Gransnet forums

News & politics

Partygate

(272 Posts)
Petera Tue 12-Apr-22 13:44:02

Johnson and Sunak to be served fixed penalty notices. Will he still maintain he didn't break the law?

Libman Wed 13-Apr-22 19:41:43

susieconvento123

An 11 minute birthday tea and cake after working all day is not a issue for me .

It is for me - it was illegal at the time.?

Libman Wed 13-Apr-22 19:43:44

gillgran

I voted Conservative after looking at the alternatives.

I'm concerned as to who is capable of taking our country forward.
I 've looked, ...& still yet to find a suitable candidate.

Has anyone yet told us why these parties were not reported at the time, by anyone?

Dominic Cummings hadn’t been sacked at that point.

maddyone Wed 13-Apr-22 19:46:25

Oh yes, revenge is best served cold.

maddyone Wed 13-Apr-22 19:48:40

Or is it, a dish best served cold? Yes, I think it is.

Libman Wed 13-Apr-22 19:50:02

Right, I’m out. Can’t cope with this groundhog thread. Kudos to those who can continue to point out that it was a) an illegal gathering and b) he lied to parliament.
He is an absolute disgrace and so are those, I’m my opinion, who defend him.

?‍♀️

Libman Wed 13-Apr-22 19:51:18

maddyone

Or is it, a dish best served cold? Yes, I think it is.

That’s the one?

Curlywhirly Wed 13-Apr-22 20:05:43

Libman

Right, I’m out. Can’t cope with this groundhog thread. Kudos to those who can continue to point out that it was a) an illegal gathering and b) he lied to parliament.
He is an absolute disgrace and so are those, I’m my opinion, who defend him.

?‍♀️

I know - it doesn't matter how many times we say that the problem isn't just that he broke the law, but that he lied (and not just once) to Parliament; his supporters insist on saying that it's just a fuss about Birthday cake and they aren't bothered. Why aren't they bothered about his lies?

Coastpath Wed 13-Apr-22 21:19:08

A technical breach of the law on the face of it.

So that'll be breaking the law then.

The idea that he had broken the law and flouted rules in this situation was nowhere near his mind at the time.

He made the law and rules.

Highly competent government of our country.

It is time for people to take more notice of the real threats to our country

Like a lying PM and Chancellor of the Exchequer

real threats to the world order and our democratic way of life, being perpetrated by Russia and China, and to which the Prime Minister must spend 100% of his time and energy addressing.

Perhaps by taking more Russian money, promoting a Russian to the House of Lords after having multiple holidays at his home?

Imposed rules were being inevitably broken in every office block in the country and also in many private homes.

Not in every home. Most people and organisations made tremendous sacrifices. Where rules were broken most of the perpetrators had not made the laws and rules themselves.

Maybe people would prefer the likes of Presidents Putin and Zi to be our leaders!

No, but neither do we want leaders who break their own rules and then repeatedly lie about it.

Ten minute so-called 'parties' must be got into proportion.

It wasn't a 10 minute party. It wasn't the only party.

growstuff Wed 13-Apr-22 21:32:24

Libman

fordk4

what about the labour leader who was in a pub on lock down was he held to accout no and I saw many people on lockdown shopping with out a mask and people told me they would not wear a mask or have the covid jabs boris did not kill anyone but the general public did so look at the over all picture boris had to run the country ans dont forget all the people cwho got paid 80% of their salary I know people who had to work for 80% of their salary all wake upnthe wat through lockdown and wherte was labour and all the other parties who did nothing during the lockdown you the public need to look at the full picture not the bits you do not like wake up britain and ask your selfes how many times did you and yiur friends break the lockdown rules

I didn’t.

I didn't either.

DaisyAnne Wed 13-Apr-22 21:48:42

Curlywhirly

Libman

Right, I’m out. Can’t cope with this groundhog thread. Kudos to those who can continue to point out that it was a) an illegal gathering and b) he lied to parliament.
He is an absolute disgrace and so are those, I’m my opinion, who defend him.

?‍♀️

I know - it doesn't matter how many times we say that the problem isn't just that he broke the law, but that he lied (and not just once) to Parliament; his supporters insist on saying that it's just a fuss about Birthday cake and they aren't bothered. Why aren't they bothered about his lies?

