Gransnet forums

News & politics

Is English cricket, not just Yorkshire cricket, institutionally racist?

(186 Posts)
varian Tue 16-Nov-21 17:32:36

Azeem Rafiq: English cricket is 'institutionally' racist says former Yorkshire player

www.bbc.co.uk/sport/cricket/59304381

theworriedwell Sun 21-Nov-21 15:27:31

I think it would be hard for anyone on here, or elsewhere, to show how they or their ancestors were directly disadvantaged by the Romans.

My husband, and many like him, can show you the plantation where his ancestors were slaves he can tell you the name of the man who raped his great great grandmother and fathered his great grandfather, a child he kept as a slave. You can visit the slave castle in West Africa where his ancestors (well some of them) started their journey to the new world.

The Roman invasion also did positive things, roads, towns, a written history. I don't think slavery did anything positive for the Africans who were taken or the ones left behind.

That is why reparations are different.

theworriedwell Sun 21-Nov-21 15:29:29

25Avalon

Rafiq is now accused of inappropriate remarks to a 17 year old girl when he was 24. According to her he was drinking vodka on an aeroplane so where does that leave his ‘testimony’ about the trauma of being forced to drink red wine? I think he has experienced racist abuse but has embellished it.

He was 15 when he had alcohol poured down his throat so unlikely to be a drinker in a Muslim household. If he drank later that was up to him but nothing to do with abuse when he was a child.

MerylStreep Sun 21-Nov-21 15:40:38

Maddyone
The whole of humankind are tribal, not just the Jewish people.
We have a small island near us ( canvey) some will know it ?
I don’t know if it’s still the case but it was often referred to as
2 tribes Canvey
Some on here know the Essex town, Maldon. Many years ago before it became gentrified the fishermen/bargemen considered the residents at the top end of the town almost
Ailiens.

M0nica Sun 21-Nov-21 16:17:02

Yes, I was also unaware of pre-Christian persecution.

It is possible that the Christians were as well - the earliest Christiaans were Jewish, but in the middle ages, perseccution of the jews was very much based on their involvement in the proseccution and death of Jesus Christ.

Calistemon Sun 21-Nov-21 16:35:30

Christianity was at first considered to be another sect of Judaism, not a separate religion..

theworriedwell Sun 21-Nov-21 16:38:38

In the Old Testament the Jews were kept as slaves by the Egyptians, Moses led them out of slavery so yes they were persecuted.

Peasblossom Sun 21-Nov-21 17:13:41

Of course, if we’re going back to The Old Testament (ie the Jewish Pentateuch) the Hebrews did a fair amount of persecuting, slavery and genecide too.?

Katie59 Sun 21-Nov-21 18:10:25

Tribalism is alive and well everywhere, schoolyard gangs, football supporters, all the way to national, religious or ethnic hatred, it’s not going to go away.

The cricket controversy is about verbal comments, very often it is serious violence even genocide, all that is going on today, forgive me if I don’t get excited about the inequalities in cricket.

Calistemon Sun 21-Nov-21 18:18:14

Katie59
No-one mentions Syria these days sad

'Sticks and stones (and bombs and bullets) may break my bones but words will never hurt me' was always a good adage.

I'll wait for the brickbats.

Alegrias1 Sun 21-Nov-21 18:24:12

How about being held down and having red wine poured down your throat?

Do you suppose that hurt?

But yeah, racist abuse is just name calling.hmm

Calistemon Sun 21-Nov-21 18:26:57

Allegedly.

How does it feel to be 3, see your Mum and Dad killed, your brother killed and you have lost a leg?

That is discrimination on the grounds of religion.

Calistemon Sun 21-Nov-21 18:28:03

Alegrias1

How about being held down and having red wine poured down your throat?

Do you suppose that hurt?

But yeah, racist abuse is just name calling.hmm

But yeah, racist abuse is just name calling

Why did I know you'd be first?

Iam64 Sun 21-Nov-21 18:34:40

theworriedwell

I think it would be hard for anyone on here, or elsewhere, to show how they or their ancestors were directly disadvantaged by the Romans.

My husband, and many like him, can show you the plantation where his ancestors were slaves he can tell you the name of the man who raped his great great grandmother and fathered his great grandfather, a child he kept as a slave. You can visit the slave castle in West Africa where his ancestors (well some of them) started their journey to the new world.

