Gransnet forums

News & politics

Where are the Tory supporters who seem shy in defending the government?

(204 Posts)
Whitewavemark2 Tue 21-Jul-20 14:11:43

Over the Russia report

Tory corruption

No protection for the NHS

No protection for our food standards

No Parliamentary scrutiny of any trade deal.

I’m sure some must think it’s all excellent?

Whitewavemark2 Fri 24-Jul-20 12:47:08

Grandad1943

I would consider myself far left in many of my political views. However, this Conservative government has carried out far-left actions by way of paying the wages and salaries of nearly ten million furloughed workers for over for months now.

Other countries have carried out similar to the above, but the fact that such action came from a Tory government in Britain was remarkable to say the least.

As a affiliated member of the Labour Party making monthly subscriptions to that body, I still applaud what this government has done, for that is true far left socialist action.

I do not expect this Tory government to continue in the same manner over throughout the next four years, but I will gladly accept true socialist policies wherever they may come from.

Grandad that’s not far left!! It is Keynesian economics.

Neither is it remarkable. They had absolutely no choice in the matter.

Dinahmo Fri 24-Jul-20 12:42:01

Grandad perhaps your age is getting to you (wink) My FIL was Labour all his life until Thatcher came upon the scene and he thought she was wonderful. Wouldn't hear a word said against her. And his father was a Socialist - an alderman and Sheriff of Nottingham.

Grandad1943 Fri 24-Jul-20 08:16:06

I would consider myself far left in many of my political views. However, this Conservative government has carried out far-left actions by way of paying the wages and salaries of nearly ten million furloughed workers for over for months now.

Other countries have carried out similar to the above, but the fact that such action came from a Tory government in Britain was remarkable to say the least.

As a affiliated member of the Labour Party making monthly subscriptions to that body, I still applaud what this government has done, for that is true far left socialist action.

I do not expect this Tory government to continue in the same manner over throughout the next four years, but I will gladly accept true socialist policies wherever they may come from.

MrsMcG Thu 23-Jul-20 21:51:06

I would be really interested to discover which 'far left' views Sparkling is referring to
I am a Socialist, that doesn't make me far left, it makes me left of centre
This Government is 'far right ', powered by the ERG. Traditional Tories have been turfed out to accommodate them
I would be interested in a genuine discussion with Conservative voters, who are happy to support them and their dogma
Are you comfortable with DC's input? Is this really what you voted for?
Do you support the voting down of the amendment to protect the NHS?
Would you still have voted for them, if in hindsight, you had known all this would transpire?

NotTooOld Thu 23-Jul-20 21:11:07

Oh dear. I suspect most supporters of the government are sensibly keeping their heads well down!

biba70 Thu 23-Jul-20 21:01:29

Sparkling - could you kindly give this newcomer an example of a 'sensible comment' about the performance of this Government? I find it hard to imagine, somehow.

varian Thu 23-Jul-20 20:08:55

The tragedy is that we seem to have no way of removing the traitors who may be in government for the next four years and are intent on ruining the country to enrich themselves and their kind.

Curlywhirly Thu 23-Jul-20 19:39:31

GillT57 me too. I can't understand why some people show such slavish devotion to their party. There is no shame in supporting a party, and being able to recognise and criticise when they make a bad decision. I wasn't happy that at yesterday's PMQT Keir Starmer didn't mention the defeat of the Amendments regarding animal welfare and protecting the NHS in a US trade deal, big mistake. Whoever you support, there will always be some decision that are unpopular and you don't agree with, there is no need to try and defend the indefensible - you are kidding nobody.

GillT57 Thu 23-Jul-20 19:06:58

No comment about furloughing I notice, no comment about calling out China 's flagrant disregard for the HongKong treaty,the origin of this virus, and of course the appalling treatment of Chinese Muslims. Heartless government indeed!

Au contraire. I think that some of the decisions made by some of the cabinet have been very good and are to be supported, you see I know the difference between slavish devotion to or hatred of a party and consideration of how they are performing in office. This current shambles are unfit to govern, many should be prosecuted, and I would day the same if they were a Labour administration.

MayBee70 Thu 23-Jul-20 18:50:37

I think the current government is so far right that anyone slightly left of centre (which, IMO most people opposed to this government seem to be) are now regarded as extremists.

Curlywhirly Thu 23-Jul-20 09:49:45

Oh for goodness sake, it's not just the far left derailing threads, I think there are plenty derailing comments made by the far right too!

