Gransnet forums

News & politics

Brexit all done and dusted?

(857 Posts)
Cindersdad Sun 02-Apr-17 16:47:13

As an arch REMOANER I for one (of many) will not simply roll over and say that is that. As things progress at the very least parliament must ensure that the country does not Brexit in a bad way because of "The Will of the People". So many lies were told by both side at the time of referendum that when the full facts come to light a re-think should be considered.

I have yet to hear a sound reason for voting LEAVE. Of course the EU is far from perfect but we are better trying to change it from within than sniping from outside. A general election or second referendum before the point of absolute no return.

I happen to be visiting Brussels on an educational trip after Easter so until then I will put up and shut up unless really provoked.

MawBroon Fri 14-Apr-17 20:45:39

Did anybody suggest you were ?

durhamjen Fri 14-Apr-17 20:46:11

www.opendemocracy.net/neweconomics/its-you-me-or-the-robot-why-are-workers-in-the-food-industry-paid-so-little/

stillaliveandkicking Fri 14-Apr-17 20:47:56

Im just saying that there are many other childcare professions other than nannies.

durhamjen Fri 14-Apr-17 20:50:27

It's a shame you are pleased about cheap labour.
Corbyn wants £10 an hour minimum wage. That will get rid of it.
Everyone should welcome that.

MawBroon Fri 14-Apr-17 20:57:35

Is anybody arguing with youSAAK ?

Ana Fri 14-Apr-17 21:04:43

You know very well that saak was claiming that the upper classes loved the cheap labour - why do you insist on twisting the meaning of others' posts to suit your own agenda?

durhamjen Fri 14-Apr-17 21:08:59

From what I've read, a lot of the cheap labour complained. Did no good because they'd had their passports taken away and would be sent back as illegal immigrants.
Came over with middle eastern families and were treated as slaves.
Is that the sort of childcare you were involved with, saak?
Sort of English person I would be ashamed of.

durhamjen Fri 14-Apr-17 21:17:27

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/apr/13/brexitland-vote-leave-sheffield-brexit-industrial-strategy

MawBroon Fri 14-Apr-17 21:20:42

Was that to me Ana??

Ana Fri 14-Apr-17 21:37:05

No, it was to durhamjen in response to her post of 20.50.

durhamjen Fri 14-Apr-17 21:46:42

They don't love cheap labour - they exploit it, and break the law.
Not the sort of English people I would be proud to be associated with, but others don't mind.

daphnedill Fri 14-Apr-17 22:01:22

By the way, Germany doesn't have a national minimum wage. After the two Germanies reunited, many British building workers were happy enough to be exploited when the German government poured billions into reconstruction in the East. Remember "Auf Wiedersehen Pet?"

Another way of looking at it, was that Germany provided jobs. As the jobs weren't permanent, it meant that Germany could benefit, because the workers could bank their pay and usually returned home to spend it. The workers benefited, because the pay was better than in the UK.

durhamjen Fri 14-Apr-17 22:07:07

It does now. Came in on January 1st 2017.
8.84 euros an hour, but most companies pay far more.

petra Fri 14-Apr-17 22:35:30

Would that be the middle eastern families that you welcome with your love of an 'open border policy' durhamjen

And Corbyn can advocate any rate of pay he wants, it's irrelevant because he will never be in power.

POGS Fri 14-Apr-17 22:40:06

"They don't love cheap labour - they exploit it, and break the law.

Not the sort of English people I would be proud to be associated with, but others don't mind."

Yes and some people are quite happy to 'exploit' those who work for example in illegal hand car washes and don't know or seem to care what wage they earn, if they too are being exploited , what their living standards and accommodation is like etc.etc. Exploitation comes on many levels !

Then there is the European Union Posted Workers Directive which feeds in to the post by nigglynellie at 19.28 .

The posted Workers Directive keeps getting mentioned on threads but conveniently forgotten time and time again. There is a collective memory loss it seems at times.

