Gransnet forums

News & politics

Is it too late for a U turn on Brexit or at least watering it down?

(482 Posts)
James2451 Fri 26-May-17 14:12:39

We oldies need to admit we got it wrong about leaving the eu, we are putting our young family members future at risk. Unity is now priority

The deep concerns by commerce, industry & farmers on our economy and hard times ahead should not be lightly dismissed.
The horrors of this week have highlighted the need for much closer unity with our neighbours in Europe. We cannot gamble on a hard Brexit to resolve differences, we need to stop and rethink how we can resolve our differences without the extremism of Brexit. Is it too late or can we save ourselves from a possible disaster? To do otherwise could be taking a gamble we just cannot afford to take on our young families future.

I am not prepared to leave it to Teresa May and trust her hard Brexit colleagues. Therefore I shall not vote for her type of Brexit.

MaizieD Mon 12-Jun-17 15:39:48

Labour's manifesto said it was their priority to retain the benefits of the single market and the customs union, while rejecting 'no deal' as a viable outcome of the negotiations

Yes, but as many have pointed out on twitter, Labour reject freedom of movement and the EU wouldn't let us have the single market and the customs union without it.

Jalima1108 Mon 12-Jun-17 15:40:57

But he can't assume from that that people were voting for a hard Brexit.

I still don't understand why more people didn't vote Lib Dem.

whitewave Mon 12-Jun-17 15:42:16

dj did you see Alastier Campbell talking about the failure that will be Brexit and Britain becoming a first world failed state?

MaizieD Mon 12-Jun-17 15:44:52

Lib Dems had a much higher hill to climb than did Labour. It would have been a true miracle if they'd managed to surmount that.

whitewave Mon 12-Jun-17 15:48:29

Also Guardian report that Tom Watson is asking No 10 if there is any truth in the rumour that Gove only got his job at Murdochs insistence?

Environment eh - bloody nightmare

whitewave Mon 12-Jun-17 15:49:16

jalima its called tactical voting and worked!!

durhamjen Mon 12-Jun-17 15:57:12

Just shows how stupid David Davis is, then, maizie.
Fancy assuming that everyone who voted Labour and Tory voted for his form of Brexit. It was probably only ten per cent!

whitewave Mon 12-Jun-17 15:57:26

MN report in Guardian which states the EU has said if May insists on running with the divorce and trade in tandem will mean that Brexit will delayed for. Up to a year.

Apparently the EU has been secretly briefing No 10 for months about their stance so that the UK could get its ducks in line.

But they are still in chaos without a plan

daphnedill Mon 12-Jun-17 15:58:54

I'm a LibDem member, so maybe I shouldn't write this, but I think the LibDems had a poor campaign. Part of the problem for them is that they have no money and don't have rich donors. My local branch apparently has absolutely no money left in the bank. I don't think the media is kind to Tim Farron.

The LDs relied on Brexit in a number of by-elections and local elections, which was a successful strategy, but there were problems in the South West heartlands, because those areas voted Leave. The strategy didn't work well in a general election.

The LDs failed to regain (or lost) seats in Cambridge, Leeds North West and Manchester Withington. All constituencies had previously had good LD MPs and I know something about them. The Labour Party had pro-Remain candidates, who were all honest about their position and promised to campaign for a soft Brexit. In the end, voters were more concerned about austerity and just hoped that Labour would challenge the Conservatives' position on Brexit. They also felt that a Labour MP would have more clout than a LibDem one.

PS. I think the Labour Party still has a problem with Brexit, because their new younger members don't want it, but the older, more traditional voters do (although there is some doubt about that, because some Ukip voters have returned to Labour). If I were a Labour Party strategist, the last thing I would want at the moment would be to be in government. Let the Conservatives make a hash of things and take ownership, then be around to pick up the pieces.

Ironically, the LibDems might get a second referendum/softer Brexit anyway.

durhamjen Mon 12-Jun-17 16:08:33

labourlist.org/2017/06/seb-dance-young-people-turned-out-to-reject-mays-insular-vision-for-britain-now-we-must-offer-them-a-european-future/

Davis had better not count the young in his 80%.

Jane10 Mon 12-Jun-17 17:22:42

daphnedil I think you're quite right. There's no chance of the tories being elected next time. Labour can just sit back and watch developments.

whitewave Mon 12-Jun-17 17:24:13

jane music to my ears smile

GracesGranMK2 Mon 12-Jun-17 17:25:39

The number of nurses applying to the NHS from the EU has fallen by 96% since the referendum - on 46 nurses have applied.

GracesGranMK2 Mon 12-Jun-17 19:37:17

I'm never to sure about petitions or how much good they can do but I do think the Brexit negotiations should be cross party and this is one asking for that.

The Prime Minister, Theresa May
Brexit negotiations should be conducted by a multi-party committee

GracesGranMK2 Mon 12-Jun-17 20:30:54

Survation 10 June

Following the General Election Theresa May should

Resign as Prime Minister 49%
Not resign as Prime Minister 38%

whitewave Mon 12-Jun-17 20:33:46

Yes i saw that gg

I've signed your petitionsmile

daphnedill Mon 12-Jun-17 22:28:16

You've probably seen this before, but it's worth a repeat grin

www.youtube.com/watch?v=sXVVCT4Jcs8

Nandalot Mon 12-Jun-17 22:34:06

GG, 'be signed too,

Jalima1108 Mon 12-Jun-17 22:40:53

Thanks daphnedill, a good explanation.

daphnedill Mon 12-Jun-17 22:43:31

You're welcome. I can't help thinking that turning the clock back a year would make life a bit simpler - although probably not so full of surprises.

GracesGranMK2 Mon 12-Jun-17 22:53:18

Hopefully signing will just add to the messages they are getting - this is certainly interesting.

Tory and Labour MPs plot secret deal to ensure soft Brexit

There seemed to be some debate on the paper review as to whether the talks were that secret but I shall just be glad if they are talking. In the middle of the article it also says:

Labour is expected to use the talks as leverage to demand an end to the public sector pay freeze among a series of concessions in next week’s Queen’s Speech at the State Opening of Parliament.

It's a 'premium' article so I can't read it all but perhaps someone else will be able to.

durhamjen Mon 12-Jun-17 23:02:56

Here's an excellent article by Paul Mason, saying why it's the end of Brexit and neoliberalism.

www.theguardian.com/politics/commentisfree/2017/jun/12/paul-mason-jeremy-corbyn-defeat-ruling-elite-antonio-gramsci

durhamjen Mon 12-Jun-17 23:04:31

Secret talks, eh, GracesGran?
Not another lot of secret talks!

GracesGranMK2 Mon 12-Jun-17 23:13:07

I don't know why they have to be secret. I think an awful lot of the public just want them to get together and get on with whatever 'it' is going to be.

GracesGranMK2 Mon 12-Jun-17 23:24:37

Wow Jen that is a powerful and beautiful article - and strangely soothing smile