Gransnet forums

News & politics

Little Britain - the state of England today

(654 Posts)
Dinahmo Tue 13-Jul-21 21:36:42

I have picked upon England since I am not as aware of what is going on in the other countries of the Union with regard to the state of the nation.

I've been sitting in my home in France, with tempests outside, watching the Channel 4 News. It was so depressing.

90,000 families living in sub-standard temporary accommodation.

Racism

Water companies deliberately releasing sewage into rivers and sea, despite all the rules and regs and heavy fines.

Cuts to overseas aid - by one of the richest nations.

30,000 children in care moved last year away from their local area, schools, support networks etc, often without prior warning (not on Channel 4)

Cuts in the arts lessons in schools.

Football

We came to France, bought a plot of land and built a house. I guess we were lucky to do so. It was an adventure, something to stop us getting bogged down in our retirement. At the time we didn't intend to stay here but now I'm not so sure. The England that I loved has disappeared.

In the early fifties we moved to Dorset. Parents under 30 with 3 children. We got a council house, possibly because of my Father's job - I don't know. In those days we had one bath a week and didn't have individual towels. The loo was in the bathroom. in the early sixties we moved to a brand new house, with, joy o joy, a second separate loo. Today my house has 3 bedrooms and 3 bath/shower rooms. And at the same time there are tens of thousands of families living in sub standard housing. WHY?

The govt is picking on subjects like Voter ID. statues and BLM because they know that it will stir up a large proportion of the population. But they're not as important as other things that are happening, like the slow but sure privatisation of the NHS. How many of you have only been able to access your GP (if you have one, as we did in times gone by, who knew oneself) by video calls or Zoom or whatever?

The water companies are privately owned so they don't give a toss. Southern Water has been fined £90 million - so much but yet not enough to prevent them from continuing to release sewage into the sea. Channel had a map showing where there were releases along the south coast today. At least a dozen. it's lucky it's raining and there are heavy seas so people won't be swimming there any time soon.

The behaviour of football fans towards supporters of the opposition. Forcing their way into the stands reserved for the Danes and being abusive. Pulling a Danish mother's hair and calling her a whore and spitting at people.

I care about these things and yet I don't live in the UK at the moment. Why aren't you all caring about the wrongs? And, if you do, why aren't you doing something about it?

You can tell me that it's always been like this but I've been on this earth for 74 years and it's about times things changed.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 13-Jul-21 21:38:39

Poverty is rising, and more and more children are going hungry

This message to one of our finest young men

Whitewavemark2 Tue 13-Jul-21 21:50:24

The water companies will continue to soak up the fines as long as the EA is restricted in the level of fines it can dish out. At present the fines are less than the cost to the water company of mitigating the problem.

Dinahmo Tue 13-Jul-21 21:56:40

WWM2 Was that photo taken at the wall painting of Marcus Rashford? The one that has been vandalised?

Elleee Tue 13-Jul-21 21:57:07

Ex Conservative PM John Major said today regarding the cuts to international aid
'The government has blatantly broken it's word and should be ashamed of it's decision'
'This isn't Great Britain it's Little England'

Kandinsky Tue 13-Jul-21 22:02:29

Makes you wonder why 1000’s of migrants risk their lives every year trying to enter this country from France.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 13-Jul-21 22:03:17

Dinahmo

WWM2 Was that photo taken at the wall painting of Marcus Rashford? The one that has been vandalised?

Yes it was.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 13-Jul-21 22:03:37

Kandinsky

Makes you wonder why 1000’s of migrants risk their lives every year trying to enter this country from France.

And your point?

MoorlandMooner Tue 13-Jul-21 22:04:57

"Why aren't you all caring about the wrongs? And, if you do, why aren't you doing something about it?"

I care deeply about the wrongs and I think you will see from many other threads on here that many other people too.

As for doing something about it, well again, lots of people do try very hard to do something about it...we campaign, sign petitions, volunteer our time to charities, try to be good citizens, write to MPs and vote for parties we believe will make positive changes.

Some people don't do anything to make change...perhaps they aren't able, perhaps they have their own problems or perhaps they are all right Jack. I imagine a lot of people who do nothing are just overwhelmed or feel powerless or without hope.

A huge amount of good goes on here in Britain as well. Really positive things.

May I respectfully ask if you care about the wrongs that happen in France and what you do about them?

Kandinsky Tue 13-Jul-21 22:05:21

My point is.
If this country is so awful why risk your life trying to enter?
Why not stay in wonderful France?

Dinahmo Tue 13-Jul-21 22:06:06

I've just had an email from one of the campaign organisations asking me to write to my MP about the NHS Corporate Takeover Bill which MPs are voting on tomorrow. All that talk from the Tories about saving the NHS from being overrun by Covid patients and the NHS is safe in their hands. Now this!

Alegrias1 Tue 13-Jul-21 22:10:39

I care Dinahmo flowers.

I thought Alistair Campbell was excellent on the Channel 4 news, he's got the measure of the government.

MoorlandMooner Tue 13-Jul-21 22:13:26

"Makes you wonder why 1000’s of migrants risk their lives every year trying to enter this country from France."

Less than a quarter of migrants to France try to leave there in order to enter Britain. Those that do have many, varied reasons for coming here e.g. they have family here, the speak english, they come from countries with strong historical ties to Britain, they don't come voluntarily but are utterly powerless and forced by people who have control over them.

