Gransnet forums

News & politics

Little Britain - the state of England today

(655 Posts)
Dinahmo Tue 13-Jul-21 21:36:42

I have picked upon England since I am not as aware of what is going on in the other countries of the Union with regard to the state of the nation.

I've been sitting in my home in France, with tempests outside, watching the Channel 4 News. It was so depressing.

90,000 families living in sub-standard temporary accommodation.

Racism

Water companies deliberately releasing sewage into rivers and sea, despite all the rules and regs and heavy fines.

Cuts to overseas aid - by one of the richest nations.

30,000 children in care moved last year away from their local area, schools, support networks etc, often without prior warning (not on Channel 4)

Cuts in the arts lessons in schools.

Football

We came to France, bought a plot of land and built a house. I guess we were lucky to do so. It was an adventure, something to stop us getting bogged down in our retirement. At the time we didn't intend to stay here but now I'm not so sure. The England that I loved has disappeared.

In the early fifties we moved to Dorset. Parents under 30 with 3 children. We got a council house, possibly because of my Father's job - I don't know. In those days we had one bath a week and didn't have individual towels. The loo was in the bathroom. in the early sixties we moved to a brand new house, with, joy o joy, a second separate loo. Today my house has 3 bedrooms and 3 bath/shower rooms. And at the same time there are tens of thousands of families living in sub standard housing. WHY?

The govt is picking on subjects like Voter ID. statues and BLM because they know that it will stir up a large proportion of the population. But they're not as important as other things that are happening, like the slow but sure privatisation of the NHS. How many of you have only been able to access your GP (if you have one, as we did in times gone by, who knew oneself) by video calls or Zoom or whatever?

The water companies are privately owned so they don't give a toss. Southern Water has been fined £90 million - so much but yet not enough to prevent them from continuing to release sewage into the sea. Channel had a map showing where there were releases along the south coast today. At least a dozen. it's lucky it's raining and there are heavy seas so people won't be swimming there any time soon.

The behaviour of football fans towards supporters of the opposition. Forcing their way into the stands reserved for the Danes and being abusive. Pulling a Danish mother's hair and calling her a whore and spitting at people.

I care about these things and yet I don't live in the UK at the moment. Why aren't you all caring about the wrongs? And, if you do, why aren't you doing something about it?

You can tell me that it's always been like this but I've been on this earth for 74 years and it's about times things changed.

MaizieD Thu 15-Jul-21 14:18:04

Lucca

“ but BLM , itself an anti Semitic, racist, Marxist organisation funded by George Soros”. Really ? Is this true ?

??? I have to do this or I'll cry.

Poor George Soros

Have a read of this:

www.buzzfeednews.com/article/hnsgrassegger/george-soros-conspiracy-finkelstein-birnbaum-orban-netanyahu

Lucca Thu 15-Jul-21 14:18:36

KateF. “ We saw this weekend what a dictator Macron is again,”

Is that with him insisting on vaccine passports ? Sorry but I’m with him on that one.

lemongrove Thu 15-Jul-21 14:20:17

The point of the France comment was obvious Lucca

Have no idea about art in schools or the French water companies and any misdeeds but every other issue the OP raises are ones causing problems in France and many other countries with a large population.
The UK ( or England as is being singled out) is not perfect, and could never be, but is still the best country in Europe to live in my view.
The aid budget is being cut to about the same amount as France has been paying btw.

Lucca Thu 15-Jul-21 14:49:17

But the OP was talking about UK. .??

Why do we have to come back with the “France is as bad” ??
It could have been interesting to hear people’s views in those issues, but no.

westendgirl Thu 15-Jul-21 14:50:02

I think that the point of outrage at cutting the Aid Budget was to do with the fact that the government had broken a promise. That is what Theresa May said so strongly in her speech.
It is pointless comparing what we have failed to deliver with what other countries do or did.
We reneged on a promise .That is what is unforgiveable.

Theoddbird Thu 15-Jul-21 14:52:06

Agree Gillycats... I too am English and proud of it.

Lucca Thu 15-Jul-21 14:52:17

Good comment

Callistemon Thu 15-Jul-21 14:52:29

Actually, a lot of you have said that you do care but you haven't said about what.

Today my house has 3 bedrooms and 3 bath/shower rooms. And at the same time there are tens of thousands of families living in sub standard housing. WHY?

Actions speak louder than words - could you offer a home to a family with a child or children who are at present living in a shanty town slum in Paris?

Lucca Thu 15-Jul-21 14:52:51

Good comment by west end girl I mean.

Callistemon Thu 15-Jul-21 14:55:14

Dinahmo

GoldenAge I realise that I slightly misread your post.

Actually, a lot of you have said that you do care but you haven't said about what.

You totally misread Goldenage's post and turned it against her.

lemongrove Thu 15-Jul-21 14:57:54

westendgirl

I think that the point of outrage at cutting the Aid Budget was to do with the fact that the government had broken a promise. That is what Theresa May said so strongly in her speech.
It is pointless comparing what we have failed to deliver with what other countries do or did.
We reneged on a promise .That is what is unforgiveable.

