Gransnet forums

News & politics

Remainders &Leavers

(107 Posts)
norose4 Thu 06-Jul-17 18:54:47

Does anyone regret the choice they made in the referendum now that we are gradually seeing the effects of leaving the EU ?

devongirl Mon 10-Jul-17 14:14:01

I think a lot of 'remainers' didn't bother to vote as they thought there was no way we were going to leave.

TriciaF Mon 10-Jul-17 14:59:26

Another 2 who have changed their minds - eldest daughter and her partner voted leave. They now wish they had been prepared better for the decision, and think they should have either abstained or voted remain.

whitewave Mon 10-Jul-17 15:03:11

?????????

Good on them. Brave hearts!!

yggdrasil Mon 10-Jul-17 16:39:04

I think a lot of people didn't vote because they were waiting for some proper information on the options. They never got it, till now

devongirl Mon 10-Jul-17 16:42:22

Why we need a second referendum IMO

whitewave Mon 10-Jul-17 16:44:33

That's wanted by the majority of the UK according to - I think it's survation

freyja Mon 10-Jul-17 16:52:16

I read the letter and agree, so signed and sent then forward to all I know including leavers; just in case of change of mind.
I agree with Whitewave, Mark Twain is so good. The 63% I presume is the 48% of the voters who voted remain and half the population who did not vote that is 15% of don't know. The other 15% are those that don't know but would have probably voted leave, all speculative. The problem is that the leavers took the 30% (I thought it was actually 28%) of don't knows as being said that they ere for leaving and that is how they made up the winner number of 52%. Although my maths is not brilliant but I hope you get my drift. The real problem was that there was no space for the don't knows. There was only a YES or NO again not very democratic but if we hear this word enough will surely think it is.

devongirl Mon 10-Jul-17 16:55:45

I do hope that if (fingers crossed) there is a second vote, there will be some rules (agreed across parties) for required minimum turnout and margin between remain/leave.

nigglynellie Mon 10-Jul-17 17:00:20

I so nearly abstained right up to the point of placing that X as I felt it was a question that the majority of people including me hadn't enough understanding of and one that we shouldn't have been asked. However I felt I should vote and bearing in mind my intense dislike for the EU, migrant crises so badly handled, their treatment of Greece which was nothing short of humiliation for that poor country, worries over mutterings about Turkey, now long forgotten of course, but along then seemingly relevant, those and other issues I reluctantly voted to leave. I now wish I had gone with my first instincts to abstain and if asked a second time that is exactly what I and my family would do.

freyja Mon 10-Jul-17 17:43:06

I know many people who abstain or voted to leave for exactly the reason you gave nigglynellie. The referendum was a total disgrace, with facts and figures exaggerated,experts on both sides ignored. How on earth did we let them get away with such a flimsy margin of 4%. Nigel Farage stated that if the vote was for remain he will except nothing but 60% majority. So again this referendum has raised more questions then answers. Some how we must get a proper debate going, with all the pros and cons and only until we all sure of the facts we should have a 2nd vote. The trouble is that sensible idea is for dreamers of a true leader and all parties agreeing but all we are left with is pie in the sky.

Welshwife Mon 10-Jul-17 18:21:57

I still have see nothing positive about leaving - all the things which are happening just make me more convinced we should remain within the EU?

NZ. and Australia have both come out saying the EU will come before UK in any trade deals and Japan has already shown it is the case with them.

How many jobs do we need to see disappear before people realise the real implications of leaving the EU

nigglynellie Mon 10-Jul-17 18:38:56

What I really can't understand is that the H of C actually agreed that the result would be first past the post!! how arrogant or plain stupid was that!! D.C. announced that whatever the result he would abide by it and see it through, he would trigger article 50 the next day! an emergency budget. D.C. fled the scene, the chancellor, floundered about, no one knew what to do! Frankly, I think we've been run by the EU for so long that all our politicians are simply unable to govern any more, and are terrified of making the simplest of decisions, a bit like thirty something children who finally leave home and simply can't manage, having never had to! Regretfully I feel that we are as a country better to 'hang onto nurse etc', very disappointing!

nigglynellie Mon 10-Jul-17 18:40:36

I should have abstained!!!