The Roman invasion also did positive things, roads, towns, a written history. I don't think slavery did anything positive for the Africans who were taken or the ones left behind.

That is why reparations are different.

Thanks worriedwell, you explained this so well, particularly as you could use personal experience. I recall working with a young man in 1981 who had achieved his degree with support from schemes in place to help immigrants whose basic education had been disrupted. His had because he’d arrived in the UK from Jamaica age 14, to join parents he hadn’t seen for 10 years. He stayed with grannie whilst mum and dad trained and established themselves in the uk. His lady name was his slave name. It was my first real exposure to the legacy of slavery. I’d read about it, had a wonderful history teacher when we learned about the horrors of the slave trade - in 1961. But I was aware we had. Etbsl family history back to the mid 19th century. We knew our ancestors travelled north for work in the mills, after agricultural work dried up in the south. We knew their children had been briefly in the work house when parents lack of work meant no food. My colleague knew his ancestors were slaves.

I can’t get angry or smug about Azeem Rafiq and the ‘fall from grace’ some seem keen to accuse him of. Racism, misogyny, all need calling out, Rafiq’s story is the heart of that. Let’s be calm, acknowledge that s**t happens. Reflect, consider, own our own stuff and move on hopefully, in a more positive wsy

Alegrias1 Sun 21-Nov-21 18:44:27

Why did I know you'd be first?

I dunno.... telepathy?

Calistemon Sun 21-Nov-21 18:45:20

I'm sorry, but slavery, which is happening here and now all over the world and in this country, makes me angry and weep, what is happening in Syria, Afghanistan, makes me even more angry and weep.
What happened in the Balkans not that long ago makes me very upset too.

What this young man endured makes me very cross, it shouldn't happen and we can educate and try to do something about it.

Therein lies the difference

Alegrias1 Sun 21-Nov-21 18:48:31

Calistemon

Allegedly.

How does it feel to be 3, see your Mum and Dad killed, your brother killed and you have lost a leg?

That is discrimination on the grounds of religion.

Anyway.

Its not a competition. Terrible things happen to people. That doesn't mean we don't get to complain about "just" bad things happening to people.

Discrimination on the grounds of religion takes many forms. Its doesn't have to result in catastrophic outcomes; it can still be discrimination.

You say that racism needs calling out then in another post play down the abuse he suffered.

I, for one, am confused.

Calistemon Sun 21-Nov-21 18:49:07

Alegrias1

^Why did I know you'd be first?^

I dunno.... telepathy?

I think the word I'm looking for is inevitability.

Alegrias1 Sun 21-Nov-21 18:49:54

Shush, someone in a far off country is much worse off than you.

Clean your plate. Children are starving in Africa

Calistemon Sun 21-Nov-21 18:52:37

Offensive

Alegrias1 Sun 21-Nov-21 18:54:50

Really? But trying to make a poster feel that their posts aren't welcome is OK is it?

I guess its just that I have a boring life (See Royal thread for details. Sorry. TAAT.)

MerylStreep Sun 21-Nov-21 19:07:23

Calistemon
It’s not looking too good for some Syrian Refugees in Denmark, is it. The Danish government deem Syria to be safe.

Calistemon Sun 21-Nov-21 19:59:14

Yes, I have a friend who has been supporting Syrian refugees in Turkey for years.

What this young man has suffered, although very wrong, bears no relationship whatsoever.

I'm sure Marcus Rashford has suffered verbal abuse but he has risen above it - what an inspiration he is!

M0nica Mon 22-Nov-21 07:54:59

We can do little, as individuals, to solve the great problems and injustices in the world. We can do so much to resolve the problems and injustices of those around us.

Sarnia Mon 22-Nov-21 08:41:18

Rafiq is under investigation by the cricketing authorities for anti-Semetic remarks made to a friend. Seems like one rule for him and a different one for others.

25Avalon Mon 22-Nov-21 08:57:18

Possibly a whole can of worms but historically haven’t Muslims and Jews often been opposed, so in a religious context Rafiq may have unconscious bias towards Jews? This is religious rather than racist or is it? Idk where I’m going with this. I’ll put it out for discussion.