Gransnet forums

News & politics

Looking back over the last decade, were many mistakes made by our politicians?

(31 Posts)
MarthaBeck Sat 16-Nov-19 12:57:11

In my view this is a question we need to consider and learn from for the future,

When the GE is over & historians write up all the facts about the last decade and also Brexit the damage will have already been done. Personally, I believe it will portray real horror stories of incompetence, errors & appalling deception. Rather, far too late then to stop UK being duped by extremists.

Looking back it’s easy to highlight the huge mistakes made by politicians during the last decade. Particularly, under funding of inflation for the NHS & Care services. Allowing homelessness, Child and OP poverty to get out of hand. I appreciate the need for some austerity measures. Though lack of urgency and getting priorities right such as tackling the acute depression in the North,Midland and other regions caused unnecessary hardship & poverty issues.

How, over that period we have allowed homelessness, the need for food banks and other social problems such as child care to escalate is appalling.

Far greater effort should have been made to stop Boardroom greed by taxing excess bonuses. Ensuring that overseas companies paid same taxes as UK businesses, stopped off shore tax havens. A complete review of our taxation was needed to ensure adequate funding, along with limiting the flow of funding for less essential such as Brexit.

The extra monies coming from those taxes and savings could and should have been used to tackle some of the real social needs, more for Care Services & inflation levels of funding for the NHS. It would have saved LA’s many headaches & also kept many who were in Care out of hospital, saving NHS more money. Though I doubt politicians will agree. Brexit unfortunately got in the way preventing many Minister from focusing effectively on our domestic infrastructure, their priorities were not properly focused.

That resulted in far too many urgent decisions being delayed, as we saw last week over the flooding. Unfortunately, the errors of the last decade do not make good reading. It will be interesting to see how the politicians hid their incredible ineptitude’s from the electorate in the coming weeks.

Could we have done better?

winterwhite Tue 19-Nov-19 11:57:07

Thanks for starting this thread, Martha. I agree with whoever said that involvement in the Iraq war was a major long-term mistake, tho more than your decade ago.

At home, the introduction of the academies system which has reduced accountability and not improved educational standards.

More generally short term thinking and quick fixes, instead of planned investment and improvement. (Did the 'ageing population' come as the unexpected factor that ministers seem to imply? Of course not.). Failure to implement the Dilnot report.

Ministers constantly changing departments - rushing to make their mark with 'innovations' that aren't funded long-term so don't work. The NHS and the justice system have been victims of this as well as education.

Tolerance of low standards of probity in public life.

varian Tue 19-Nov-19 15:13:14

I agree winterwhite. I think that short-termism is an overarching problem and to some extent it arises because of the FPTP voting system.

In spite of them not having got the support of the majority of electors, Tory and Labour Parties have alternated almost on the basis of "buggins turn" by gaining a disproportionate number of seats.

When they have an outright majority they can rule in a way which was once described as "elective dictatorship". Because they know their time is limited they plunge headlong into ill-thought-out schemes, mainly undoing whatever the last lot did, whilst continuing to blame them for everything which goes wrong.

If we had a proportional voting system, as most grown up democracies have, there would be far more coalition governments, shifting after an election a bit to the right or left, rather than hurtling to extremes. Having to co-operate and compromise with other parties should result in more carefully considered shifts in policy.

There are many immediate priorities for our politicians. Stopping brexit is the most important because only then will we be able to address all the pressing issues - the climate emergency, investing for our future, properly funding our public services and creating a fairer society, but I would also put electoral reform very high up on that list.

Tooting29 Tue 19-Nov-19 16:11:53

I agree with previous posts. The referendum was a big political mistake. Other mistakes the two party culture and the lack of willingness to work together in a cross party way, particularly for implementing reforms in social care. Arbitrary public funding cuts post 2010. Too much tinkering with the education system. Failure to reform police force - why do we have 49 different constabularies instead on one national police force. Tinkering with NHS rather than a real reform to get the best out of the service.

Rebellious Tue 19-Nov-19 22:14:48

I feel it would be quicker and easier to ask which decisions were not mistakes.

varian Wed 20-Nov-19 08:37:04

twitter.com/AndrewCornwall5/status/1197011331917983744?s=09