Gransnet forums

News & politics

Animal Rights after the Brexit Repeal Bill

(165 Posts)
Ilovecheese Mon 20-Nov-17 16:13:58

I'm sorry I don't know how to do a link but I have just read this in the Independent on line
"MPs have voted to reject the inclusion of animal sentience – the admission that animals feel emotion and pain – into the EU Withdrawal Bill.

The move has been criticised by animal rights activists, who say the vote undermines environment secretary Michael Gove’s pledge to prioritise animal rights during Brexit.

The majority of animal welfare legislation comes from the EU. The UK Government is tasked with adopting EU laws directly after March 2019 but has dismissed animal sentience.
The Government said during the debate before the vote that this clause is covered by the Animal Welfare Act 2006.

The RSPCA disputed the Government’s claim."

I'm not a great animal lover myself, but I don't like to think of them being treated as if they have no feelings.

I wondered what animal lovers think about this.

Jalima1108 Sat 25-Nov-17 14:42:53

Are you concerned about standards of animal husbandry and appalling cruelty to animals in general in the EU or not djen?

durhamjen Sat 25-Nov-17 14:44:36

www.viva.org.uk/pigs

Pig farms get the shame of Britain award. About ten farms listed on this link, with photos of how our farmers treat sentient animals.

Of course, none of you buy your pork from such farms, do you?
Yours is all organic, kept in the fields, allowed to play nicely until slaughtered humanely, etc., etc.

durhamjen Sat 25-Nov-17 14:46:08

In the whole world, actually, Jalima. They probably have better welfare standards in Africa with the tribesmen than on our pigfarms.

Jalima1108 Sat 25-Nov-17 14:47:39

Straw-based/outdoor systems
UK – 40% of sows are outdoors, 90% of indoor sows and 60% of finishing pigs are kept on straw, 2-3% of finishers are free range and 0.6% of production is organic.
Sweden – more than 90% of sows and finishers are kept on straw. But just 1% of Swedish pigs are kept outdoors and these are all organic.
Rest of EU, US, Canada, Brazil – very few, if any, pigs are kept outdoors or on straw indoors. Most are kept on slatted floors. Very few organic pigs.

durhamjen Sat 25-Nov-17 14:53:37

www.viva.org.uk/what-we-do/our-work/turkeys

10 million turkeys going to be killed this Christmas, every one of them just bred for the Christmas market.
The population is only 66 million!
I know at least 40 vegans or vegetarians who will not be eating any.

durhamjen Sat 25-Nov-17 15:01:07

Where are your figures from, Jalima?

www.viva.org.uk/pigs/can-you-trust-the-tractor

Jalima1108 Sat 25-Nov-17 15:02:22

www.pig-world.co.uk/news/highlighting-the-differences-how-uk-welfare-standards-compare-with-our-competitors.html

durhamjen Sat 25-Nov-17 15:02:38

Even on your figures, 40% of sows outdoors means that 60% are not.

durhamjen Sat 25-Nov-17 15:03:46

The voice of the pig industry is rather biased, isn't it?

Jalima1108 Sat 25-Nov-17 15:11:37

The voice of the Guardian is rather biased too which is where a lot of information anti-British farmers seems to come from.

Jalima1108 Sat 25-Nov-17 15:13:15

Even on your figures, 40% of sows outdoors means that 60% are not.
On straw, not crammed in cages as they are in many other countries.

Of course, we import much of our bacon etc from the Netherlands and Denmark anyway, although I always try to buy British.

durhamjen Sat 25-Nov-17 15:13:16

www.viva.org.uk/what-we-do/pigs/we-go-undercover-expose-shocking-cruelty-morrisons-supplier

East Riding Country Pork.
Pigs are supposed to be treated as sentient beings, according to the government and the Tories who voted against it. These animals are supposed to have better rights than they have in the rest of the EU, so we don't need to give them more rights.

durhamjen Sat 25-Nov-17 15:14:46

Mine comes from Viva!, where they have taken their own photos and videos of the cruelty involved.

Jalima1108 Sat 25-Nov-17 15:16:13

Don't worry, shan't post any more smile because no-one will ever be able to change your view that everything about Britain is dreadful, nasty and bad and that everything about Continental Europe is wonderful.

Even though I did vote remain, I hope I don't have a blinkered view of the EU.

durhamjen Sat 25-Nov-17 15:16:29

Jalima, your figures are only about straw-based outdoor systems, not about the rest.
What about the rest, like those that Viva! have shown?

durhamjen Sat 25-Nov-17 15:22:21

An interesting interactive map here to show you about factory farming in your area.

www.ciwf.org.uk/media/7431377/new-interactive-map-exposes-uk-factory-farming-hotspots.pdf

You can click on it to show the different animals.

durhamjen Sat 25-Nov-17 15:35:30

Pathetic, Jalima.
This is about farmed animals and the fact that this government did not want to keep the clause in about animals feeling pain, etc. Not about comparing other EU countries with ours and finding them worse than us.

However EU farmers keep their livestock, they still have a clause that says they are sentient beings. We will not after Brexit. Their governments are still responsible for the laws.
Our government will not be after March 2019.

But that's okay, you throw your ball out of the pram just because you won't admit that you are wrong on this.
I don't have a blinkered view of how animals are kept anywhere.
As well as Viva! I belong to Peta which campaigns about how farm animals are kept in Eastern Europe and has some success at stopping live transport of animals, etc.
CIWF is about animals all over the world, and not just in the EU.
I have signed up to two campaigns today for them.

I can't believe that you don't object to 60% of UK farm animals being mistreated just because some other countries might keep them in worse conditions.

Jalima1108 Sat 25-Nov-17 15:51:10

How do you manage to twist other people's posts to change the meaning?

An amazing skill!

durhamjen Sat 25-Nov-17 16:09:28

Herefordshire has over 16 million indoor reared livestock, not allowed to express their normal behaviour. Shropshire has over 14 million.
North Yorkshire has the greatest number of pigs confined, 221,000, with over 7 million livestock confined altogether.
CIWF map.

petra Sat 25-Nov-17 16:13:52

jalima
how do you manage to twist other people's posts to change the meaning
Practice grin

durhamjen Sat 25-Nov-17 16:27:17

"the law alone is not always strong or detailed enough to ensure that [farm animals] have a good quality of life."

durhamjen Sat 25-Nov-17 16:30:02

Essex has over 2 million factory farmed animals.

durhamjen Sat 25-Nov-17 16:32:56

www.2sfg.com/news/company-news/updated-statement-to-the-guardianitv-investigation/

nigglynellie Sat 25-Nov-17 17:00:23

Goodness dj you'll undoubtedly be defending bull fighting, vile festivals in Spain, the disposal of donkeys, worn out greyhounds etc, circus animals, practises too horrible to even think about in many EU countries, all state approved. Not to mention intensive pig farming in Denmark, Holland, France, the list is endless. The EU may well consider animals to be sentinent, so what, unless you enforce these appalling cruelties which Europe clearly doesn't, that word is totally meaningless. Oh yes, they love hunting in the countries of the EU, songbirds are a favourite,(think Malta, Cyprus, Spain) in fact anything that moves. You're right this country isn't perfect, far from it, but I had to be any creature in this world, to say I'd rather be one in the UK than any other country is an understatement.

nigglynellie Sat 25-Nov-17 17:03:47

Sorry, 'sentient'.