Gransnet forums

News & politics

Do you sometimes get really frustrated when things seem to have such an obvious solution?

(81 Posts)
GillT57 Thu 26-Aug-21 13:45:43

The main thing I am thinking of is the well discussed shortage of HGV drivers which is causing delivery problems. To me, the obvious solution would be to offer some sort of career development loan to enable people to take lessons and achieve their HGV licence, either independently or through a logistics company. What about ex-service personnel? The career loan could be deducted at source as with student loans. Surely I can't be the only one who sees this solution? Or does anyone know if there is such a plan?

Lindaa4 Sun 29-Aug-21 09:24:50

I think the chancellor will stop the money he has been giving to people to stay at home .I think it is next month, then more people may be wanting a job

4allweknow Sat 28-Aug-21 20:29:33

The existing drivers needs to be given a decent wage. Those new to the role should be offered a minimum graduated pay scale no matter which company they work for. The European drivers left because of the pathetic wages and the complicated and expensive process of applying for 'visa" type papers to enter/work in UK. Had the wages been worthwhile perhaps more would have stayed or UK workers would have taken HGV jobs in the first place without the need of those from Europe.

MarjieM Sat 28-Aug-21 16:35:49

As the Mother in Law of an HGV driver, I know that they work very long hours, for not a lot of money and mostly go unappreciated. I also know that the majority of British drivers are law abiding and get very angry when they see continental drivers, flouting the rules, driving dangerously and giving HGV drivers a bad name.
It’s time we gave our drivers credit for what they do, and better wages. Maybe more people would apply to train.

Thisismyname1953 Sat 28-Aug-21 16:21:22

My son told me recently that some companies are offering a £1000 signing on bonus for HGV drivers . I’m not sure how true it is .

Polarbear2 Sat 28-Aug-21 15:13:59

nanna8

Can you use those long road trains like we have here or is the traffic too heavy?Longest one here was 113 trailers. Mind you wouldn’t want to be stuck behind it! Usually they belt along though.

Roads arent big enough am afraid. Our roads wouldn’t cope at all. Small country compared to yours - space wise ??

HannahLoisLuke Sat 28-Aug-21 14:19:46

Peasblossom

Perhaps better pay and conditions would be more effective that a training grant?

Why not both?
And regarding the insurance issue, I would imagine that many servicemen would be excellent drivers having driven army vehicles, including in some cases tanks.

nanna8 Sat 28-Aug-21 14:12:40

Can you use those long road trains like we have here or is the traffic too heavy?Longest one here was 113 trailers. Mind you wouldn’t want to be stuck behind it! Usually they belt along though.

Gabrielle56 Sat 28-Aug-21 13:37:43

I suspect historically female drivers were put off by : no facilities at truck stops for females; sheer physical barriers with the older rigs (not so much now with modern tractor units and auto transmissions) ; safety! Always safety, we passed have had to factor in the " am I likely to be attacked?" Element into oh so many professions! I've always wanted to learn to pilot an HGV but all these put offs were so very prevalent in 70s and80s I simply out it out of my mind☹️

Gabrielle56 Sat 28-Aug-21 13:32:19

NotSpaghetti

As a temporary measure I think HGV drivers should be on the same list of exemptions as ballet dancers.
At least the port checks would be shorter.

Whaaa?!? Tell me this is a joke??? Ballet dancers? Really? ....although thinking about it opera and ballet get heritage lottery funding while brass bands are not considered either part of our heritage-or even music according to the greedy stuck up snobs er ,I mean the powers that be at the lottery bank!

chrissyh Sat 28-Aug-21 12:38:47

There was a man on a radio phone-in programme the other day who had trained and passed his HGV test but couldn't get a permanent job, just a couple of days here and there doing agency work. The companies wanted experienced drivers.

MerylStreep Sat 28-Aug-21 12:24:22

NannyG123
That was one of the reasons why my friend sold his Haulage company and retired some years ago. Another, self employed, also gave it up.

Alegrias1 Sat 28-Aug-21 12:13:16

Sarahmob

My husband is an HGV driver and considers himself to be well paid by the company he works for. To clarify the ‘retesting every five years’ Germanshepherdsmun it isn’t a retest of driving skills, it’s a simple medical/eyesight check. Mr mobile says that there is a bit of a problem getting people who are qualified to do those, but it’s not impossible.

