Gransnet forums

News & politics

Likely consequenses of brexit

(830 Posts)
varian Tue 03-Jul-18 20:40:02

If brexit happens, as I fear it probably will, the consequences, both intended and unintended, are likely to damage this country to an unprecedented extent.

As it is the most important political issue of our times, I believe we should continue to discuss it on GN, but we must be prepared for a continuence of the blind unreasoning dogma we have had so far from the little band of brexitextreemists on GN who will just keep their fingers in their ears.

Even so, I think it is important to continue to seek out the truth. We owe it to our children and grandchildren.

Allygran1 Sat 07-Jul-18 23:45:56

Jura2 what evidence do you have to support your statement.
"One Referendum was on the basic idea, without any detail, massive lies, misinformation and fraudulently run. and won by a tiny majority".

Since the referendum we have also had a General Election and put a Government and Opposition in Parliament that both stood on a Brexit support mandate.

Let us get this straight 17.5 million people is not a 'tiny majority". That was then, and in the General Election although the Conservatives lost seats, Theresa May had the largest increase in share of the vote for forty years. She stood for election on a hard brexit platform.

Allygran1 Sat 07-Jul-18 23:32:05

GillT57. The referendum was advisory, and the Government took the advise of around 17.5 million British people from across political divides. In there would have been some Union members who voted leave as well no doubt. Why is it Gill that because you, as a remain voter was not in the majority that you have to try to diminish Brexit the only and easy way you can by making it look like those who voted leave have been fooled. Let me tell you that I for one and all those I know who voted Leave, including those on Gransnet "News and Politics Forum" as far as I can see from post's, not only fully understand the reasons they voted to get out of the EU system they also understand the importance of moving into the twenty first century, rather than being stuck in the past.

The EU is strangling individuality, has embedded itself: an undemocratic, unelected, corporate, capitalist system, into each Country that they have ensnared using access to a single market.

The people that have seen through the EU, and realise it has become a protectionist contradiction to the reason why it was formed are the leave voter's. Why would you allow the future of up and coming generations to be threatened by tying yourself to a failing system? The European Project has gone into reverse, and created old divisions, the very thing it was formed to eliminate. It is causing divide by control, not of the "jack boot" as was feared in 1945 but of eurocratic institutionalised rigidity, regulations and top heavy un elected control, based on entrapment and fettered Country's..

The cost to this Country as the third largest contributor to the 27 other Country's is based on a seven year payment system. Thankfully, we did not join the euro, thankfully Margaret Thatcher negotiated a rebate that still stands. The other issue you as a Trade Unionist should be concerned about is, that the EU, in so much as the EEA Country's are moving to both the far left and the far right, with some of these polarised political opinions even sharing Government of their Country's in three instances to challenge the EU directives, regulations and controls. Five Country's considered to be on the brink of financial failure, If Italy goes bust as it is likely to do, plus Greece, the Euro fails. Greece is being kept afloat, but the EU cannot keep Italy afloat, it would bring the Euro down.

Don't you think it is irresponsible to distance yourself from all this. High unemployment, unrest, mass movement of legal migrants causing pressure and high unbalanced numbers of people overloading infrastructures, and all services, including Education, creating poor living conditions, social unrest and as I said high unemployment figures.

When the UK leave the EU, other Country's are already saying they will not pay more in to compensate for lost income to the EU, no doubt the EU will find some other ruse to make money out of them to pay the high wages of the eurocrats. Just one years pension for one eurocrat would buy a small mansion and their annual salary a life style that you and I could only imagine.

Take a look behind the swish buildings, the marshall looking flag arrangements reminiscent of an old Europe. The so called 'parliamentary' chamber that makes the EU look democratic. Take a look behind who the Commissioners are. Take a look at the mass waste of money, just one instance moving buildings, moving country's even every month to please France, what! That is just the tip of the iceberg. Take a peek, even do some research and lift the EU curtain to see what is really behind it before you criticise the leave voters.

Allygran1 Sat 07-Jul-18 22:12:41

football Next Wednesday Lemon. England v Croatia, should be a great match.

jura2 Sat 07-Jul-18 21:01:43

Of course, anyone with a memory and a bit of insight will remember what Brexit, and the exception re Financial Services is quite simply about:

www.thelondoneconomic.com/opinion/the-brexit-undertones-of-the-eus-impending-anti-tax-avoidance-legislation/21/06/

as most Tories are linked to all the big financial firms, like Mrs May's husband and the rest.

GillT57 Sat 07-Jul-18 18:28:06

I have to agree with lemon , there is unlikely to be another referendum. Ever. The British electorate has shown itself to be gullible and easily fooled by liars, cheats and charlatans. Pity Cameron didn't take this into account before he so arrogantly called this referendum, didn't like the answer and ran away. Bloody man. As a member of the QT pointed out on Thursday, if this had been a Trade Union Ballot for say strike action, it would have been invalid.

