Gransnet forums

News & politics

Do you beieve Hancock or NHS staff?

(180 Posts)
trisher Sun 12-Apr-20 11:43:56

According to Matt Hancock there are sufficient supplies of PPE equipment around. But the evidence from NHS staff contradicts that.
A third of UK surgeons and surgical trainees do not believe they have an adequate supply of personal protective equipment (PPE) in their trust, with wide regional variations, a survey has found.
More than half of those who responded (57%) to the Royal College of Surgeons (RCS) of England survey said there have been shortages in the past 30 days.
The survey of nearly 2,000 surgeons and trainees showed a postcode lottery when it comes to PPE. More than half (52%) of respondents in the Thames Valley said they now have access to adequate PPE, but that dropped to just over a third (34.7%) in the North West.
In London, which has been at the heart of the outbreak in the UK, a third (33.4%) of respondents said they do not believe their trust has an adequate supply of PPE.
^ survey was carried out after improved PPE guidance was issued by NHS England at the beginning of April ^
Sue Hill, RCS vice president, said:
The guidance is now much improved, but we have consistently said that advice about what protection to use for which medical procedures is rendered meaningless if the kit doesn’t reach the front line.
More than half of those responding to the survey also expressed scepticism about their chances of getting a Covid-19 test for themselves, should they need one.
Confidence was particularly low in the East of England, where 75% of surgeons said they believed they would not get access to a test.
One surgeon, who responded to the survey said:
The lack of mask wearing in general patient contact has been scandalous.
I caught Covid-19 from a patient on the ward who was pre-symptomatic but later tested positive. He infected at least six staff. One of my colleagues remains very sick from this.
I was denied a test even on appeal. We were ‘spoken to’ for wearing simple masks and gloves in general ward areas. We agreed to submit to authority but strongly disagreed that there was no risk.
The RCS is urging its members not to risk their health, and that of their patients, by carrying out risky procedures without adequate PPE

Sussexborn Sun 19-Apr-20 02:46:18

Not waiting around here but getting on making and supplying as much as we can both in small and large businesses and the general public. Doing an amazing job. I can’t sew or knit but have donated late MIL’s button tin.

Very few governments were fully prepared and ready but most are doing their best. My US health forum friends are very nervous as already in debt for copayment for their cancer treatment and now worrying how much the virus will cost them on top if they succumb.

I am concerned that it has now hit Africa and they are in a very serious position.

There will be all kinds of enquiries but not sure who would have done a better job. Certainly not labour who’ve been too busy squabbling, jostling and seemingly attempting to destroy any credibility in their party.

Hetty58 Sun 19-Apr-20 02:01:48

Of course there are shortages, on and off, day by day, in various hospitals. Ten days ago, the government amended (downgraded) the regulations to ameliorate the situation.

Now, it's fine to wear the same protective gear for a complete ward round (great, who cares?). There were warnings to not 'waste' stuff too.

Yet we're told that the situation is under control. Utter rubbish - political damage limitation at it's best. If in doubt, lie through your teeth. They must believe the public are idiots!

NotSpaghetti Sun 19-Apr-20 01:45:47

It’s not just the UK in a mess with PPE.
America, for example, has also been busy selling their stock to China as it was a “great business opportunity”

apple.news/AYZfEkqo9SrixBw3U0Eu6GQ

growstuff Mon 13-Apr-20 12:35:16

Never mind CleoPanda. The day can only get better! hmm
PS. Is it true that pandas only eat bamboo?

SirChenjin Mon 13-Apr-20 11:43:13

Not “people” - person.

CleoPanda Mon 13-Apr-20 11:32:12

@growstuff - in response to your criticism of my earlier post- you clearly did not read all the posts. Yes, people have said that all politician lie. Quote”-“All politicians lie (other than the one who has just stepped down). I don't believe any of them.”
Which was posted early on here.
You clearly have your incredibly strong and biased opinions and are unwilling to change an iota. I’ve known many people who are totally secure in their own opinions and refuse to consider other views or standpoints. Maybe you are as popular as they were?
Some people are happy to try to see other views and actually consider them. Others know they can never be wrong.

growstuff Mon 13-Apr-20 01:19:08

Presumably some has been used and some has passed its "sell by" date and hasn't been replaced.

SirChenjin Sun 12-Apr-20 23:39:40

Where the heck has it gone?? shock

Nandalot Sun 12-Apr-20 23:32:06

The Guardian has shown that the stockpile of emergency equipment in case of a pandemic has been reduced by nearly 40% over the last six years.
www.theguardian.com/world/2020/apr/12/revealed-value-of-uk-pandemic-stockpile-fell-by-40-in-six-years?CMP=share_btn_fb&fbclid=IwAR3EGYers9RKbQg-wezvh7sL2yQs3ecT4sURQBbL1V31Wi3ixE7_qZeeQ6o

growstuff Sun 12-Apr-20 23:25:58

Avalon It is totally unacceptable that there is anything wrong with the supply chain in any areas. This isn't some kind of lottery game.

