Gransnet forums

News & politics

How do we stop boys who become drunk being labelled as sex predators?

(273 Posts)
trisher Wed 31-Mar-21 11:16:28

I've been reading some of the posts on the everyone's invited website. The stories are shocking and disturbing, but one thing I found really worrying is how many of the incidents happen when a girl is drunk. These are often quite young girls -14 upwards. They seem to reach a state when they are passing in and out of consciousness and are then sexually assaulted by a boy. I know the boy shouldn't do it, but given that he is probably equally as drunk, and drink lowers inhibitions, is it then fair to label him a sexual predator? He might know and be very concious of the way to treat girls when he is sober, but alcohol affects everyone. It's something that worries me for both the girls and boys involved.

Peasblossom Fri 02-Apr-21 13:25:01

Barbados produced a report in 2019 about the issue of male abuse by females.

My parting post.

Peasblossom Fri 02-Apr-21 13:23:27

You only have to type in ‘women abusing boys’ into Google to come up with a whole raft of research and evidence, including the one I quoted.

But if you do, I have no doubt you’ll dismiss anything that doesn’t fit in with your established beliefs.

There we are, I’ve had my say. It hasn’t changed anything. I think we’ve reached an impasse, don’t you.

M0nica Fri 02-Apr-21 13:19:00

Trisher. watching drunks fighting, i would say even the slightest push by one drunk against another ends up with the two both reeling apart.

Galaxy Fri 02-Apr-21 13:12:51

I know there are quite a lot of teachers on this board and wonder how they feel about teachers addressing issues around consent, pornography etc in class. Would they feel equipped to do this (obviously I know they already provide sex education) or would they prefer this to be done by specialist services such as Barnardos etc.

suziewoozie Fri 02-Apr-21 13:06:57

Peasblossom

I found it on Google without having even the name of the university or the conference.

Along with much other similar research.

I don’t dismiss statistics of reported crime. But for the reasons above we don’t know how much unreported abuse goes on.

A non-judgemental, non-actionable survey might be thought to produce more accurate statistics.

Well I’ve been looking as well and can’t find anything that matches the figures you give. However the Conference you mention seems to have been about child sexual abuse within the family which, whilst incredibly important, is not what this thread is about.

Galaxy Fri 02-Apr-21 12:42:52

And actually the feminist agenda which you seem to despise might support boys and men to talk about what has happened to them. It is feminists who have been talking for a long time about how gender roles in our society impact negatively on both girls and boys.

Summerlove Fri 02-Apr-21 12:40:01

peasblossom of course men shouldn’t be abused. By women or other men.

I don’t believe anyone said they should be?

If a woman treated a man in a way that made him uncomfortable, of course she is wrong.

But the thread title is how to get men to stop being labeled, so most of us are commenting ob that.

Of course the answer is “teach them not to be sexual predators”

Which incidentally also works for women!

Summerlove Fri 02-Apr-21 12:35:02

Trisher, you are like a dog with a bone trying to blame women for being violated,

It’s very sad.

BlueSky Fri 02-Apr-21 12:35:01

Good post Peasblossom.

Galaxy Fri 02-Apr-21 12:34:28

Sorry that emoji was to my premature posting not to you!

Summerlove Fri 02-Apr-21 12:34:21

kircubbin2000

I think women have been conditioned not to speak up in the past.Dont really know why. A few years ago ,I was probably late 40s early 50s my husband and his female cousin and I went to a party at his friends house. Nobody was overly drunk and the friend decided to walk us all home.He put his arms round me and the cousin and soon had his hand inside my bra.When we got home the cousin was very annoyed and of course she had suffered the same groping. My husband wouldn't believe a word of it and told us it must have been an accidental slip! He said his friend would be mortified that we thought it was intentional.
I now wonder why neither of us gave him a slap or spoke up.

Women were conditioned not to speak out, because that’s easier for men. Same reason we are always told to smile and be “nice”.

They still are conditioned that way, though it’s slowly getting better. Women who do are still often called vile names.

I hope your husband learned to believe you as time passed.

Galaxy Fri 02-Apr-21 12:33:10

hmm Hiw do the messages that have been said on here help boys. Push them off, just be strong, etc etc, if you were drunk it was probably your fault

Peasblossom Fri 02-Apr-21 12:32:37

Of course I’ve got an agenda Galaxy. The prevention of abuse of all children.

What’s yours?

