Gransnet forums

News & politics

How confident are you in a good deal for the UK?

(875 Posts)
Trisha57 Fri 04-Dec-20 22:48:56

Just that really. Watching the News tonight and it seems there are conflicting views, as always.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 08-Dec-20 16:37:27

Appears a deal has been reached on NI. Hopefully details will be clearer later.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 08-Dec-20 16:33:02

Good news.

The government has jettisoned the Internal Markets Bill clause.

Some sense and pulling back from breaking international law.

Jaberwok Tue 08-Dec-20 15:59:25

Lemon, you are so right. how ridiculous of me to respond/react to such nonsensical, childish rather sad comments. In future they will be firmly ignored! Good news is that Christmas visits are sorted without causing offence to anyone, always a slightly tricky area! So,up with that tree, on with those lights and good cheer all round! Love the picture Firecracker!

Firecracker123 Tue 08-Dec-20 14:50:54

Starmer doing what comes naturally lol

Sitting on the fence

petra Tue 08-Dec-20 14:17:57

biba70
Wrong again. From the beloved Gaudian www.theguardian.com/politics/2020/dec/05/military-planes-to-fly-vaccines-in-to-britain-to-avoid-ports-hit-by-brexit

biba70 Tue 08-Dec-20 13:46:30

Urmstongran, I do believe, like Raab, that you have forgotten the UK is an Island.

Very different to the other EU countries who can stick together and move import and export to each other without borders, crossing seas, tedious paperwork, massive delays or tariffs. Plus the will to support each other and work together. In times of shortages, as Covid will cause for all- they will prioritise each other. For medicines, chemicals for water treatment, oxygen, and millions of other essential stuff we just cannot or do not produce.

The fact this Goverment is planning to Airlift the vaccine with military planes (that is if the EU allows the UK into their air space, and military planes even more so) - should tell you all you need to know.

MayBee70 Tue 08-Dec-20 13:38:23

No but they’re the ones that have headlines saying that the Queen supports brexit and that some members of the judiciary are traitors etc etc..

petra Tue 08-Dec-20 13:32:57

MayBee70
Not all anti eu articles are in the mail and sun.
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/oct/10/brexit-leaving-eu-farming-agriculture

lemongrove Tue 08-Dec-20 13:32:40

Life will go on and for the future it’s good to think how we can do things differently.Some Remainers do think that way but some seem determined to be as pessimistic as possible.
Enjoy your Christmas break from politics Urm ?

Urmstongran Tue 08-Dec-20 13:21:04

Nope. Just my own musings this morning MayBee validated to some extent by people (out and about Christmas shopping if they can) what is their main concern at the moment.

Nothing to do with the Daily Mail or the Guardian.

Heartening really to realise that yes, this Brexit is big, but made me realise life will go on.

And for all the naysayers on here with facts, quotes and pie charts, I do fully respect your viewpoints. Our government has promised help to farmers and others in difficult situations where they can to support them through the transition.

Good news IS out there. It IS the season of goodwill.
We could try to join in. Be less abrasive and kinder on here and maybe less het up.

Just my opinion.

I’m staying off politics for a while. Let the dust settle. Anyway I need to go and write some Christmas cards and buy a tree this weekend when I’m out of quarantine!

‘Season’s Greetings’ to you all who contribute on politics and have made these threads so interesting and engaging this year. Seriously, I’ve enjoyed your company. We all brought something to the table.
? ? ???

lemongrove Tue 08-Dec-20 13:13:06

Good post Urmstongran ????

lemongrove Tue 08-Dec-20 13:11:37

Jaberwok....I realised ages ago that some pro EU posters will constantly trot out condescending and patronising posts and assure anyone who supports Brexit that their posts are
‘Silly’.Look at it this way.....it’s their only way of trying to put themselves on ‘the high moral ground’ by putting down posters with opposite views to themselves, and being so angry that we have left the EU.I feel sorry for them really, ( kind of).

MayBee70 Tue 08-Dec-20 13:00:13

So you’re saying that the majority of people didn’t pay much attention to the details of what they were voting for in the referendum then? Given that they’re not, in general all that interested in politics. Just Sun/Daily Mail headlines perhaps?

Urmstongran Tue 08-Dec-20 12:55:37

Agree biba that playing any kind of blame game is beyond silly. If no deal it is, we have got to agree to disagree as each side has red lines they can’t cross. So be it. Time to gear up and move on.

On another note, Covid has decimated the U.K. and Europe. Now the logistics of how to vaccinate millions of people are also on the front burner. And how (for the EU) to share out a €750 billion loan??