I agree with NannyG123 on this one; its a bit more than an eyesight check every five years. Its not even "just" a test of driving skills.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Driver_CPC

ayse Sat 28-Aug-21 12:13:11

Mamgujane

Old-fashioned idea - why not go back to more freight by rail? Much less polluting, fewer drivers needed - only for shorter journeys from goods station to final destination.
I’m sure there are a dozen arguments against this, one of which will be our already overloaded passenger rail system. But a bit of intelligent thought (haha with this government?) should be able to come up with a plan.

Far better for the environment as well. Not beyond the wit of man but outside this government’s agenda. There are still many old sidings that could be used if upgraded etc.

Govt has said it will not relax the immigration regs for HGV drivers but will encourage the employment of ex services and apprentices.

Growing0ldDisgracefully Sat 28-Aug-21 12:10:04

I saw an advert on Facebook yesterday, looking for HGV test examiners. So a lack of those is part of the problem.
My OH used to be a delivery driver for John Lewis (not the same I accept) but he got out of that because of the unrealistic delivery schedules, and the use of agency staff as co-staff with poor English, leading to serious H&S issues, some of which led to injury sustained by my husband because the co-staff member didn't understand what was being required of them when moving heavy items into customers' homes. I would imagine there could be similar negative aspects to HGV delivery drivers' jobs.

cc Sat 28-Aug-21 12:05:39

I'm not sure if anyone else has mentioned this but apparently there are quite a few young men who have paid for their HGV drivers training but are not allowed to work because the lower age limit is 25. Surely if there is a test at the end of the course this should enable the younger trained people to drive HGV's? It was said that they are getting jobs driving smaller vehicles, doing shelf stacking or whatever because they're too young to be employed as HGV drivers

Mamgujane Sat 28-Aug-21 11:35:06

Oh Lesley 60 I see you’ve posted the same idea!

Mamgujane Sat 28-Aug-21 11:33:10

Old-fashioned idea - why not go back to more freight by rail? Much less polluting, fewer drivers needed - only for shorter journeys from goods station to final destination.
I’m sure there are a dozen arguments against this, one of which will be our already overloaded passenger rail system. But a bit of intelligent thought (haha with this government?) should be able to come up with a plan.

Lesley60 Sat 28-Aug-21 11:32:08

I don’t understand why these big container lorries can’t be transported by rail it would certainly free up the roads a little

Amalegra Sat 28-Aug-21 11:31:41

Thanks for this! I have just emailed the link to my daughter who I know may be interested in some of them. Would be myself but I am retired now and kept quite busy with my grandchildren!

Jillybird Sat 28-Aug-21 11:25:34

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Polarbear2 Sat 28-Aug-21 11:19:47

I guess the pandemic coupled with Brexit has taught us that low paid jobs are often the most valuable to society - and in some cases the highest paid …aren’t that valuable at all! As for the short term answer I’d say a relaxation the visa issue could help somewhat - coupled with better wages and conditions.

grannygranby Sat 28-Aug-21 11:19:09

HGV drivers have no status. Some service stations wouldn’t even let them use their loos. It’s like work in slaughterhouses, great shortage there I believe. We allowed east European immigrants from lower paid countries to do these poorly paid jobs with loads of stress and poor conditions, inhuman in some cases, and no status.
Companies pay as little as they can to keep prices low. Millions of animals are slaughtered a week and sold really cheaply. It costs more to buy a plant based sausage than one made from a living suffering sentient animal. Perhaps it will be a good thing that proper prices will have to be charged reflecting the reality behind cheap food.

NannyG123 Sat 28-Aug-21 11:04:09

My husband was an HGV Driver for about 40yrs. Then was told he would have to have a CPC licence which meant 5 days in a classroom which he would have had to pay£500 for.And he would have to do this every 3 years. My husband was just turning 60 at the time and stopped hgv driving. He said after 40yrs why do I need to go into a classroom to be taught how to do my job.

Sarahmob Sat 28-Aug-21 11:00:39

My husband is an HGV driver and considers himself to be well paid by the company he works for. To clarify the ‘retesting every five years’ Germanshepherdsmun it isn’t a retest of driving skills, it’s a simple medical/eyesight check. Mr mobile says that there is a bit of a problem getting people who are qualified to do those, but it’s not impossible.

Jaxjacky Sat 28-Aug-21 10:26:36

I read yesterday, one store I can’t recall which, bought a load of transit vans. They can now use drivers who don’t require the HGV licence, not very green as more trips are required and obviously you need the money for the vans.