Galaxy Fri 02-Apr-21 12:30:58

How do the mess

Peasblossom Fri 02-Apr-21 12:24:51

I found it on Google without having even the name of the university or the conference.

Along with much other similar research.

I don’t dismiss statistics of reported crime. But for the reasons above we don’t know how much unreported abuse goes on.

A non-judgemental, non-actionable survey might be thought to produce more accurate statistics.

Galaxy Fri 02-Apr-21 12:22:23

But the comments that they should have fought them off, they were both drunk etc, just push them, dont help anyone of either sex to feel comfortable in talking about this.

suziewoozie Fri 02-Apr-21 12:19:49

And it’s children of both sexes - gender is a social construct.

Galaxy Fri 02-Apr-21 12:19:37

I am not dismissing it you cant provide a link and when I Google it that info is not available. You seems to be dismissing much of the information that is provided in terms of crime statistics etc.

suziewoozie Fri 02-Apr-21 12:19:09

Peasblossom

You dismissed the research of 2006 as being outdated, which showed that both boys and girls were almost equally abused and that the vast majority of abuse of boys (95%) was carried out by females.

In dismissing it, we’re you assuming that things have drastically changed in 15years? It was worldwide research carried out by reputable researchers and accepted by a world wide symposium.

And yet you dismissed it.

What I see in this discussion is that the same language and justifications for abuse that men have used are equally used by female posters on this site.

Girls touching up boys for a bit of a laugh
It wasn’t really abuse because it didn’t involve penetration.
It depends what you mean by abuse
He must have done something first
It doesn’t happen
It doesn’t happen very often
It’s mostly men that do it anyway. Women don’t abuse
It wasn’t that bad for him
He must have wanted to or it wouldn’t have happened.

Attitudes like these, in the last, have made women reluctant and ashamed to report abuse.

By perpetuating them it makes it almost impossible for boys to report the abuse perpetrated on them. We won’t know the true figures until both boys and girls feel equally able to report without disbelief and condemnation.

But I know you won’t accept this. For many of you it would mean putting aside your feminist agenda and looking at what is really happening to children of both genders.

I said it was outdated which it is and you didn’t provide any links or details on which I could judge it.

Galaxy Fri 02-Apr-21 12:14:06

Whereas you have no agenda whatsoever.

Peasblossom Fri 02-Apr-21 12:02:29

You dismissed the research of 2006 as being outdated, which showed that both boys and girls were almost equally abused and that the vast majority of abuse of boys (95%) was carried out by females.

In dismissing it, we’re you assuming that things have drastically changed in 15years? It was worldwide research carried out by reputable researchers and accepted by a world wide symposium.

And yet you dismissed it.

What I see in this discussion is that the same language and justifications for abuse that men have used are equally used by female posters on this site.

Girls touching up boys for a bit of a laugh
It wasn’t really abuse because it didn’t involve penetration.
It depends what you mean by abuse
He must have done something first
It doesn’t happen
It doesn’t happen very often
It’s mostly men that do it anyway. Women don’t abuse
It wasn’t that bad for him
He must have wanted to or it wouldn’t have happened.

Attitudes like these, in the last, have made women reluctant and ashamed to report abuse.

By perpetuating them it makes it almost impossible for boys to report the abuse perpetrated on them. We won’t know the true figures until both boys and girls feel equally able to report without disbelief and condemnation.

But I know you won’t accept this. For many of you it would mean putting aside your feminist agenda and looking at what is really happening to children of both genders.

suziewoozie Fri 02-Apr-21 11:46:58

vegansrock

And the fact that the vast majority of sexual assaults are performed by males, though you wouldn’t think so by the tone of some of the answers on here.

And how!

vegansrock Fri 02-Apr-21 11:45:49

And the fact that the vast majority of sexual assaults are performed by males, though you wouldn’t think so by the tone of some of the answers on here.

suziewoozie Fri 02-Apr-21 11:42:38

Peasblossom

PippaZ I notice that in you legal post you always refer to the defendant as male and the accuser as female. Can I ask if the Act is framed in this way?

Or does it allow for the accuser to be male and the defendant female?

The Act actually uses ‘he’ whenever the sex of the person is actually mentioned, otherwise it says ‘the person’. I think almist all legislation uses ‘he’. Something to do with being a patriarchal society.

Peasblossom Fri 02-Apr-21 10:13:32

PippaZ I notice that in you legal post you always refer to the defendant as male and the accuser as female. Can I ask if the Act is framed in this way?

Or does it allow for the accuser to be male and the defendant female?