How do you trust someone who had such a casual attitude towards Johnson's lying to the nation, lying to parliament, lying to the Queen, etc? Maybe, those who are so lax about the man's morals simply have a very different attitude to morality.

Oldbat1 Wed 13-Apr-22 21:55:06

Pleased to see that a Tory peer in House of Lords has resigned. At least one Tory with integrity. Let us hope many in the Commons will cease to defend the indefensible - I know they won’t/can’t resign but please stop backing this liar.

Luckygirl3 Wed 13-Apr-22 22:05:45

Libman

susieconvento123

An 11 minute birthday tea and cake after working all day is not a issue for me .

It is for me - it was illegal at the time.?

And for me - but the issue here is not the party or its length.

It is the lying to parliament and to HM, trying to gag the media, subverting justice by handing out lucrative contracts to his mates (and not then censuring them when they failed to deliver) - it is his casual disregard for parliamentary procedures and for democracy that is the issue here.

The conviction for breaking covid rules is merely the tip of the iceberg. And, since it involves a breach of the law, should have been the thing that finally rid us all of this integrity-free individual. But still he continues. And that is a measure of how far he has undermined our democracy.

SuzanneC Wed 13-Apr-22 22:12:19

grin

GillT57 Wed 13-Apr-22 22:18:47

Well done Lord Wolfson. Where does the Bar Standards Board stand on members either disregarding or supporting this? Braverman and Raab are both members I believe?

Curlywhirly Wed 13-Apr-22 22:24:08

Couldn't agree more Coastpath with your post at 21.19 - well said.

MaizieD Wed 13-Apr-22 22:49:27

for anyone who might be interested, David Allen Green, solicitor and legal commentator, has analysed the 2nd paragraph of Lord Wolfson's resignation letter on his blog. Noting that Lord Wolfson is highly regarded among the llegal profession.

The first sentence is the general finding of fact: there was not only repeated rule-breaking but also (as rules can sometimes just be for policy or guidance) breaches of the criminal law.

This general finding is incontrovertible – the paid penalties are conclusive proof.

The second sentence then sets out a further finding of fact: the breaches were not merely trivial but were of such a “scale, context and nature” that such conduct cannot pass “with constitutional impunity”.

So not just breaches, but significant breaches.

The second sentence then sets out the factors which go to this significance – that others complied at personal cost, and were prosecuted and even criminalised for lesser breaches.

And, as with the first sentence, what is stated is incontrovertible.

Having established these two conclusions, the third and fourth sentences then distinguish between what happened but also the official response: the implication here is that a more measured official response could have perhaps cured the problem.

But the official response was not measured.

Then having set out the facts, and stated that the official response was deficient, the fifth sentence (somewhat inevitably) then follows – including a deft last stab that the prime minister does not see the problem in the same way.

And the paragraph then ends with the firm stamp of the word “resignation”.

He then contrasts it with our Lord Chancellor's excuse for his boss. Raab is a solicitor, too. He really should know better.

davidallengreen.com/2022/04/a-close-look-at-the-resignation-letter-of-david-wolfson-qc-as-justice-minister/

Callistemon21 Wed 13-Apr-22 22:55:05

Libman

gillgran

I voted Conservative after looking at the alternatives.

I'm concerned as to who is capable of taking our country forward.
I 've looked, ...& still yet to find a suitable candidate.

Has anyone yet told us why these parties were not reported at the time, by anyone?

Dominic Cummings hadn’t been sacked at that point.

It was rumoured that journalists were at one or two, whether or not that is true.

If so, they weren't going to report them because they were breaking the law too.

Casdon Thu 14-Apr-22 08:45:18

According to the papers this morning our esteemed leader is set to receive three more fines. The 10 minutes to eat a piece of birthday cake ‘defence’ won’t wash if that is the case.

Chocolatelovinggran Thu 14-Apr-22 09:03:52

Excellent post Coastpath. Says it all. And no, I didn't breach lockdown rules.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 14-Apr-22 09:17:16

Johnson to receive more fines

MaizieD Thu 14-Apr-22 09:19:17

Casdon

According to the papers this morning our esteemed leader is set to receive three more fines. The 10 minutes to eat a piece of birthday cake ‘defence’ won’t wash if that is the case.

It never did wash with anyone with more than one brain cell.