After what it has cost this country in terms of money (Covid )
I think a cut to the level of what France is paying ( and has been paying) is reasonable.
The promise was made in ‘good times’.

GrannyGravy13 Thu 15-Jul-21 15:00:36

I was under the impression that the reduction in Foreign Aid was a temporary measure?

Callistemon Thu 15-Jul-21 15:00:56

JaneJudge

MayBee70, if people start listing things they'll get accused of virtue signaling wink

Quite right.
When I suggested that posters might like to support a small charity I've supported for years, I was shredded on here and told in no uncertain terms I was a virtue signaller.
I've never mentioned it or anything we do since.

JaneJudge Thu 15-Jul-21 15:02:31

I suppose the point is we should be striving to live in a good and fair country, we shouldn't accept that because another country is bad, everything is ok. It is a bit like the argument about free schools meals being compared to starving children in third world countries. The point is we are NOT a third world country, we should be doing better for the people who live here and we shouldn't be blaming people for being poor. People generally cannot help being poor.

It is too easy to blame 'people' and not look at probable causes and short and long term solutions

It is a bit like some of the comments about racism on this thread. We are not that racist not compared to <insert country of choice> That isn't the point, the point is we could and can try better. It wasn't a huge leap that the rhetoric around brexit and closing our borders would manifest itself into something bigger or something else , especially when you have dedicated organisations and their hooligan following.

Dinahmo Thu 15-Jul-21 15:04:20

Devongirl4

Did you eventually buy your council house?

If this question is aimed at me, I lived in the council house in the fifties. And nor did my parents.

GrannyGravy13 Thu 15-Jul-21 15:04:22

Exactly Callistemon

Has the OP posted what she would do if they were residing in England?

Notright Thu 15-Jul-21 15:06:41

Believe me, many people do think about it and care but with all the things you mentioned, there's not a lot we can do as so few are not listening. It seems that the minority who are causing such chaos in our dear country, individual people as well as companies, are too selfish to think of the future. I dread it for my great grandchildren when they arrive.

Dinahmo Thu 15-Jul-21 15:10:05

lemongrove

Good post Maggs ??

Yes Ellianne you are correct, this thread is political.The OP won’t turn out to be a fan of the Conservative Party ( that’s putting it mildly am sure.) Starting a contentious thread about the ‘state’ of England and not the UK was the first clue.
Hardly worth bothering to debate this subject really, but heartening to see so many posts rebutting it.
As stated, the OP doesn’t know who does what to question or help in their own small way, from giving to charities, food banks to writing to MP’s. Am hoping Dinahmo does the same things in France.... when not cleaning the three bathrooms and weeding the massive garden.

My garden is not massive. The plot is quite large, but not by the standards of many people, of whatever nationality who live in France. Most of it is given over to wildlife and what is meadow is mown once a year. And, for your information, it cost 39,000 euros back in 2006/2007 when the exchange rate was very good. Compared with a plot of land I looked at in Suffolk (less than 1/3 acre which was eventually sold for £106,000) with overhead power lines coming from Sizewell in the next door field.

Dinahmo Thu 15-Jul-21 15:13:41

Chewbacca

I think OPs reading matter and choice of t.v. programmes feeds in to her confirmation bias.

What do you think my reading matter is? You don't know my choice of tv either apart from Channel 4 news.

Ellianne Thu 15-Jul-21 15:16:02

JaneJudge

MayBee70, if people start listing things they'll get accused of virtue signaling wink

That's sad. I for one have picked up several excellent suggestions on GN how to improve things for others. Just because these caring actions take place within my own community doesn't mean they are any less valuable.
Being accused of being a Pollyanna or comments about wanting a medal are silly.

Dinahmo Thu 15-Jul-21 15:18:09

Callistemon

Dinahmo

GoldenAge I realise that I slightly misread your post.

Actually, a lot of you have said that you do care but you haven't said about what.

You totally misread Goldenage's post and turned it against her.

Well that makes a change doesn't it. Compared with the numbers of you have have misread my posts and turned them against me. All because I have criticised my home country from a few miles away.

halfpint1 Thu 15-Jul-21 15:20:54

The OP posted her opinion on what the English news was given out , and mentioned the word France.
Most of the replies read like a pack of wolves attacking the OP and France, very few concentrate on the actual subject.

Granny1810 Thu 15-Jul-21 15:21:01

It does annoy me when someone can sit in another country and criticise their homeland. You ask why we are not doing anything, well who is to say we are not. We are not a revelutionary nation. However you are unaware of grassroots. Things will change.

westendgirl Thu 15-Jul-21 15:21:54

Lemongrove it was still a promise on which organisations built their budgets, a promise we made and which others relied upon.
Look at the wastage if you want to talk of money spent through the pandemic . I'm not going into it as it has been covered. Jane Judge you are right. We could and should do better . We should surely be aiming high and not put up with low standards in government as in elsewhere. this is where lowering standards leads

JaneJudge Thu 15-Jul-21 15:23:44

Ellianne, of course doing things within your own community isn't less valuable. I don't feel that way.

I have become apathetic though. I have stopped signing petitions and I never write to my MP any more as nothing ever comes of it. I feel resentful that volunteers are relied upon to do complex jobs that should be paid too sad