Gransnet forums

News & politics

Disappearing Banks

(40 Posts)
mrsmopp Wed 14-Mar-18 23:37:16

Another local bank has closed leaving our small town with no banking facilities at all. Don't they care about their customers any more? A hole in the wall is no substitute. How are businesses supposed to pay in their takings?
Gradually the services of post offices have been whittled away and many of those have closed too.
Why is everything getting worse instead of better? Things really are going down the plug hole aren't they? Fed up I am.

mostlyharmless Thu 15-Mar-18 15:28:23

I’ve been using online banking happily for about twenty years.
But it means fewer and fewer people need a physical bank. I can’t think why they don’t combine different banks and perhaps the post office to offer a human banking service in every town.
It’s still a service that older people in particular need. I suppose as you age you end up with your children (if you are lucky enough to have children living nearby) doing your banking online for you. The Government doesn’t help by only paying pensions and benefits into bank accounts.
I seem to remember about thirty years ago that “pension day” was Thursday and all the pensioners went into our local town to collect their pensions from the post office and do their shopping.

keffie Thu 15-Mar-18 15:33:37

Marge most of the people who have been hacked haven't got proper additional security on there online banking , too easy passwords and no avg security or the like. You can get free versions of avg and avast security which are paid for by advertising.

I am not saying it doesn't happen to people who have good security however it's extremely much harder if you haven't got good security. Also alot of people aren't savvy with scams and keep up to date.

I have lost count of the amount of people I know whose security is appalling and had to sort out there laptops etc for them.

2 of our sons work in software developement and software engineering. Our 3rd son has his own business site. I have been bought up by mine with virtual.

The internet and online banking is as safe as you make it. Infact safer in some ways as you aren't going to a cash machine and withdrawing cash where someone can watch you, mug you and so on. Pitfalls to everything.

Regarding the question on high street banking. Our local branch recently closed. We have to go into the main branch if we need to deal with a person.

I can understand the frustration however branches just aren't used anymore like they were. I probably need to go in the bank once a year. The last time was to pick up a new security key as I had lost my old one.

Our adult children and grandchildren have and will grow up with online banking. There is always something for each generation as they age to struggle with.

My late mom struggled with alot or new innovations before she died.

Nonnie Thu 15-Mar-18 15:48:31

It really is all down to supply and demand. Banks can't keep unprofitable branches open or their shareholders would be angry and we should all remember that it is very likely we are the shareholders. Anyone who has a pension is probably a share holder in some such organisation. It isn't all wealthy people who own shares.

Really tough if you need to use a branch and there isn't one near you. We don't so it is fine for us to use online banking.

Ilovecheese Thu 15-Mar-18 15:51:55

I think the answer to your question "don't they care about their customers any more" mrsmopp is:

No they don't

mostlyharmless Thu 15-Mar-18 16:00:23

My hairdressers doesn’t accept cards so they have to pay cash and cheque takings into a bank. They were forced to change their bank after many years with them when the local branch closed recently. Lots of other businesses must be in the same boat.
Not sure how they would cope if the last bank in town closed down.

vickymeldrew Thu 15-Mar-18 16:12:06

How many people who complain about branch closures actually conduct any profitable business through their bank? There seems to be a misconception that visiting a branch and paying in the odd cheque, or having a chat with a cashier keeps a bank ticking over financially. I expect lots of us on Gransnet have our funds tied up in premium bonds, investment bonds and National Savings with maybe our pensions paid to us via a bank. Banks, like any other retail outlet, need to cover their costs to remain open.

jenpax Thu 15-Mar-18 16:23:31

I sometimes have to pay cash in to my account or for one of my daughters.
I admit to not using the branch very often now, but I do use phone banking (not internet).
I would be surprised if we can go completely cashless, as lots of transactions for tiny amounts are not worth using a card for, and in any event many of the retailers charge for card transactions if the customer spends below £5

Caledonai14 Thu 15-Mar-18 16:57:08

Our nearest Clydesdale closed down many years back and we all got used to going to the next village where the bank became very busy indeed. That has now closed down too and we have to go to a town 30 miles away which is much more difficult all round. The most recent village closure was fought tooth and nail by all involved. I've never known a bank so continuously busy and it made no sense. The distant town branch promised all sorts of new things, like being open on a Saturday, but that lasted just a few weeks. Then they suddenly started sending private mail to the wrong address and when I finally managed to get down to the branch, they made me discuss it with a teller while a large queue built up behind me. None of the three staff within the town bank would come to the information window. Despite many phone calls and complaints it took months for them to admit and sort their mistake and there has still been no apology. The banks are trying to force us to go to internet/telephone banking by making it so difficult to use the branches. For some of us, internet banking is a scary and difficult option (if simply trying to get a wrong address sorted is anything to go by). Their other tactic is to issue a number which is supposed to be for the branch you are with, but which just rings out unanswered and with no option to leave a message. I shall be changing banks after more than 40 years, but there is no guarantee that the new bank will stay open either.

sarahellenwhitney Thu 15-Mar-18 19:59:08

I am guilty of online banking. If I receive a cheque for some reason or another I can pay it into my village post office . I can also withdraw money over the counter at the same time as I have a horror of ATM's.Folk have their accounts cleaned out due to disclosing their personal information.It is advisable to change your passwords every now and then.

keriku Thu 15-Mar-18 20:48:55

I live in Fife, the RBS closed one small branch after another till there are now only 4 in the whole county. They seem to be permanently queued out the door. They have not put on any extra tellers to deal with the extra clientele. I have had no option but to start online banking, my husband has not done so. Yesterday the bank made an error, so he contacted them online. They wouldn't deal with his query as he doesn't do online banking - so he had to drive to the nearest large town and wait bloody ages to be served. They said they closed the branches due to falling trade but we knew some of the staff and they said they were just as busy as ever! The RBS bosses have creamed off profits leaving the ordinary staff and customers to suffer. It's a disgrace!

Ellie Anne Thu 15-Mar-18 21:37:27

We can also pay in cheque s at the post office but the queues are awful. Our wee bank was always busy.

Tizliz Thu 15-Mar-18 22:18:58

The problem with no banks here is the inability to get cash. This is a tourist area and b&b only take cash. I can’t see tourist queuing in the P.O. (in the Spar) to get cash.

I was passing the nearest bank yesterday so used cash machine - it was empty.

meandashy Fri 16-Mar-18 07:03:13

I think the fact the banks are stating people aren't using them is absolute poppycock ?.
There will always be people who can't /won't/don't want to use online banking & why should they? Online banking does not cover all the services a bank provides! Money grabbing gits.......

jenpax Fri 16-Mar-18 07:17:19

Yes! Tizliz,and recently Link which supplies most of the cash machines in the UK announced it was scaling them back! Many places now only have those hideous fee charging machines which make the user pay £1.50 for taking cash out! Many people on low incomes will struggle if cash machines go this way!