Gransnet forums

News & politics

Four day week

(158 Posts)
Rosina Thu 14-Nov-19 08:38:58

Regarding this proposal, which keeps cropping up in the election campaign and is again in the news this morning with regard to NHS staff, I am at a loss, perhaps over simplifying the detail. Do we have a situation where employees will need to take a 20% cut in order to work for four days instead of five, or where employers will need to keep paying staff for five days and see a 20% drop in production decimate their businesses over time, given competition from other countries? I really can't see how this can be a serious proposal without some form of explanation as to how it will work.

MaizieD Thu 14-Nov-19 10:27:36

But don't forget, all the increased spending is more money circulating in the economy, more money for infrastructure projects and consumer spending, and more money returning to the Treasury in tax take.

I can see 'inflation' being raised as an objection, but it only becomes inflationary if resources become scarce.

MaizieD Thu 14-Nov-19 10:31:00

Teachers. As I understand it teachers are leaving the classroom in droves because of the long hours and increased stress... I have seen it stated that a significant number of teachers leave the profession within 5 years of qualifying... (I'd have to check that, though and don't have time to do so ATM).

jenpax Thu 14-Nov-19 10:33:55

I used to work a 4 day week (a charity) but had extended hours for the 4 that I was in, and this gave me a day off in the week.
I loved it! I was used to starting work early and working unpaid overtime anyway (many people in small charities have to do this to keep things working!) and this just formalised things and allowed me a much needed day in the week to sort out personal admin (for things that were not open at weekends like the council tax department!) and a day when I could indulge a hobby without children under foot!

NfkDumpling Thu 14-Nov-19 10:40:08

I wonder how this will work for my DS who has a contracted 47 hour week?

growstuff Thu 14-Nov-19 10:42:40

Callistemon The priority in a secondary school is always to have specialists, especially with exam classes. You're right that part-timers sometimes lead to classes having a specialist for, for example, three lessons out of four and a non-specialist for the fourth lesson, if the class needs teaching when no specialist is available.

The problem of non-specialists is beyond this thread and is mainly caused by chronic shortages in some subjects. Absences, including long-term absences, are sometimes covered by cover supervisors, who are often not even trained teachers. It's an absolute scandal, but I'm not sure how much parents are really aware what's going on.

Grandad1943 Thu 14-Nov-19 10:48:47

Anniebach Quote [ I don’t think it will work for all. Comparing Microsoft with small businesses is daft. ] End Quote.

Anniebach, four day working weeks applies just as well for small and medium sized businesses as it does for large.

By example, a small transport contractor engaged in home delivery for a large online retailer that requires seven days working.

That contractor can then engage one driver employee on a nine or ten-hour day for four days and then a second on three days of ten or eleven hours. Both the forgoing would working either four days on duty followed by three days off, or three days on duty followed by four days off.

The above covers all the required working for the vehicle and the employees get longer periods of rest in terms of days off, while the employer gets maximum flexibility in terms of vehicle and employee engagement.

The above has been worked in the road transport industry for a considerable number of years. How else would anyone get what they ordered online delivered on a Saturday or Sunday without such flexibility?

The same applies to employees in many of the Distribution centres that setup the orders for delivery.

Shortlegs Thu 14-Nov-19 10:54:46

Diane Abbott has done the sums, so everything will be OK.

Candelle Thu 14-Nov-19 10:57:23

DC number 1 is a 'part-time' GP. The hours necessary to do her job are working 7.15 am to 8.15 or 9.15 pm several days a week with ''half days' of 7.15 am to 2.45 pm.

Perhaps patients only see the number of hours available for consultations and not the many hours necessary each day for administrative work. Doctors are also unavailable for consultations as they visit nursing homes and make home visits. Oh, I didn't mention the'phone calls that come through at any hour, should there be a crisis.

Where exactly are these 'part-timers' supposed to find extra hours?

DC number 2 is a 'part-time' civil servant. She works three full days with hours spread over four days. So far so good, except that there are so many staff shortages for a variety of reasons, that she is covering four full-time jobs. Four.

Both these public servants also work evenings and weekends, once home, trying to do their jobs thoroughly.

The public need to know that these and many thousands like them are propping this county up. There is no slack in some sectors for reduced hours!

Politicians can promise the earth but reality is that shortage of money and a genuine willingness to sort these problems out is immediately necessary before more people bow out of these incredibly stressful roles and we sink even further.

NfkDumpling Thu 14-Nov-19 10:59:15

I don’t think a lot of trades - plumbers, carpenter, plasterers and so on - could cope with hard physical work for ten plus hours a day. Especially for outdoor work when on dull day we’re lucky to get six hours decent outdoor light.