As for the Corbyn £10 an hour Living Wage it sounds good but it couldn't come into play until 2020 presuming he is still Labour Leader , Labour wins the General Election and there isn't an early General Election called.

Why do I say it sounds good?

The Living Wage will be probably over the next 3 years be getting pretty close to £9/£10 anyway. If a snap General Election was called for arguments sake say in July 2017 and Corbyn won could he follow through on his 'PROMISE' Labour would increase the Living Wage to £10 an hour 'within months of winning the next General Election'?.

I wonder how many businesses would have to shut down or jobs could be lost if that scenario happened.?

durhamjen Fri 14-Apr-17 22:42:26

I never welcome middle eastern families who do not pay their taxes, petra.
Normal, ordinary middle eastern families are welcome, of course, but not those who live in massive mansions in Belgravia, etc., who only come here to cheat the system. Those who exploit workers should be in prison, just like anyone else in this country who breaks the law.

Cunco Fri 14-Apr-17 22:48:59

A recent Parliamentary Committee Report was critical of Parliament, government and Civil Service over their performance during the Referendum campaign, raising issues to be avoided in future Referendum campaigns, if there are any.

www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201617/cmselect/cmpubadm/496/49603.htm

This includes: "The manner of the presentation of government reports, particularly those from the Treasury, and the decision to spend £9.3m on sending a leaflet, advocating a Remain vote, to all UK households, were inappropriate and counterproductive for the Government. While the Government did not support a Leave vote, they nonetheless had a constitutional and public obligation to prepare for both outcomes from the referendum."

Amen to that. There was never any doubt that the government supported Remain and, sadly, the Civil Service were not seen to be impartial.

I would imagine many of the EU Directives and Regulations will be adopted by a post-Brexit Parliament, if it allows us ever to reach post-Brexit. It will also demonstrate just how many EU Regulations and Directives there were that Parliament had never approved previously.

MaizieD Sat 15-Apr-17 14:11:45

EU Parliament seems to have more power than people think it has

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/brexit-eu-parliament-uk-leave-talks-meps-ukip-nigel-farage-european-commission-council-a7680236.html?utm_content=bufferdff78&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter.com&utm_campaign=buffer

(apologies for the massive link)

It is seen in Britain as a mere talking shop. The European Parliament usually makes UK news bulletins only when Nigel Farage hurls insults, Ukip MEPs literally fight among themselves or there’s another row about the Parliament’s costly travelling circus between Brussels and Strasbourg.

Yet the 751-member Parliament will play an important role in shaping Brexit and has the power to vote down any UK-EU deal. Although little-noticed in Britain, its influence has grown and most EU policies are now the subject of “co-decision” by the Parliament and Council of Ministers from member states.

The Parliament is already flexing its muscles over Brexit and taking a harder line than the European Commission, the EU civil service, and the European Council, the 27 national leaders.

durhamjen Sat 15-Apr-17 14:24:06

OLAF is still looking into UKIP fraud. In 2015 one MEP was sentenced to 5 years in prison. Farage and others are being investigated. That's probably why they make a fuss in the EU parliament, to show other MEPs that they are there.

Jalima1108 Sat 15-Apr-17 14:34:11

Olaf? He always seems to be a jolly little snowman

Ah, the other OLAF.

Sorry, on that note I will log off and leave you all to it as Cindersdad appears to have done having given a good stir smile

durhamjen Sat 15-Apr-17 14:38:35

Jolly little snowman is always losing his head. Don't want that to happen with UKIP fraud.

stillaliveandkicking Sat 15-Apr-17 18:18:09

How funny that quite a few people in the actual government were being done for expense fraud and more, even now some in the house of lords pretend to go and claim. I actually think a majority of them are remoaners smile

MaizieD Sat 15-Apr-17 18:24:57

OMG! 'Remoaners' the ultimate insult hmm

Rigby46 Sat 15-Apr-17 18:31:30

* saak* you think or you know? Anyway why let the facts get in the way ?

stillaliveandkicking Sat 15-Apr-17 18:40:42

Do you know otherwise Rigby? Were they all framed?