Welshwife Sat 07-Jul-18 18:21:09

Proof please - not just hearsay.

nigglynellie Sat 07-Jul-18 17:38:54

The EU is corrupt and fraudulent, perhaps they should be stripped of their authority?!!

lemongrove Sat 07-Jul-18 17:08:48

The footie was great btw ???????⚽️?

Jalima1108 Sat 07-Jul-18 17:08:22

I was just about to mention empires and the way the elite treated the slaves and peasants lemongrove

lemongrove Sat 07-Jul-18 17:07:44

Maw grin but, but........this is the Brexit thread!

Jalima1108 Sat 07-Jul-18 17:07:10

Some people never left the fight discussion MawBroon!

lemongrove Sat 07-Jul-18 17:06:08

It won’t be proven though jura there isn’t a hope in hell of proving anything.
Only the HOC will have any input on the final deal.

MawBroon Sat 07-Jul-18 17:05:30

Oh dear, the final whistle has been blown and we are back to Brexit. ⚽️⚽️⚽️⚽️

lemongrove Sat 07-Jul-18 17:03:33

True!

All empires come to an end, and for the same reason, they get too big and over extend themselves.

jura2 Sat 07-Jul-18 17:02:00

Luckylegs, oh yes you can if it is proven, as it has officially and absolutely without doubt, that the vote was illegal and fraudulent.

Just as you can win the Tour de France, the Olympics, or anything else and be stripped of your Medal or Trophy if proven to have won illegally.

Anyhow, no one is talking about a second vote on Brexit, but on the final deal...

nigglynellie Sat 07-Jul-18 17:00:40

You're right Lemon, there was nothing we could say or do, but we should have tried!!

nigglynellie Sat 07-Jul-18 16:59:01

I don't think the EU will still exist in 10 years, transparency over their expenses has just been narrowly defeated, so 'expense' money spent can remain completely unaccountable and a good time had by all!! This will inevitably cause more muted dissent amongst the 'peasants' and a gift for the far right. The EU will eventually be the architect of its own downfall and we can and must be, well shot before that happens!

lemongrove Sat 07-Jul-18 16:58:56

There won’t be another people’s vote jura
Anything different will be decided in Parliament.

Yes niggly Greece was treated appallingly, with nothing any EU country could do or say ( well, they could, but wouldn't have got anywhere.)

Luckylegs9 Sat 07-Jul-18 16:39:56

If you vote for something and you lose, you cannot do it again. I fail to see remainers logic. Democracy is precious as is our Health Service. I think in the next ten years other countries will follow our stance.

jura2 Sat 07-Jul-18 16:32:54

One Referendum was on the basic idea, without any detail, massive lies, misinformation and fraudulently run. and won by a tiny majority.
so a vote on the final deal would be totally fair, of course.

And if you are sure no-one has changed their mind, why are you afraid of a vote on the final deal?

nigglynellie Sat 07-Jul-18 16:29:11

Eastern European countries are deeply worried about the prospect of the UK being shut out of Galileo, and other security matters, but have been warned to toe the EU line on brexit or they will be punished financially! So much for individual countries having their say!! Why on earth would we want to stay in an organisation with the morals of the Mafia? Money is poured into poor countries, money that they can never ever begin to pay back, which loosely means that they are trapped and prevented from ever giving an opinion apart from the official one, till the end of time - just like the USSR, China, North Korea, all is well on the surface, but dissension is not tolerated and will be severely punished! obviously not by physical methods, but by financial ones!
Whatever sort of way is that to carry on? How on earth can we be complicit in that? When it was Greece pulled down into penury, we were guilty by association, and yes, I did and do feel ashamed at our perceived acquiescence. It was an awful way to treat a population, and here we go again, do as we tell you or else???? except hopefully it'll be they not we!

lemongrove Sat 07-Jul-18 16:16:11

One referendum is enough, we can’t keep having them.
Very few people voted for the way we leave the EU in any case, just that we do leave it.
I think the UK and the EU can really get on and do a deal now.

jura2 Sat 07-Jul-18 16:14:28

There is a very good reason why KPMG and other top financial services are doing a lot of research into all the options ahead. To prepare for relocation if things don't work out to their advantage and that of their customers.

80% of the UK market is in services. And a massive % of the tax we need to run NHS and all the ther essential services in the UK.

jura2 Sat 07-Jul-18 15:57:01

So let's put it to the vote then Lemongrove ... and see

lemongrove Sat 07-Jul-18 15:50:05

There will be much horse trading still no doubt, but Barnier must be pleased that there is now a real possibility of doing a trade deal with us.