BusterTank Thu 14-Nov-19 11:01:45

It's absolute madness . As for the NHS maybe if they give the nurses fix contracts rather than 3 monthly , it would be more appealing .

newnanny Thu 14-Nov-19 11:18:11

I would not worry Rosina. It is another looney left idea by JC and McD that is ill thought out and will not work in practice. We are already short of NHS staff so giving them all 20% time off is typical of him, making a situation worse and adding confusion. Labour will not get in with their shambolic ideology and leaders who support terrorism.

newnanny Thu 14-Nov-19 11:26:15

@MazieD, I was one of those teachers who left at 57 after teaching for all of my working life and examining A levels too. The frequent changing of exam specifications so when you have spent about 80 -100 hours preparing for a new specification it changes after one or two years meaning you have to start from scratch again and is very disheartening. This along with new curriculum maps and constant recording is very draining and takes the joy out of teaching. There is a massive issue in teaching as there are fewer new recruits than those who retire plus many are also leaving. In some subjects vacancies go unfilled for months on end. When I gave in my notice at Xmas they could not recruit another suitable candidate so I had to stay on until July and even then they wanted me to go in to school in September to do handover as they had to use a NQT.

Grandad1943 Thu 14-Nov-19 11:31:26

NfkDumpling in regard to your post @10:59 today, many manual
Workers have to work outdoors in poor weather conditions at all seasons of the year.

How do you think your local supermarket, Pharmacy, greengrocers and many other retailers would manage every day if the delivery drivers were not prepared to work making deliveries to those retailers in all winds and weathers, day and night right throughout the year.

Even more importantly how do you think we would all manage if the employees at your local sewage treatment plant were not prepared to get out there again day and night, in all winds and weathers, at any time of the year clearing blockages and restrictions in the tanks and flow channels.That action requires carrying out far more often when the weather is as bad as it has been of recent.

Of course, no one ever thinks of them or quotes them in forums posts or other media. Just think of the professionals in classrooms and cosy offices and the world will be just OK.

Nanny27 Thu 14-Nov-19 11:40:22

Just wondering if we are ultimately heading towards a rolling 7day week, who is going to look after the children at weekends or are teachers expected to do that on top of everything else we are expected to do?

Anniebach Thu 14-Nov-19 12:08:08

Our building firm could not work a 4 day week

sodapop Thu 14-Nov-19 12:17:49

Think how much more difficult then growstuff to ensure services are covered 24/7 in the case of emergency services, hospitals, residential and community care.

pipdog Thu 14-Nov-19 12:29:26

No one has mentioned farm workers. If you own the farm then you expect to work all day everyday until the work is done but if like my husband you are an employee then you work the hours set, (or longer as my husband did as he wouldn't leave a job half done!). Someone has to feed the stock every day no matter what and that someone has to know the stock to know when one is unwell etc. Most people don't credit farming as a skilled occupation but it is. How many people can lamb a sheep, calve a cow, build a stone wall, lay a hedge, mend tractors etc all in the same day. these things take time to learn properly, colleges just don't cover all these skills with enough attention to make sure the students are proficient enough to do the job. Most people wouldn't work for the money most agricultural workers are paid for the dirty and often dangerous work that is done daily on a farm. Where on earth would you find more staff with these skills?

Callistemon Thu 14-Nov-19 12:31:13

newnanny some change is good but constant change causes stress and does in fact cost (waste) so much public money.
I returned to permanent work in the mid 1980s and there appeared to be nothing but constant change, none of it seemingly for the better.

Callistemon Thu 14-Nov-19 12:32:25

Just wondering if we are ultimately heading towards a rolling 7 day week, who is going to look after the children at weekends or are teachers expected to do that on top of everything else we are expected to do?
The grandparents, of course, those baby boomers who have had so much from the state (apparently)!

growstuff Thu 14-Nov-19 12:32:27

I'm not claiming it's easy, but emergency services already work shifts. There are 168 hours in a week, so at least four people will be needed for 24/7 hour cover anyway. The problems just aren't the same.

Grandad1943 Thu 14-Nov-19 12:32:55

pipdog 100% agree with your above post. ?

Callistemon Thu 14-Nov-19 12:34:47

pipdog and don't get me started on farming - 5 am starts, sometimes working all night, then having to carry on the next day. Four day week? they do not have a clue about some people's working lives!!

growstuff Thu 14-Nov-19 12:37:17

Does anyone know what the Labour Party is actually proposing? It seems to me that people are making a lot of assumptions. It's clear that different systems would suit some jobs, but would be difficult, if not impossible, in others.

humptydumpty Thu 14-Nov-19 12:44:20

Further, can anyone enlighten me as to when the manifestos of both parties will appear?

Callistemon Thu 14-Nov-19 12:47:09

Only listening to he who is waiting in the wings to take over as PM/Leader of the Opposition, take your pick.
McDonnell.