Gransnet forums

News & politics

Here's an opportunity for all the Leavers

(172 Posts)
MaizieD Thu 06-Feb-20 10:20:53

I see that Sajid Javiv intends to launch a 'Brexit Red Tape Challenge' with his budget He intends to invite the public to suggest ways in which Britian might diverge from the EU rule book according to the Financial Times.

So here's your chance to get your thinking caps on and let the Chancellor know what particularly irks you about EU rules.

Do share your thoughts with us because many Remainers are curious to know what red tape turned you against the EU...

Chestnut Sun 09-Feb-20 23:10:22

Good grief, just took a peek at this thread and sure enough, the same repetitive whingeing by the same people.

As Opal said, just bleating on and on and on and on and on.....

varian Sun 09-Feb-20 22:04:26

The gloating leavers should be reminded that the overwhelming polling evidence for the last three years showed a Remain majority and this was confirmed by the results of the EU parliament election and the GE in both of which most voters supported parties advocating Revoke or a People's Vote.

It is only because we live in a sham democracy that a party voted in by a minority end up with a big majority of MPs and drag us out of the EU against the will of the people.

Elegran Sun 09-Feb-20 21:45:03

Could you please list exactly which features you feel are being undermined, Opal? The features that make the UK so great? Then those who voted to remain can list the features that they would say made the UK great and are being undermined, and we can all work toward maintaining all the good things and transforming all the bad ones.

Carrying doubterswith you to help you towards a goal is not quite the same as "carrying" useless people on your back. You have to use a lot of tact and subtlety and persuade everyone that it was the right move, by demonstrating practical progress, if possible. That takes time.

Just telling them triumphantly to suck up a decision that they are highly sceptical about won't, in fact, persuade them that it will succeed, it is more likely to make them think that with such brutal people implementing it, there is going to be a lot of collateral damage.

varian Sun 09-Feb-20 21:38:49

Not half Maizie. 17m out of 67m is a lot less than half.

The gloating leavers may not yet understand what damage they have done. But they will in time.

Opal Sun 09-Feb-20 20:41:46

They've been moaning a lot for nearly four bloody years, time to suck it up and move on, eh?

MaizieD Sun 09-Feb-20 20:38:55

That's the price you pay for voting for something that half the country didn't want, Opal. You get to hear them moaning a lot...

Opal Sun 09-Feb-20 20:32:01

As I said, bleating on and on and on ..........

varian Sun 09-Feb-20 20:01:53

We were a great country as one of the most powerful and influential members of the European Union - the world's largest and most effective trading block.

But because 17m out of the 67m UK residents were fooled into voting leave in the fraudulent referendum of 2016 wd have tbrown that away.

Opal Sun 09-Feb-20 16:59:44

GGMK3 The best you can do is to make it work and try and carry those who didn't agree with you

I voted for what I thought (and still think) is best for our country, in line with the majority of those who voted. I fully intend to try making it work, and anyone with an ounce of common sense will do exactly the same. BUT don't expect me to "carry" those who bleat on and on with the same rhetoric and are constantly criticising and undermining everything that is great about the UK.

POGS Sun 09-Feb-20 16:20:25

GGMK3

'It's time to stop acting like spoilt children with your name-calling, etc., and act like an adult who one day may be walked through the ruins of this country just as the Germans were walked through the concentration camps if you allow your politicians to get this wrong. The right moves rest with the people holding those politicians to account.'
-
' I still believe was undemocratically and possibly illegally forced on us'
---
'The leave voters want something so badly they ignored the lies and lack of accountability. Now they must hold the politicians to account and stop the lies.'
--
'That is being an adult Oopsaminty, not telling others what their beliefs must be. That is 1984, Nazism, our own Civil War and all the dictatorships you can remember rolled into one.'
--

4 years of the same old, same old rhetoric.

Name calling, belief democracy only works when it is in the eye of the beholder and the offensive raising of Nazi Germany.

You lose the arguement / debate by continuing with a vendetta against those who exercised ' their ' right to vote in a democratic process in opposition to yourself if all you do is parrot, / mirror image those you chastise.

MaizieD Sat 08-Feb-20 16:27:31

He is a bit horrid to them but I do feel his pain...

We've even had bendy bananas on this thread.. Surely everyone knows by now that a bored Brussels Correspondent made that up? What was his name now...er.. Johnsomething wasn't it? hmm

varian Sat 08-Feb-20 14:29:46

Which EU law shall we get rid of now Brexit is done? Four calls to James O'Brien

www.lbc.co.uk/radio/presenters/james-obrien/which-eu-law-can-we-now-change-four-brexit-calls/

Why do these leavers keep phoning in only to demonstrate how clueless they are? Surely they should know by now that James O'Brien will run rings round them?

GracesGranMK3 Sat 08-Feb-20 11:13:40

I am not blaming them Oopsminty but neither am I one of them. I may admit one day that they were right or I may insist they visit the parts of the country decimated by the decision I still believe was undemocratically and possibly illegally forced on us. What I cannot do is change my uniform and try and escape to South America pretending I am something I am not.

The leave voters want something so badly they ignored the lies and lack of accountability. Now they must hold the politicians to account and stop the lies.

*The EU is not going back on what it said about a Canadian style agreement. It did not say anything of the sort, never has and it wasn't in the deal. Johnson signed up to the political declaration which said just the opposite. I imagine Johnson is someone who could gas-light a partner in just the same way to remove the blame from himself.

