Gransnet forums

News & politics

Corbyn

(255 Posts)
Firecracker123 Wed 06-Nov-19 08:44:41

Corbyn last year
"Shamina Begun should be allowed to return to the UK. She was only a 16 year old immature child when she joined ISIS she cannot be held accountable for her actions at such a young age"

Corbyn last week
"We the people demand 16 year olds be given the vote in the UK, they are responsible and free thinking young adults"

The Brexiteer

lemongrove Wed 06-Nov-19 19:20:20

Breathtaking? Corbyn’s rabble rousing, I think not.
Being able to rant at the home crowd is his speciality, as are things he can vote against and doesn’t like.A leader he isn’t.
He is a weak vacillating man promoted above his pay grade.

Firecracker123 Wed 06-Nov-19 17:52:32

Corbyn and the Labour Party have lost touch with ordinary working class people. It's a party completely dominated by North London. Nigel Farage

Labour no longer represent Leave voting constituents in the North, Midlands and Midlands

Whitewavemark2 Wed 06-Nov-19 15:31:09

Breathtaking. Channel 4 Researchers have put together the top 20 Jeremy Corbyn speeches over the last 30 years. They show a remarkable consistency of principle. Journalism at its very very best.

Oopsminty Wed 06-Nov-19 15:02:34

I was wondering that. All this endless comment and for what purpose?

I'm no more likely to vote for Jeremy Corbyn today than I was when I joined GN

Even though I've read many supportive posts from intelligent posters

Imagine getting the main/most vocal political contributors on political threads in a pub somewhere. Would they speak to each other in the same way?.

Doodle Wed 06-Nov-19 15:00:21

Kind of where I was coming from ladymuck grin

ladymuck Wed 06-Nov-19 14:57:25

Doodle, no-one in their right mind would be influenced by the comments made on Gransnet.

Doodle Wed 06-Nov-19 14:53:07

I don’t disagree about debate painting but from all the threads I have read on GN there has been little debate more dogmatic I am right and you are wrong from both sides. I was merely asking if anyone’s vote had been swayed by comments from either side.

ladymuck Wed 06-Nov-19 14:52:13

Just as a matter of interest.....knowing nothing about the procedure.....when a person decides to stand as an MP, surely checks are made on the person's background, history, membership of organisations,etc.

Surely someone who has proved themselves to be anti-British (as is suggested by the facts stated about Corbyn), they would not be permitted to be a member of Parliament?

paintingthetownred Wed 06-Nov-19 14:46:03

Doodle,
Your views are positively dangerous.

People lose faith in the political process and they lose faith in democracy at it's core.
I and many others are of the view this was a deliberate strategy on behalf of some (yes tories) so that people would cease engaging in the political process.

Guess what, you have lost it. We are continuing to engage, and all the young people along with us.

And yes, I do think it is important to engage in debate.
And yes, I do think Corbyn is a man of principle.
And yes, I do think he would do a fantastic job.

painting

Doodle Wed 06-Nov-19 14:39:16

It’s all the same. If you are a Labour supporter it’s bash the Conservatives and if Conservative supporter its bash Labour. Just wondering in all these political threads where each side think they are in the right and everyone else is wrong whether anyone has been swayed by the arguments of either side to change their voting plans.

Gonegirl Wed 06-Nov-19 14:13:58

To be fair, I think the first remark in the OP shows compassion.

Don't agree with the second remark though.

trisher Wed 06-Nov-19 14:09:21

Unsubstantiated vitriol which has been proved wrong but which is still repeated? Or fair comment on a stupid remark?

Doodle Wed 06-Nov-19 13:52:43

Vitriol is coming from both sides. Just look at the Mogg thread.

Anniebach Wed 06-Nov-19 13:28:02

But Corbyn thinks 16 year olds are immature

trisher Wed 06-Nov-19 13:25:38

I do wonder what it is that stirs up such vitriol from some posters. I think perhaps they find anyone who has good basic principles a kick to their conscience. They know that ultimately war and terrorism are wrong. They know they should be worked against and combated, but they do nothing. So they turn on anyone who has a history of working to stop such things. They make false accusations and refuse to change their views even in the face of evidence.
As for 16 year olds voting Why not? After all if we have a fixed term 5 year Parliament they may vote at 16 but won't have another untl they are 21 and 15 year olds won't get a choice till they are 20.

Whitewavemark2 Wed 06-Nov-19 12:17:48

Corbyn

Judge us on whether we’ve built a million genuinely affordable homes so that decent and secure housing is within the reach of everybody.

“Judge us on whether in-work poverty still exists in five years’ time

“Judge us on whether people are still sleeping rough after five years of a Labour government.

“Judge us on whether proud women and men are still having to depend on food banks five years into a Labour government

“Judge us on whether we’ve unleashed a Green Industrial Revolution, created hundreds of thousands of green energy jobs in the communities that need them most, and significantly reduced our greenhouse emissions.

“We don’t have any time to waste.”

Anniebach Wed 06-Nov-19 12:15:30

It is in the BBC clip, you didn’t watch it I assume Maizie

MaizieD Wed 06-Nov-19 11:51:54

You've watched the BBC clip, I assume, Annie?

Anniebach Wed 06-Nov-19 11:51:30

And cordon off an area for people to say what they dislike about all the party leaders ?

Anniebach Wed 06-Nov-19 11:48:48

Yes, he said ‘I was there but I don’t think I was actively involved in it’ .

A wreath laying ceremony for terrorists who murdered Olympic athletes and he didn’t think he was actively involved!

ladymuck Wed 06-Nov-19 11:25:45

People have short memories. There are also young voters who will not know of the personal history of our current politicians. Doesn't do any harm to keep them informed.

EllanVannin Wed 06-Nov-19 11:21:38

I happen to agree with GracesGran. She's correct in many ways !

grapefruitpip Wed 06-Nov-19 11:21:02

Should we cordon off an area for people to say what they dislike about the man?
That way , there would be no need for the endless dredging up?

MaizieD Wed 06-Nov-19 10:54:58

Here you are, Annie

The Corbyn Wreath Row Explained

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-45196409

growstuff Wed 06-Nov-19 10:40:52

Yes Anniebach. The bodies of the terrorists were in the same graveyard, but people who were actually there have confirmed that Corbyn probably didn't even know about the graves.

He was laying a wreath in memory of dozens of Palestinians and Tunisians, including civilians, killed by an Israeli air attack on the PLO headquarters in Tunisia on 1 October 1985, an act that was condemned at the time by the UN and Margaret Thatcher’s Conservative government. This is an annual ceremony which is held by Palestinians and Tunisians to mourn the dead in that attack.