Yes Brexit is important but in the big sea of a pandemic maybe not so much. Us politico bods on here find it fascinating. The majority of the general public? Nah. They’re getting on with Tiers, Levels, mental health issues, shielding, loneliness and worrying in some cases about jobs. Christmas. Illness etc.

Life will go on. The world will turn. The sun will shine. The grass will still grow and one way or another people will adapt. It’s what we do.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 08-Dec-20 12:30:47

Jaberwok

Oh that big of you how very condesending! Perhaps you can supp!y some facts and figures to support your claim, then I might condesend to speak to you.

Don’t be silly

biba70 Tue 08-Dec-20 12:28:34

Peter Bone today saying Boris will 'charm' them all in Brussels. Oh my sad

and that if there is No Deal, it will be the fault of France, as historically the French are always at fault sad what an old fool.

Jaberwok Tue 08-Dec-20 12:26:37

Oh that big of you how very condesending! Perhaps you can supp!y some facts and figures to support your claim, then I might condesend to speak to you.

Jaberwok Tue 08-Dec-20 12:23:17

Must get that on catchup, I always enjoy listening to J.R speak. So much common sense and home truths make him a joy to listen to.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 08-Dec-20 12:21:54

Jaberwok

Oh I see! What a rude, patronising dismissive answer, only to be expected I suppose. Again, how do YOU know exactly how the majority of people are thinking? Answer is, you dont, it's as simple as that! Not wishing to lower myself to your level but who exactly is the silly one making sweeping, silly statements?!

It is your tendency to make your posts personal that I find silly, it does nothing to further the argument, and yes I do dismiss those sort of posts as not being worth taking part in.

Provide me with evidence that I am incorrect with moderate language and i will be happy to talk.

Jaberwok Tue 08-Dec-20 12:12:03

Oh I see! What a rude, patronising dismissive answer, only to be expected I suppose. Again, how do YOU know exactly how the majority of people are thinking? Answer is, you dont, it's as simple as that! Not wishing to lower myself to your level but who exactly is the silly one making sweeping, silly statements?!

Urmstongran Tue 08-Dec-20 12:09:16

Just been listening to John Redwood on SKY news (Adam Boulton wasn’t a happy bunny having to listen to listen to him - he nearly spontaneously combusted especially when Redwood asked him to stop interrupting (!) and let him answer the question - whilst pointing out that the opinions were already 2:1 - only him for Brexit - the tie straightener from Brussels and some high up bloke in the commerce industry were both pro-Eu). Actually Boulton apologised to Redwood at the end of the interviews (somebody in the control centre must have said something into his ear piece!).
?

Anyway I loved that Redwood was so on top of his facts! Pointed out that the biggest no-no for the EU was the level playing field and the fact that we might choose to do things differently (nimble vaccine roll out anybody?). He said look how it’s okay for the EU to prop up EU airlines etc. when we don’t. Our labour standards are superior, ditto animal welfare.

Look when we joined he said. Fishing had to be less for us, more for the EU. look at industries, less for us tenders out to EU and always more for them. The guy from Brussels looked a bit uncomfortable by this stage, more tie straightening ...

What is the point said Redwood of being hobbled to EU practices when we can once again choose to do things our way?

I cheered from the sidelines! It was wonderful to hear such positivity.

Boulton seemed a bit subdued by the end of it ...

Whitewavemark2 Tue 08-Dec-20 11:49:39

No support for no deal

David0205 Tue 08-Dec-20 11:38:36

Firecracker123

Yes No Deal / No Fish for the French fishermen that will certainly hurt them for a long time.

Your concern for the French Fishermen is touching, don’t worry their government will compensate them - eventually. Let them create havoc for a few weeks, then pay them off, French hauliers too probably

Whitewavemark2 Tue 08-Dec-20 11:37:54

David0205

It doesn’t matter what Labour do they can’t influence anything, it’s highly unlikely that the Tories will get 40+ rebel, although you can never say never. Johnson will be replaced fairly soon whatever the outcome he has been a millstone far too long already

I think the ERG are likely to rebel if there is a tiniest hint of compromise and if Labour voted against it would fall I think as there are about 80 ERG headbangers.

David0205 Tue 08-Dec-20 11:33:18

It doesn’t matter what Labour do they can’t influence anything, it’s highly unlikely that the Tories will get 40+ rebel, although you can never say never. Johnson will be replaced fairly soon whatever the outcome he has been a millstone far too long already