Gransnet forums

News & politics

People still think EU nstionals are being treated fairly in the UK?

(122 Posts)
notanan2 Mon 05-Aug-19 12:20:33

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2019/aug/05/surge-in-eu-citizens-unfairly-refused-access-to-universal-credit

growstuff Mon 05-Aug-19 21:51:31

Agreed :-)

Maggiemaybe Mon 05-Aug-19 23:23:41

There are many many more British expats in the EU than t'other way round. Fact.'

I’d be interested to see your source for this “fact”, Jura2.

Any figures I’ve seen have been in the region of nearly three times as many EU citizens in the UK as there are UK citizens in the EU.

growstuff Mon 05-Aug-19 23:25:36

That point has already been made. Jura got it wrong.

Maggiemaybe Tue 06-Aug-19 06:21:46

Obviously. But as I said, I’d like to hear from Jura, thank you.

jura2 Tue 06-Aug-19 08:51:41

Will try and find the figures, no time just now.

As for child benefit, unemployment benefit, help with medical insurance, and so much more - UK people living in the EU and also in Switzerland- are all entitled to those- and often, as is the case here, at a much much higher rate than in the UK. It goes both ways- that is how it is meant to work.

growstuff Tue 06-Aug-19 08:57:07

You like your pound of flesh, do you, Maggimay? ;-)

jura2 Tue 06-Aug-19 09:02:45

Fair enough, growstuff- I have often repeated a question because someone has made a statement and then have not been prepared to explain. That is OK.

So, it seems I got it wrong- figures change all the time- and figures are not accurate either anyhow. I know several retired people, for instance, who live 'under the radar' in France and Spain - and not part of any figures.

And of course, a vast amount of UK citizens living in other parts of EU are retired- whereas most EU people in UK are active/working.

The benefits are reciprocal, is my point ... and often paid at a much higher rate than in the UK (as child benefit in France, or here).

jura2 Tue 06-Aug-19 09:13:00

However, I took it that this thread was and is about the total insecurity people from the EU are experiencing in the UK, still today. And the total insecurity of UK citizens living in the EU - and have no idea if their lives will be thrown upside down and inside out this autumn, or soon after. Can't plan anything, living in limbo, eaten with worry and stress, watching the Pound going down the chute, and their security with it. This especially if they are mixed families. It is perhaps difficult for anyone who has never left the UK to imagine - but I can assure you it is real, very real, for 10s of 1000s- both sides.

And yes, I am fully aware that some of you don't care, don't care at all- not one tiny weeny little bit.

Lessismore Tue 06-Aug-19 09:23:10

A little anecdote to add a human perspective.....friends of mine came from Poland with a very ill daughter. They left everything behind because some specialist care was available here.
From the moment the plane touched down they were seeking work. They worked all the hours they could in horrible jobs way below what they had been doing. They clawed their way up and up and bought a house in a run down area which they have transformed into a beautiful home. They also slogged away at learning English.
Their children are bright,well behaved and popular.
Can people not see that advantages to having such neighbours?

MaizieD Tue 06-Aug-19 09:39:01

And yes, I am fully aware that some of you don't care, don't care at all- not one tiny weeny little bit.

I'm not sure if it is 'not caring' jura.

I think that a significant number of Leavers are absolutely and genuinely at a complete loss to comprehend why Remainers cannot see that the obvious and overwhelming benefits of leaving the EU are worth every moment of pain and suffering that it might cause to individuals. After all, if they (the Leavers) are prepared to face what they believe will be short term chaos disruption why shouldn't everyone else be ready to cheerfully do so, too?

This is not sarcasm, BTW. I'm trying very hard to see the Leavers' point of view.

Maggiemaybe Tue 06-Aug-19 09:50:20

You like your pound of flesh, do you, Maggimay? ;-)

Not at all, growstuff. Just interested in how/why misinformation is spread.

Adding a jaunty wink to a personal comment doesn’t make it any less rude, btw.

growstuff Tue 06-Aug-19 09:55:28

You're right about at least two things, Jura.

The number of EU citizens living in other EU countries is only an estimate. Apparently, the figures are based on surveys at ports.