Hancock has made promises in the past (40 new hospitals, 50,000 new nurses) and now 100,000 tests and goodness know how many ventilators. One missed target/broken promise is unfortunate, but a history of them is something else.

He and the chief nurse person lied to the public about why they couldn't answer the question about how many NHS staff have died. Even when he was forced to give a figure, he lied about the actual number, which is actually at least double the number he gave - and rising.

growstuff Sun 12-Apr-20 23:19:22

OK Shelmiss I made a mistake. One poster claimed everybody not on the front line lies. I certainly don't think every politician lies - and I suspect many other posters feel the same as I do. However, some politicians and their advisors certainly do lie and/or avoid telling the truth. They need to be held to account because it undermines trust, which is sorely needed at the moment.

I'm not sure whom "apart from one...obvs" refers to.

growstuff Sun 12-Apr-20 23:12:24

grannyactivist I suppose that might work if medics had very long arms hmm.

growstuff Sun 12-Apr-20 23:10:05

Well said patcaf.

Dinahmo Sun 12-Apr-20 17:24:10

NHS staff, definitely.

GagaJo Sun 12-Apr-20 16:50:45

Yes, FarNirth. I believe HIM.

trisher Sun 12-Apr-20 16:28:05

Thanks FarNorth what a dreadful situation.

FarNorth Sun 12-Apr-20 16:23:30

Recent tweet from a doctor :

"As a frontline NHS Oncology Doctor
With coronavirus
Because I had no protection
Racked with guilt I may have put patients at risk
STOP YOUR HYPOCRITICAL APPLAUDING AND GIVE US THE EQUIPMENT AND TESTS WE NEED
I have never been so tired angry & utterly ashamed of this Govt."

MaizieD Sun 12-Apr-20 16:18:36

@patcaf ?

patcaf Sun 12-Apr-20 15:43:45

The NHS staff. I have worked in NHS procurement. It is not complex and it is not new. Picking packs for hospitals by size and location is actually very simple. Hospital logistics is very well run and there are hundreds of couriers available at the moment. It is either not there or it has been centralized and it is sheer incompetence. I saw someone said the NHS managers would not lie. Believe you me they will lie about anything to maintain their positions.

Politicians may be doing their best but unfortunately their best is proving to be insufficient by a huge margin. Doing your best is an excuse for children not for senior politicians in a crisis.

SirChenjin Sun 12-Apr-20 15:38:08

Shelmiss the claim was that many posters believe all politicians lie.

vampirequeen Sun 12-Apr-20 15:37:57

Would those who feel that the government has done all it can and can't be blamed for ignoring the results of Operation Cygnus offer some evidence to support their argument? As far as I can see from the evidence offered it is clear that the government failed in it's duty to protect the population because it failed to act on the information it had amassed.

grannyactivist Sun 12-Apr-20 15:34:29

In the UK the military are past masters in both long-term storage and logistics. They keep a number of central stores (stockpiles) across the country that are equipped for all eventualities. New stock replenishes the goods that are issued and so items do not go 'out of date'. In an emergency they have the means to respond quickly and with the right equipment in the right place to be accessed as needed.

If a similar model was adopted by the NHS there would be no equipment perishing in stockpiles. Also, if the problem (in part) is that stock are not getting to where it's needed in a timely way, then I'd suggesting let the military take over the logistics rather than just have them haring about the country delivering hither and thither.

Until today (new guidance just been issued) the government advice regarding the need for PPE during patient contact was defined as being within 1 metre of a patient, it has now been revised in line with current good practice to 2 metres.

You can see straight away that the government guidance fell below what nursing staff perceived to be the threat level and why medics would want to wear PPE if they were within 2 metres of patients they're caring for - after all that fits in with government guidance for the general population.

Whitewavemark2 Sun 12-Apr-20 15:31:40

Former BBC journalist John Humphries is claiming that the journalists at the bbc are being told to go easy on ministers.

www.theneweuropean.co.uk/top-stories/john-humprys-on-bbc-presenters-during-coronavirus-1-6604475

Shelmiss Sun 12-Apr-20 15:31:02

Where did anybody make any of those claims CleoPanda? Nobody has claimed that all politicians lie every time they speak

Erm growstuff...read the second comment on this thread. Page 1. Apparently they nearly all do apart from one...obvs.

trisher Sun 12-Apr-20 15:21:07

Hang on if there is something wrong in the supply chain in some areas how can saying everything is OK not be lying? If he isn't lying does he simply not know what is happening? Is he that incompetent?