Dinahmo Tue 13-Jul-21 22:18:29

MoorlandMooner I am interested in what happens in France. There's very little that I can do about it because we don't have a vote apart from the very local elections. We could not participate in the recent elections because we aren't nationals.

When we told a friend that we'd got our residency permits he asked whether we were planning to become French nationals. My answer was no because we are English and not French. I think that now we have left the EU it is possible to have dual nationality. Of course, when the UK was part of the EU dual nationality wasn't necessary.

Kandinsky I think that the police in France are more violent than those in the UK and make life extremely difficult for the refugees in the camps.

Dinahmo Tue 13-Jul-21 22:19:40

Kandinsky forgot to add - many of the refugees fleeing to the UK have family members already there plus English is more likely to be their second language, rather than French.

MerylStreep Tue 13-Jul-21 22:24:28

It seems we’re not alone with our racism.
This from a left leaning news outlet.

www.euractiv.com/section/non-discrimination/news/france-has-a-discrimination-problem-says-national-human-rights-defender/

MoorlandMooner Tue 13-Jul-21 22:26:13

I can see that it's next to impossible for you to make change politically Dinahmo. I believe a lot of people feel the same way here even though they can vote. Our voting system means many (including me!) don't feel their voices are heard e.g. in a safe constituency for a particular party there is little hope for those who want change.

That said many millions of people here and I'm sure in France, whatever their political persuasion, make small or big contributions for good as part of their day to day lives...it just isn't sexy or newsworthy and so we don't hear about it.

Luckygirl Tue 13-Jul-21 22:27:11

Oh we do care - believe me.

I have just been watching some sort of fly-on-the-wall police documentary which focussed on homelessness, multi-occupancy dwellings and addictions. I was once a social worker and it brought it all back - that sense of being powerless in the face of malign forces and uncaring government. Nothing has changed - it has all got worse.

The crunch question is what can we do?

Vote for a government that has some sense of morality and compassion; and a real grasp of what life is like for those at the bottom of the heap?......been there, tried that and watched the little Englanders vote in what they thought was their own self-interest, forgetting that we are all brothers/sisters and we are all affected by the misery of those at the bottom by way of increased crime etc.

I try not to think too hard about it all - I have more than enough to be depressed about - and I recognise my total impotence here.

I try to do what I can in the small sphere of influence that I do have.

Luckygirl Tue 13-Jul-21 22:32:21

As MoorlandMooner pointed out: "Poe0l make small or big contributions for good as part of their day to day lives."

I am a school governor and try to make sure that the school creates the sort of environment that will give children a good start in life. I belong to a local group of women who are involved in social action - supporting local people where needed; initiating social projects etc.

These are the sorts of things that many people do daily but no-one person can change the mess there is around us. Lots of us just chip away as best we can.

Luckygirl Tue 13-Jul-21 22:32:33

People

SueDonim Tue 13-Jul-21 22:33:45

Why aren't you all caring about the wrongs? And, if you do, why aren't you doing something about it?

How do you know ‘we’ don’t care and are not doing anything about it? I could reel off loads of things that people in my world do to make lives better for others. Just because we don’t make a big noise about it doesn’t mean we don’t care.

MerylStreep Tue 13-Jul-21 22:38:31

SueDonim
Absolutely!!!

Ellianne Tue 13-Jul-21 23:04:12

I had a similar attitude towards what was happening England when I lived in France Dinahmo, so I can understand your frustrations. It wasn't until I analysed my feelings that I realised the news I was receiving abroad about the UK was primarily depressing and dwelt on all the negatives. Much of it is sensationalised and not representative of the real situation. You gradually become out of touch with your home country and start to be more critical of it. I can assure you that plenty of caring does go on in England and that young people especially are striving for the best possible future.

Dinahmo Wed 14-Jul-21 00:39:44

Ellianne We have several friends in England with whom we are in regular contact. Family too. I am signed up to several campaigning organisations, I watch the English news on tv and read English newspapers on line and our friends keep us informed. I am aware that there are many little stories about peoples' goodness and kindness and some not so small, such as Marcus Rashford's campaign for continuing school meals and Captain Tom's fundraising for the NHS.

The genie has been let out of the bottle and it's going a lot of effort to change things, effort that I think the Tories lack.

grannyactivist Wed 14-Jul-21 01:30:18

I care. And I campaign and lobby, sign petitions, demonstrate. I do what I can, but sometimes I feel like the boy with his finger in the Dyke. I could become very demoralised - especially as I work with people who are on the margins of society - but I also see the very best of people. People, from all walks of life, who commit themselves to making a difference in society, particularly those volunteers who force themselves out of their comfort zones. At the height of the pandemic there was a great community effort that I think has sowed seeds for more cohesive communities in the future (I hope so anyway).

So often these sorts of discussions come down to Left, Right or Centrist Politics, to Brexit or Remain, to 'mask' or 'no mask' wearing - and ignore the fact that we're all multi-faceted people who are more than the sum of our political views.

I am a Christian on the political left, but amongst the Conservative voters I know there are many who are kind, thoughtful, caring people; people who go out of their way to be helpful, who volunteer and make a point of looking out for their neighbours. Today in Parliament 24 of them defied the Whips and voted against the cuts to foreign aid; I salute each one of them and any other Tories who support their position.

I believe that this current government is acting in a moral and ethical vacuum, but I also believe that there are MPs (of all parties) who view their job as a vocation and went into politics to to serve their constituents. The country is not finished yet and, inevitably, as the demographic changes so will the political landscape.