Nearly all EU adults in the UK have paid employment, whereas ex-pats living in EU countries tend to be retired.

growstuff Tue 06-Aug-19 09:56:06

Really? Thanks for the tip! ;-)

growstuff Tue 06-Aug-19 09:58:20

I agree with your third point too, Jura. The insecurity must be soul destroying. These people are here legally, but are being treated as second class citizens.

notanan2 Tue 06-Aug-19 13:17:27

Settled status means nothing if other government agencies arent accepting it unless it goes to appeal!

jump through X hoop and you can continue to live here as before

Jumps through X hoop...

Goes to next gov agency

sorry but X hoop is "insufficient evidence" go re submit all your evidence all over again

How long will that take?

3 to 9 months

Goes to change job. "Yes here see I have confirmation of settled status"

no Im sorry that is not enough, we need to see ALL your documents all over again

But I dont have them and the gov wont tell me when I'll get them back!

Oh no my mother is dying I need my passport back

well you have to cancel the process if you want your documents back

But you've had them for 4 months! And I HAVE settled status anyway surely that.....

Yeah. Theyre fiiiiiiiine! hmm

jura2 Tue 06-Aug-19 13:33:22

A real nightmare- and, if the parents are of different nationalities, and one of them is non-EU- multiply the nightmare by many extra 0s.

BTW I know many British expats working here in Switzerland who are sending Child maintenance back to UK- with kids finishing schools in UK where they are not paying taxes either, and with kids using NHS, etc. This child care is much much more than in the UK and with the exchange rate currently, even more so- bout 60% more than a few years ago (just as we are now 60% less- t'other way round).

And those who are currently un-employed and get 70 or 80% or salary paid for 2 years, as said, with support for health insurance, in finding jobs, courses training and free language courses. Good- as that is the whole point- goes both ways.

jura2 Tue 20-Aug-19 19:26:09

And now Priti Patel has jumped the gun and written to officially revoke Free Movement for 1st of November- without any plans to protect those already here- and some ridiculous figures for minumum salary of 33.000 ?!?

And British citizens in the EU who had been reassured I sick with fear and stress- the Pound is dropping and t it seems very likey that pension will no longer be index linked beyond 2020, and reciprocal health care agreement will more than likely be dropped too. It is really really scary for so many.

jura2 Tue 20-Aug-19 20:31:16

sorry about typos - sure you get my 'drift'

varian Thu 29-Aug-19 14:55:02

LIsten to this distraught EU national who has lived and worked in the UK for twenty years and then say "well done, Pritti Patel"

news.sky.com/video/anti-prorogation-protester-i-looked-after-your-children-now-you-kick-me-out-11796458#spark_wn=1

jura2 Thu 29-Aug-19 14:58:55

'Nearly all EU adults in the UK have paid employment, whereas ex-pats living in EU countries tend to be retired.'

and many many are living under the radar too- taking from both sides- like Lawson was.

Greta Thu 29-Aug-19 16:09:12

Boris Johnson and Pritti Patel both stated they would guarantee EU nationals an automatic right to remain in the UK.
This was a lie. The settlement scheme is flawed and the government has refused to enshrine the rights of EU nationals in law.

I am afraid the damage has now been done. I for one will never feel the same about this country again.

blondenana Thu 29-Aug-19 16:40:25

notanan2 my son lives in Spain, and has been trying to get married since February, he has had to do all the things you mention, passed from this place to that, and back again,get full birth certificates, which took weeks, then they were passed on to somewhere, then get proof he and partner have not been married before, etc,all this has taken months, and has to go before a judge, at last they have got a date,for the 14th of September
It is an absolute pain in Spain to get anything done quickly,
Same with applying for a mortgaage,but he says he will never come back to this Country

growstuff Fri 30-Aug-19 01:46:13

Yes, it was a lie Greta. Sadly the people who support them don't care that they lie.

growstuff Fri 30-Aug-19 07:59:43

Even committed Brexiter, Dan Hannan MEP, realises what's going on. Tweeted yesterday.

jura2 Sat 07-Sep-19 10:49:48

Lots of similar cases currently - it is a disgrace. Can you imagine what this does to a family?