Welshwife Mon 10-Jul-17 19:16:40

That is anot her misconceptionNiggly the UK has NEVER been run by Brussels! They only deal with European things and get joint trade deals which are beneficial to all countries. The EU has been used as a useful scapegoat for years and now the UK Govt are reaping the benefit(!) of those lies

The U.K. Has been responsible for domestic laws and budgets and UK taxes and benefit rules etc - as is every other EU country responsible for their own.

David Cameron was very much caught on the wrong foot by the result of the referendum and had no plan B ready. That is why he cut and run and the Tory party had no leader with authority for a couple of months till Thersa May picked up the poisoned chalice.

nigglynellie Mon 10-Jul-17 20:03:14

We all have our own opinions Welshwife. My observation of the EU is that it is rich man's club, be it banking, academia, big business. For me it is run by arrogant bullies, who treat people less fortunate than themselves with barely disguised contempt. I never ever thought that I would for the second time in my life see desperate people the wrong side of a razor sharp fence! I wonder where they are now courtesy of the all caring EU?! Now it's Italy's turn! Will the EU help? have they a plan? Do they care? So long as it doesn't interfere with their gilded lives, I very much doubt it very much.

Welshwife Mon 10-Jul-17 20:16:03

Have you ever listened to a debate in the EU?

There are too many diverse people and governments for it to be as you describe.

Welshwife Mon 10-Jul-17 20:17:12

In fact when I read your description I thought it was of the Tory party running the UK and how they behave in the H o C.!

nigglynellie Mon 10-Jul-17 20:45:53

Very probably! All politicians seem no be tarred with the same brush. However, our government did help Eire when that country found itself in financial difficulties, unlike the EU's attitude towards Greece!! As one of that country's politicians said not so long ago, that we are dealing with intransigent, bullies, and ain't that the truth.

Tegan2 Mon 10-Jul-17 20:51:22

Unlike Greece we don't need the EU to ruin our economy; we seem to be quite capable of doing it all by ourselves#that'llshow'em!

MaizieD Mon 10-Jul-17 21:16:46

Interesting twitter thread

twitter.com/EmporersNewC/status/884474494512975872

It's very long but worth reading.

"Steve Analyst‏
@EmporersNewC

1. Hello, United Kingdom, it’s the United States of America here, and we need to talk."

nigglynellie Mon 10-Jul-17 21:22:21

So you approve of the EU ruining Greece's economy, and now threatening Italy? Well these countries have to be brought back into line and others cowed that's true, so I suppose the end justifies the means! As for refugees? Well they must get on with that and just mange as best they can so long as the EU ship and all at the helm sail on unimpeded nothing else matters.

Welshwife Mon 10-Jul-17 21:34:58

The Greeks were desperate to join the EU and were allowed in and needed to accept the EURO - that has been their problem. Figures were 'adjusted' to get over the EU rules to allow them to join. They could not just continue to receive EU money and the situation not improve.

There were mistakes made and the joining of Greece is probably one of the biggest - naturally Greek politicians were annoyed at the events. Their economy was very poor before joining and the drachma not great.

A majority of countries which have joined the EU have done well - it made a spectacular difference to Eire - the farmers had never had it so good but many of the farmers abused the system - and that was ultimately not good.

Many companies which do not pay correct tax plus people like newspaper owners want to leave because they can manipulate many of the U.K. Politicians for their own ends and that is far more difficult to do with the EU - Murdoch has actually admitted that.

Welshwife Mon 10-Jul-17 21:39:50

Interestingmaizie when you see it in an orderly manner - brings it into fo as properly.

MaizieD Mon 10-Jul-17 21:46:40

What I can't get over, Welshwife is the fact that it was Britain who initiated or pushed for all those things which were used against the EU in the Leave campaign.

And thanks for posting about Greece; I was just about to do it myself, same points... grin

Though, WRT Greece, I don't think the 'austerity' budget they were forced to implement has helped. It's particularly ironic that austerity policies are now rapidly going out of fashion..

Welshwife Mon 10-Jul-17 21:57:52

The fact that the Uk has instigated many EU ideas or laws has been mentioned over the months the but many facts are easily forgotten.

When you look at that list and also see the extra leeway they agreed to with Cameron it is no wonder everyone thinks the Brits are bonkers!