, it is like flogging a dead horse. To keep suggesting that the votes were rascist, everything gets blamed for that, an easy target, it saves looking at the real reasons I suppose, having just one thing to blame instead of trying to sort the real reason out.'

I don't want to know about the rest of you.
You would do better to read a complete thread rather than just pick up on one post. Otherwise I might just think you are following me round again, Ana and niggly.

rosesarered Thu 10-Nov-16 17:07:58

oh give it a rest djen

Ana Thu 10-Nov-16 17:09:32

Don't flatter yourself durhamjen, I've been following the thread, certainly not you!

durhamjen Thu 10-Nov-16 17:09:42

I have a copy of the i in front of me.
58% of whites voted for Trump; 37% for Clinton.
8% of African Americans voted for Trump; 88% for Clinton
29% of Latinos voted for Trump; 65% for Clinton
29% of Asians voted for Trump; 65% for Clinton.

I think the voters saw racism in Trump.

rosesarered Thu 10-Nov-16 17:10:12

Brexit and sovereignty issues are nothing like voters in the US choosing Trump as President.

Ana Thu 10-Nov-16 17:16:51

Quite. Although I expect the usual line will be trotted out again by someone soon...(all those who voted to Leave may not be etc. etc...)

rosesarered Thu 10-Nov-16 17:18:30

grin yes...if only I could put money on it.

durhamjen Thu 10-Nov-16 17:24:16

So why criticise me? Why not realise who and why I was asking?

durhamjen Thu 10-Nov-16 17:25:01

Trump said it was Brexit +++

Ana Thu 10-Nov-16 17:26:54

Trump said what was Brexit?

rosesarered Thu 10-Nov-16 17:36:51

Trump says a lot of things, most of them idiotic.

nigglynellie Thu 10-Nov-16 17:39:20

Trouble is that democracy for some is only applicable when it works for you, and completely inexplicable and probably inappropriate when it doesn't!! Perhaps certain white people shouldn't have been allowed to vote in the U.S? That should have solved the problem, but sadly not democratic however you look at it!!!

rosesarered Thu 10-Nov-16 17:41:48

exactly, all democtratic votes have to be respected, whether you like them or not.Losing with good grace seems to be a thing of the past.

whitewave Thu 10-Nov-16 17:48:56

I think really rose and ana you sort of miss the point. It isn't the question of refusing to accept the democratic process. The question we are trying to answer is why is the post war democratic liberalism contract being rejected and why is the voter turning to authoritarian reactionary politics with all that implies.

Ana Thu 10-Nov-16 17:53:40

Oh is that the question 'you' are trying to answer? Good luck with that!

TriciaF Thu 10-Nov-16 18:07:51

Exactly, whitewave. A similar change is happening in most of the western world.
In Europe, Brexit plus France, Germany and Hungary, and others, to say nothing of Russia.
Why? That's the big question. I once read that political movements go in waves - from liberal to autocratic, and back again.
It takes many years for the average person to catch up.
I wasn't surprised that Trump won, half expecting it. Grateful that we're in the older generation now and were lucky enough to experience the postwar years when people cared about eachother.

nigglynellie Thu 10-Nov-16 18:12:21

Patronising attitude of the political elite the rich getting richer, at the expense of the poor? resentment, Them and us? could have something to do with it!

Beammeupscottie Thu 10-Nov-16 18:13:19

Could it be that there is antipathy to the educated, articulate liberalism associated with the, often affluent but not always, middle-classes? So people look to a Redeemer who looks strong and fights in their corner and such is the savvy of the Donald.
He is saying F... the Political elite, all you need is a Tycoon leader and you can be as rich as me.

durhamjen Thu 10-Nov-16 18:13:55

Obviously it's a bit too difficult for you to answer, Ana.
Never mind.

MaizieD Thu 10-Nov-16 18:14:32

Trouble is that democracy for some is only applicable when it works for you

There's that old 'some' person again. S/he gets everywhere grin

durhamjen Thu 10-Nov-16 18:16:47

This is a good response.

politics.co.uk/blogs/2016/11/09/trump-is-beyond-politics-this-is-now-a-fight-for-human-decen