Lucca Thu 23-Jul-20 09:40:31

Sparkling

As Ive said before on this forum, all sensible posts are derailed by far left views, so I don't bother.

I disagree. As I see it Conservative supporters come up against strong opposition that’s all, it doesn’t mean thread is derailed nor that the opposing posters are “far left “. For example I think the present government are doing an appalling job but I can absolutely assure you I am not far left having voted Lib Dem forever.

Sparkling Thu 23-Jul-20 09:26:30

As Ive said before on this forum, all sensible posts are derailed by far left views, so I don't bother.

Tooting29 Wed 22-Jul-20 20:20:14

Probably got more sense than be a target for Tory bashing

Greta Wed 22-Jul-20 20:01:01

Jabberwok: ”No comment about furloughing I notice, no comment about calling out China 's flagrant disregard for the HongKong treaty,the origin of this virus, and of course the appalling treatment of Chinese Muslims. Heartless government indeed!”

Furlough: The Government implemented a furlough scheme similar to that of many other nations. They had no choice.

China: The following countries have critized China: Australia, Austria, Belgium, Canada, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Iceland, Ireland, Japan, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, and the UK.

vegansrock Wed 22-Jul-20 19:54:56

Emperor’s new clothes

vegansrock Wed 22-Jul-20 19:54:26

Definitely a case of empowered new clothes...

GagaJo Wed 22-Jul-20 19:53:15

grannyrebel7

When will all these working class people who voted Tory come to their senses? Why on earth did they think the Tories would do anything for them? Tories are only interested in the elite not the shop worker, the postman or the factory worker for example. Trouble is the working class have become a little more affluent and they think their status is a little higher so they vote Tory. Idiots!

Exactly grannyrebel7. I have a lovely friend, voted Tory. Volunteers to work in a food bank and decries the rise in poverty and hunger over the last few years. NEVER links her vote with the social deprivation in her area even though she's an older lady and lives in an area decimated by Thatcher.

I don't like to ask if she voted Tory in the 1980s too.

Jabberwok Wed 22-Jul-20 19:08:00

No comment about furloughing I notice, no comment about calling out China 's flagrant disregard for the HongKong treaty,the origin of this virus, and of course the appalling treatment of Chinese Muslims. Heartless government indeed!

trisher Wed 22-Jul-20 18:20:59

When the only reply from Conservative voters is that they don't engage because the OP wasn't phrased properly or they don't like the OP you realise that they are totally unable to post anything good about this government. A government which seem to be based on the concept that they will say anything but do the opposite. So they assert that there is protection in law already for the NHS and food but defeat an amendment which woud have made this absolutely clear. If there is the provision they claim they could have abstained or permitted a free vote. But if someone can explain exactly why they had to defeat the amendment I would be interested.

Lucca Wed 22-Jul-20 18:04:19

CraftyGranny

Just as an opinion:

I have noticed that "the usual suspects", when on anything but polical threads are really nice people. But, suddenly become the Incredible Hulk when on polical threads, or dare I say Incredible Sulks.

Just saying!

Yes. Works both ways.

Gajahgran Wed 22-Jul-20 17:55:52

What short memories you have, those that say the Conservatives do not support the workers. They have just supported those that were furloughed.

And no Hetty58 we are not dead because we were sensible enough to follow the Government guidelines.

CraftyGranny Wed 22-Jul-20 17:51:41

Just as an opinion:

I have noticed that "the usual suspects", when on anything but polical threads are really nice people. But, suddenly become the Incredible Hulk when on polical threads, or dare I say Incredible Sulks.

Just saying!

Hetty58 Wed 22-Jul-20 17:22:10

Whitewavemark2

'Where are the Tory supporters who seem shy in defending the government?'

Dead maybe - or they've (finally) realised that the people they voted for were quite willing to sacrifice them during the pandemic?

Greta Wed 22-Jul-20 17:02:21

Grannyrebel7:
Quote: "When will all these working class people who voted Tory come to their senses? Why on earth did they think the Tories would do anything for them?" End Quote

The Tories did do something for them. They delivered Get Brexit Done! I believe the GE was a Brexit election. Promises of money to the NHS, Take Back Control, promises to stop EU immigrants taking our jobs were all that was needed for many working class people to vote Tory. They didn't need/want to know more.
Will they come to their senses? I'm afraid I think it could become rather nasty when they do.