Gransnet forums

News & politics

Sir Kier Starmer has double standards?

(69 Posts)
GrannyGravy13 Mon 25-May-20 10:28:01

Several Labour MPs have broken lockdown and they have not been sacked...Stephen Kinnock 400 mile round trip to visit parents.
Ali has attended funeral mass gatherings
Gething rewrote Welsh lockdown rules after he was caught.
Corbyn not observing over 70’s lockdown.

Callistemon Mon 25-May-20 15:14:15

I never thought I'd defend Jeremy Corbyn but I wondered how he broke the lockdown? What did he do?
Over 70s were advised to stay at home, as was everyone who wasn't an essential worker apart from for exercise and shopping for essentials.
Only those with a shielded letter were told not to go out.

Sir Keir Starmer can't sack MPs, only Shadow Cabinet Ministers from their Shadow Cabinet posts.

Whitewavemark2 Mon 25-May-20 14:31:56

Someone suggested that Cummings mode of dress is attention seeking.

That does have more than a ring of truth about it.

MayBee70 Mon 25-May-20 14:23:34

Do those people that have a problem with the way Keir Starmer dresses not feel horrified that the man that is effectively running the country dresses like a vagrant most of the time. And his puppet PM doesn’t look a great deal better: the words hedge backwards springs to mind.

Hetty58 Mon 25-May-20 14:06:24

Witzend, yes, people are flouting the rules. There is only 80% compliance.

It's an entirely different matter when those who should lead by example just don't bother to.

Witzend Mon 25-May-20 13:44:04

Personally I think all this ‘outrage’ has got completely out of hand, esp. when so many people - inc. my next door neighbours - are flouting the rules on a regular basis.

Yes, I know such people as DC should obey the rules they themselves have set, but FGS, if we still had public hangings there’d be a screaming crowd out there cheering the hangman - it’s really not pleasant to see all this baying for blood. Anyone would think that the entire population but DC had been scrupulously observing the rules.

And so what if DC does happen to have a relative close by? It doesn’t follow at all that that relative - or anybody else - would be both willing and able to take on full time care of a child who’s been living with parents now too ill with the virus to do it.

So many people are talking as if childcare in such circs.would be a piece of cake to organise.

Dinahmo Mon 25-May-20 13:41:54

Of course I am aware that the curve is flattening. However, I happen to think that it could have happened sooner. Curve flattening began in other countries before ours. I suppose you could call it a success. On the scale of 0 - 10? Bottom half I think.

Track and trace had started soon after the first cases. The govt then cancelled it for reasons not necessarily apparent but possibly because of Cummings' suggestions about herd immunity. They are now starting it again.

Johnson could/would not answer Starmer's questions about it during PMQs last week. Instead he insisted that it would be up and running by 1 June and it was going to be world beating. This despite the app in tested in the Isle of Wight not working too well. This was the app developed by the company owned by Cummings relatives.

I can only conclude that some people have short memories when it comes to the actions of this government.

Roni Mon 25-May-20 13:30:07

Was Cummings a guinea pig for the tracking system?

Also heard that either he or his wife have family in London who could have provided emergency care for their child if needed (also has staff) - this actually was not needed as they were not seriously ill. Also how many times did he visit Durham etc.?

GillT57 Mon 25-May-20 13:21:00

Crikey, is this the best that the Boris fan club can come up with? A load of whataboutery and smears about how Starmer wears his jacket. I don't know why anyone is surprised by what has happened over the past few days, this is what you get when you elect a liar and cheat into office. He is sneering at us all, and many people are bound to feel hurt that they have been fooled by this serial liar.

MaizieD Mon 25-May-20 13:19:04

He was in the House of Commons Chamber for a PMQ, maybe 2 or 3 PMQs. Can't remember the details. It may have been before Starmer was elected when he was still LOTO. I think that would count as a necessary journey, to go to Wesminster for PMQs when you're LOTO. Wouldn't you?

Anyway, it's now established we can all break the rules if we think it's necessary.

Lucca Mon 25-May-20 13:13:02

Corbyn not observing over 70s lockdown .I missed that.

