Gransnet forums

News & politics

Populism on a sharp decline

(70 Posts)
Whitewavemark2 Tue 27-Oct-20 10:13:05

I think the other thing with populism is that it is generally adopted by the more extreme politics.

So in both the U.K. and USA there is the most right wing government that we have had since I can’t remember.

The extreme left populist are characterised by leaders like Hugo Chevaz

Alexa Tue 27-Oct-20 10:10:36

Populism is the lie that dictators tell the people, that they are better than all politicians who are lying cheating thieves.

EG Mr Trump tells that to his devotees via Twitter. The devotees take Mr Trump's bait and think "Trump is the one and only Hero Man who will champion the people against corrupt politicians".

GagaJo Tue 27-Oct-20 09:35:58

It would make sense. But turkeys vote for Christmas all the time. They then spend the next 4/5 years complaining about Christmas, but make no link to their vote.

I do, however, want to see whoever is in power at least pay lip service to the commitments they made to their country. I think we're in a bad way when the politicians don't even attempt to cover up their corruption.

I hope against hope that Trump will be out, but I read a report by a pollster that has been correct in almost all of his predictions and he predicts another Trump win.

I'm glad I am old. Not too much longer to tolerate such corruption, but I do worry for my grandson. He fits about every category that the right wing hate.

varian Tue 27-Oct-20 09:27:40

One aspect of populism is the rejection of experts, described as the elite. The pandemic has proven the need for expertese, showing us how much we rely on doctors, researchers, statisticians, epidemiologists, and ultimately how much our survival may depend on the work of virologists and vaccine developers.

All but the most abject knuckle dragging populists can see that they were wrong to ignore the experts and allow their gut instincts to be manipulated.

It is no coincidence that the countries which elected populist leaders have suffered very badly from the incompetence of their governments during the pandemic.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 27-Oct-20 09:18:13

To my mind it is a parasitic ideology that sits on the back of mainstream ideologies which are themselves grounded in a wide systematic set of beliefs

Whitewavemark2 Tue 27-Oct-20 09:06:48

The point is it is about division, and I would have thought that most right thinking folk can see that it does nothing for the country setting people against people and should always be rejected

Whitewavemark2 Tue 27-Oct-20 09:05:35

Urmstongran

Everything the left don’t like!

Nope you can have populist left leaning governments as well as right leaning

Whitewavemark2 Tue 27-Oct-20 09:03:28

25Avalon

What do you mean by populism?

It has a specific meaning in politics.

It is a concept that is seen as worshipping the people, but beyond that it is a very “thin” ideology. So it doesn’t provide answers to every political theory, but it does provide a divisive background to any one of the mainstream political ideologies.

It is often used to define what is seen as “the people” against the elite. So it is an ideology of division, setting what it terms as the virtuous will of the people against the corrupt elite. It is used in any area that is useful to divide the population.

It has grown in Europe probably since the 80s and instances can be found where it has targeted immigrants and national minorities.

And you have heard that rhetoric from both Trump and Johnson. Farage of course. Brexit was a prime example, and Johnson used the rhetoric throughout the last election.

sodapop Tue 27-Oct-20 09:01:04

I agree with your last paragraph lemongrove so many amateur diagnosticians on here.
Autism, depression, narcissism, OCD are bandied around without any real concept of how devastating these conditions can be. I think sometimes that posters asking for advice must get frightened to death by these comments.
There are people as you say who are just selfish, bad, or uncaring but we seem afraid to say this and hide behind labels.

lemongrove Tue 27-Oct-20 08:51:19

It’s what we see and hear about daily Iam64 and it has been building for a long time.
In politics, and in the general public, feelings and sentiment have taken precedence over caution,truth, and common sense. In some things, this can be be for good reasons and have good outcomes, in others ...not so much.
Everyone is an expert now it seems, and emotion in anything at all is lauded.
All the diagnosing that goes on here on the forum about mental health is a sign of this too, ‘he’s a narc!’ ‘She is toxic’ kind of thing. Sometimes ( to misquote Freud) sometimes being selfish is just being selfish.

Urmstongran Tue 27-Oct-20 08:48:25

Everything the left don’t like!

25Avalon Tue 27-Oct-20 08:40:27

What do you mean by populism?

Iam64 Tue 27-Oct-20 08:39:54

I hope you're right whitewave, about a rejection of the Trump/Johnson type politics.

I'm interested in lemongrove's view, that 'emotional responses (from everyone) seems to be increasing'. My current irritation is towards self diagnosis of serious m.h. problems such as anxiety state, or clinical depression. Often what people are describing are uncomfortable feelings of sadness, or worry. Is that what you meant lemon? It goes without saying, that I am in no way dismissing the significance of feelings but a feeling is a different thing than a genuine diagnosis of a serious m.h. problem.

I've probably gone right off piste here

Urmstongran Tue 27-Oct-20 08:38:02

It does make great sense Petra. When people are scared they cling to what they know to feel safe.

lemongrove Tue 27-Oct-20 08:31:18

That makes sense Petra

petra Tue 27-Oct-20 08:25:24

Urmstongran & Lemongrove
It also stated ( in the Guardian) that these anti votes probably a backlash against their governments reaction to covid and the populists were more than likely to rise again when it's over.

petra Tue 27-Oct-20 08:21:05

you-gov survey 25 countries throughout Europe
The Guardian article I read states that 25 countries across the world were surveyed but only 8 of them were in Europe.

lemongrove Tue 27-Oct-20 08:17:46

Just wishful thinking whitewave as from what I see and read about, emotional responses ( from everyone!) seems to be increasing.

Urmstongran Tue 27-Oct-20 08:13:26

I still predict a win for Trump.
The voters are turning out in force o that’ll upend the poll predictions anyway.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 27-Oct-20 07:52:12

You-gov survey in 25 countries throughout Europe shows that people are rejecting key statements of populism.

Good.

(Probably because they look at the failing government in the U.K.)

People are rejecting emotional responses in favour of listening to experts, like scientist and facts.

I think the decline will get a big boost if Trump loses as well.

Johnson will be on the wrong side of history.