Black Lives Matter versus All Lives Matter

I share your fear GrannyGravy

I have just read this on Twitter and it does feel very apt censoring things in the name of political correctness will lead to more extremism than ever before

I hope with all my heart that we can stop before we reach the cliff edge where the only way is down!!!

There does seem to be a lack of levelheadedness and judgement which tbh always happens as a reaction.

BLM certainly have not called for these to be axed it is ONLY the decision of the companies.

The way things are going,it seems now like only black lives matter,it is madness now,pulling TV programmes and changing street names
So many people are so fed up with how this is going they are losing sympathy,

I think it is very dangerous to judge drama/comedy/writings from years ago by today's standards.

The majority of the Worlds Nations are built on pasts that we know would not and should not be acceptable in 2020.

By destroying and hiding away anything that a section of society feels uncomfortable with (we should all be uncomfortable with slavery) puts us all on a very slippery slope that has not got an end in sight.

Do you think it's going a bit far now with UKTV pulling the episode in Faulty Towers Don't mention the war, because of radial slurs ?

And Gone With The Wind Mammy was the first black woman to receive an oscar ?

And other comedy shows.

Where did I say ‘a whole generation’?

I see Farage has gone from LBC with immediate effect, proving what we have known all along that his brand of politics is racist

So if we know all lives matter but one group is saying "we don't feellike our lives matter" then we should be looking into why that is the case and fixing the issue. Then we can say all lives matter because it is true.

We already know all lives matter. No one would be saying it if black people hadn't asked for their lives to matter too.

Issues need to be dealt with seperately to be heard.

When we remember 911 you don't hear people shouting ALL BUILDINGS MATTER

When we have breast cancer awareness people don't shout ALL CANCERS MATTER

When someone breaks their leg you don't shout at them ALL BROKEN BONES MATTER

We already know those things matter.

Issues need to be dealt with seperately to understand themand deal with them.

Excellent post Tooting29. My concern is the anarchy we are seeing on the streets. Pulling down statues by mobs cannot be right if we are a civilised country. People will take matters into their own hands to protect the statues and many will be hurt, including the police. I am disgusted that the media are trying to rile everybody up. There needs to be a serious review where everybody can have a voice. We are already trying to adjust our lives to deal with the pandemic and now we have this to cope with.

Growstuff I don't think that generalising and calling a whole generation racist is actually going to promote much racial harmony.

Sparkling I agree with you entirely. And before I am branded a generational racist. I will set the context of my experience. I am white 60+. I am fortunate to have mixed race nieces and nephews who have brought a wealth of diversity to our family, we enjoy their culture and fully embrace it. And yes they have faced racism in their lives and this is wrong and is challenged. Their lives matter. At some point in the past they have a slave connection and they and we continue to educate the younger generations. I also have a very close gay friend, who faced prejudice and fear for her career in the late 70s if her sexuality had been known. She still faces abuse and her life matters. I have a granddaughter who is also gay and her and her partner have to deal with paint daubed on their house and abuse frequently. Their lives matter. Their child our great granddaughter may have to face bullying or comment at school as her family does not fit the norm. Her life matters. Lastly I had an autistic and epileptic step son, who faced difficulties and prejudice from people who did not understand his condition. His life mattered. I have another friend who has been seriously overweight all her life, she has faced abuse and judgement and assumptions made on her appearance. Her life matters.
I am proud that my children and grandchildren have been raised to embrace different cultures and accept people as they are. We cannot change history, but we must learn from it. We can protest and pull down statutes, and have the conversation. We can legislate but until all hearts and minds recognise that everyone's life is valued then no further progress will be made.

Furret I know. It's visible.

Sadly growstuff there is so much ingrained racism in our generation that many just don’t ‘get’ it,

I am fed up with people who can't even acknowledge that there is still racism in the UK.

I'm not claiming that it's as bad as it was in the past, but history hasn't stood still. There is still plenty of room for improvement.

What on earth are you on about Sparkling. There are so many muddled (and inaccurate) thoughts in your post that you have completely lost me.

Are you aware of the racist abuse many black football players experience? Why do you think that is?

I agree with you Sparkling.

Has anybody read the Vision on the Black Lives Matter website.

I'm afraid all this will back fire. We are supposed to read something into everything, we will be frightened to think next. What happened was police brutality and a failure of the system in Americia, not here. we have most football teams with successful black players and lots in the music industry. All lives do matter Sue, don't tell me that there is a hidden agenda in that statement because there isn't. Where were our rights when the soldier was beheaded, didn't his life matter. I am fed up by all these isms people take people as they are, not to tiptoe round every comment uttered.

While you read the Trump Bible Kapitan?

Franbern, time to pick up your well thumbed copy of The Thoughts of Chairman Corbyn, settle down on the Beanbag, and read yourself to sleep dreaming of the glorious revolution that never happened. Night, night.

"Black Lives Matter" as an organisation is about "Black Lives Matter as much as every other Life"!!

It is NOT about "Black Lives are more important" or "Other Lives don't Matter"

It is NOT disputing that All Lives Matter just saying that Black Lives Matter just as much!!!!

Tooting29 how can you not get it? Black people have been enslaved and dehumanised in the past and still today are discriminated against. They are not asking for anything more than anyone else, they simply want to be afforded the same rights and privileges as everyone else.

Try thinking of it as ‘Black Lives Matter as much as white lives do’. When a man can casually be killed on camera by the very people who should be keeping the peace, there’s something wrong in this world. It’s not as if George Floyd is the only one. The statistics tell the whole story.