But in any case so what? everyone agrees people should not break the rules but someone instrumental in setting up those rules ?

Grandad1943 Mon 25-May-20 13:05:38

Elliegran Quote [ The government has flattened the curve and deaths are reducing. I would call that success.] End Quote.

Elliegran, it has not been this government who have reduced the infection rate and through that the number of deaths. It is the conventional people of this nation making changes and sacrifices in their daily lives that has brought about the forgoing.

Those people followed the regulations that this government laid down, but of course, we all now know that some attached to this government do not believe those regulations apply to them.

In the above the action by Cummings now threatens the whole credibility of the lockdown, social distancing and all else that has reduced the infection rate.

Face it Elliegran what has been carried out by Cummings in the eyes of the vast majority within this nation is indefensible.

MaizieD Mon 25-May-20 12:36:08

Well, Hetty, they flattened the curve that was much larger than it should have been because they delayed lockdown by a good three weeks...

Some people's bar for 'success' appears to be a rather low one...

Evoha16 Mon 25-May-20 12:34:51

Hello Elliegran - aka Morag - et al - doing what any reasonable parent would do? Defending the indefensible ?

GrannyGravy13 Mon 25-May-20 12:33:50

I have just posted on another thread that if all the the other sightings of DC are proven he should fall on his sword.

I have mixed thoughts regarding going to stay in a lodge on his parents property, because I would do anything for any of my children or grandchildren if I thought it was the correct thing for the child (We have several children on the spectrum in our family and they would not be comfortable/or manage to stay with all family or friends)

Hetty58 Mon 25-May-20 12:31:58

Elliegran, can we have an example of:

'The government is doing a very difficult job and doing it well.'

anything will do?

Galaxy Mon 25-May-20 12:28:54

Elliegran would my children have been safer in the uk or in germany?

trisher Mon 25-May-20 12:27:29

I really don't get this GG13 are you suggesting that the leader of a party not in power should sack elected representatives while the leader of the party in power refuses to sack an employee? Have you never heard of democracy? MPs are answerable to their constituents. Cummings is answerable to Johnson. That's the difference FFS.

Willow10 Mon 25-May-20 12:26:59

Would, not wold!confused

Elliegran Mon 25-May-20 12:25:38

Willow 10 I agree with you. Time to move on and look at the bigger picture.

Elliegran Mon 25-May-20 12:22:24

Dinahmo obviously you belive everything you read in the press. The government has flattened the curve and deaths are reducing. I would call that success.

Willow10 Mon 25-May-20 12:20:23

I'm not affiliated to any political party, in fact I think they are all a complete waste of space and tax, only in it for their own ends. But am I the only one who thinks this baying for blood has gone far enough? He's not a mass murderer for goodness sake! Anyone else wold be reprimanded by the police and fined. Why does he have to lose his job? Oh sorry, of course - it's all about egos and power shuffling as usual. What a bunch of hypocritical, backstabbing 'colleagues ' they have turned out to be. And them all being so perfect, naturally. Can't they give the guy a break and move on for goodness sake! Or is this just a cover up story for something actually serious going on?

Dinahmo Mon 25-May-20 12:16:59

Elliegran where have you been for the last few weeks? Have you not seen the tv or newspapers?

I think that the majority of people on GN at the moment don't think that the govt. is doing a good job, judging by the comments on this and other threads.

Personally I think that Starmer's demeanor is correct, especially when dealing t=with the PM at PMQs

GGumteenth Mon 25-May-20 12:10:28

SOCIALISTS .dont believe in the Honours system or titles ,well not any socialists I grew up with ,maybe English "socialists" have different standards ?

Is that a rule or a law?

Galaxy Mon 25-May-20 12:02:56

Well that was an insightful political debate.

Elliegran Mon 25-May-20 12:00:11

I just wish Starmer would remember to take the coat hanger out of his jacket before he puts it on. He is so stiff and starchy.
Sick of hearing the bleats from the loony Lefties and Remoaners on here. The government is doing a very difficult job and doing it well.