*There is nothing new about Spain having a veto over Gibraltar It was always the case and the members will always stand by a member state. We chose to be a 'third country'. Standing in the playground shouting "they're being mean" is not the way to run a country and campaigning is over.

*There is a need to admit to the fact that our economy will change and not in a good way for many. This can be ameliorated but may mean the sort of taxes Brexiteers did not vote for.

*We are unlikely to be able to roll over all the trade deals we had through the EU and new deals are unlikely to offset the losses. True Brexiteers have said this is not what leaving was about but they need to admit it is likely to happen and work out how to protect those who are affected.

That is being an adult Oopsaminty, not telling others what their beliefs must be. That is 1984, Nazism, our own Civil War and all the dictatorships you can remember rolled into one.

Leavers must now stand up, be counted and stop the catchphrases and empty rhetoric. There is much to do and it needs doing fast.

Greta Sat 08-Feb-20 11:04:50

I certainly acknowledge that we are leaving the EU but I still think it was the wrong decision taken by a very small majority in a badly conducted referendum. I just hope that leave voters will now act responsibly and challenge the government. The leave vote per se does not guarantee that Brexit will be a success. Surely you can see that, Oopsminty? I just wish some posters would refrain from writing meaningless phrases such as ”We are all leavers now/ we won/we now all need to pull together etc.” It's no good hiding behind immature statements like that. They will get us nowhere but they do tell us something about the posters' choice of arguments.

Oopsminty Sat 08-Feb-20 10:53:12

And we've left

So the whole Leave /Remain thing is null and void

It's not a soundbite to point out the fact that we're Leavers

We've gone

Oopsminty Sat 08-Feb-20 10:48:35

Never assume!

But I'm not so malicious as to blame those who voted to Leave

It will all work out

And I'm being the adult here

GracesGranMK3 Sat 08-Feb-20 10:45:24

You simply cannot expect people to agree with that Oopsminty You presumably decided to leave. The best you can do is to make it work and try and carry those who didn't agree with you. Leavers are a grown-ups not children and you must stop throwing these cliches about. You need to get real.

We are not all "leavers"; that is over and can never change. We were either wanting to leave or not wanting to leave and that will not change. What those who have brought us to this point now have to do is show us, by holding their politicians to account, that it was worth and that means being honest about what can be achieved. The different world the Brexiteers in parliament wanted will not be good for everyone and you need to own that.

Saying "we are all leavers now" has no meaning and seems to infer some sharing of blame or shame. Work at being an adult in an adult world and making the best of it for heaven's sake and stop these silly sound bites. Get on with it; make it a success and you might be forgiven. That is the best you can hope for. You wanted your views to be taken into account now the work starts for you in following this up and holding your politicians to account.

Oopsminty Sat 08-Feb-20 10:20:29

It's time we understood that we're all Leavers now

GracesGranMK3 Sat 08-Feb-20 10:19:24

We are now at the point where the Brexiteer must get real if we are to have the best result we can from leaving Brexit. So far we have only lost - losing our seat at the table and our power to deal as part of a large trading group.

We do not want to hear about the top of the mountain stuff they pretend is possible any more. It now has to be real grown-up stuff where you don't look towards a rampant liar as your father figure. (I do worry about the childhoods' of those who voted for Johnson)

This is where you, the people who brought this upon us, take responsibility, question the politicians you voted for and understand that Little England - which we will surely become, cannot have everything it's own way just because it once had an empire or fought a war.

You are not victims of the "bad remainers". There is now no such thing. Blaming others for having a different view to yours has not convinced them and if you try this with countries or trading blocks we will simply become more isolated and a laughing stock.

You are not victims of a punishing EU. You are adults who wanted something (although most of us are still struggling to understand what) which many other countries will not want to give you without a decent two-way deal being struck. You cannot have it all your own way and you cannot keep blaming others.

It's time to stop acting like spoilt children with your name-calling, etc., and act like an adult who one day may be walked through the ruins of this country just as the Germans were walked through the concentration camps if you allow your politicians to get this wrong. The right moves rest with the people holding those politicians to account.

varian Fri 07-Feb-20 23:56:33

Divergence from EU regulations will lead to a huge increase in beaurocracy.

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/feb/07/brexit-regulation-britain-eu-agencies-sajid-javid

Chestnut Fri 07-Feb-20 23:21:25

I like Cheddar best.....ah now there's another story. ?

Oopsminty Fri 07-Feb-20 21:04:57

I hate Stilton

growstuff Fri 07-Feb-20 21:01:14

Defra has refused the application for cheese made in Stlton to be called Stilton - not the EU. I thought we were supposed to be respecting facts.

NotSpaghetti Fri 07-Feb-20 20:05:32

varian and chestnut
The tampon tax is on the way out.
It was discussed in 2018 and was on schedule to be gone by 2022.

MamaCaz Fri 07-Feb-20 19:58:35

Thank you MaizieD.
What you have found and pasted backs up what I imagined had to be the case: An application for a PDO or a PGI is first made to the authorities of the relevant Member State. It is judged by the Member State against the criteria in the Regulation and, if found to be acceptable, forwarded to the European Commission for final approval.

In other words, we in the UK have clearly initiated regulations that so many readily blame the EU for, a belief that Boris et al are only too keen to encourage to further their own aims.
Not that detractors will ever acknowledge this and stop blaming the EU, I bet!