Gransnet forums

News & politics

Priti Patel wins legal battle over Rwanda migrants plan.

(216 Posts)
Urmstongran Fri 10-Jun-22 19:36:10

Best news I've heard all week.

silverlining48 Sat 11-Jun-22 17:10:53

I undestand there is no where and no way to claim asylum before turning up on our shores, they have to get here first, and then claim from here. So no person can be illegal until after a claim is denied.
Refugees can choose where they want to go, many speak English, or have connections here. Its hard enough to begin life in a new country but made worse where you dont speak the language fluently.
Putting aside the fact that because for historic reasons the world speaks English, if we were unlucky enough to be fleeing this country, we would choose somewhere to go where they did. We take very few in comparison to other countries, who welcome them but the majority of refugees seek refuge in neighbouring, poor countries which can ill afford it.
How would those ex pats, aka immigrants, who choose to live in other countries feel if they were as vilified. These are people, like us. Just not as lucky.

CaravanSerai Sat 11-Jun-22 17:12:47

I can be bothered to check.

There was a case in 2018 of a Iranian man joining a Year 11 class at a school in Ipswich. There was no question of him misbehaving. He simply wanted to study as his qualifications overseas were not being recognised here. Sometimes people do desperate things.

Sky reported on this saying there were 9800 applications for asylum in 2016, 580 of whom claimed to be children. On investigation, 61% were deemed to be over 18, That’s 354, less than 4% of the total number of asylum applications of which I can find one story of a man in school.

volver Sat 11-Jun-22 17:14:45

CaravanSerai ??????

Urmstongran Sat 11-Jun-22 17:17:39

Not all migrants are honest, upstanding individuals sadly. There have been stabbings and incidents where citizens have been murdered by those who wish us harm in the West. I have seen the tv news and been horrified. Some of these migrants have undiagnosed mental health issues. Processing individuals (some of whom don’t tell the truth) must be an expensive nightmare when they arrive on our shores without documents. For some reason unknown to me & many law abiding taxpayers it takes too long to sort these migrants out. And the cost of housing them in hotels is eye-watering. £5 million a DAY. Just think about that for a moment. Digest it and think where better could our government be spending that daily amount? It costs BILLIONS each year.

I say they come over from France. They are safe there, not persecuted. They ought to wait in line with everyone else to apply for residency in this country. Not queue jump by paying people traffickers or smuggle themselves in by paying some gang masters to hide them in a container lorry so they can slip out in the night to find themselves living under the radar - unsafe perhaps, coerced by unscrupulous individuals to work in nail bars and back street takeaway kebab shops paid less than the minimum wage. It’s plain wrong.

Philippa111 Sat 11-Jun-22 17:19:43

Pritti Patel is very far from pretty, in any way. She is a callous and cruel human being, devoid of any compassion. How can any decent human being find her actions acceptable... Beats me!

paddyann54 Sat 11-Jun-22 17:21:12

Wish there was a like button for posts like yours Caravan Serai
So much bigotted nonsense from people you would think knew better .Asylum seekers get just over £5 a day and a roof over their heads ,those 4 star hotels are often hovels.the one in central Glasgow had bars on windows and no way of opening them for fresh air .Thankfully my part of the world isn't AS against immigration and will stand up for their rights ,maybe thats because we had many driven out by force in the clearances so have some understanding of the issues .Through the letters and books written about our anscestors .

volver Sat 11-Jun-22 17:24:29

OK. So just because we don't have the appropriate systems in place that a modern country should be able to provide without even thinking about it, we'll take it out on the asylum seekers. And its really all about money, not about being humane. And as for pretending its for their own good?

Like I said. Pathetic.

garnet25 Sat 11-Jun-22 17:24:59

For those of you here who want to send refugees to Rwanda, I'll just say this.

I wouldn't be here if my mother had not been allowed into this country as a refugee from the Nazis. Some of you would no doubt wish she had been refused entry but Britain was a kinder country then.

HousePlantQueen Sat 11-Jun-22 17:30:02

Paddyanne, most people in England feel as you do, are ashamed of what the Johnson administration is doing and we are not like the unfeeling and cruel people who are stirred up by Farage and his like. As my late Grandfather often said "the emptiest tin makes the most noise"

volver Sat 11-Jun-22 17:33:32

I saw something earlier today about a protest in London, like the one in Scotland last year that prevented the unannounced extradition of asylum seekers. I just can't find it right now.

There are good people all over.

Thank you for telling us about your story garnet25

Kandinsky Sat 11-Jun-22 17:34:35

But these people aren’t escaping Nazis, they’re not escaping anyone. They’re already in a safe country ( France ) free from any harm.
They are economic migrants who think they’ll get a better deal here in the UK.

End of.

volver Sat 11-Jun-22 17:35:07

Can't be bothered any more.

End of.

Urmstongran Sat 11-Jun-22 17:35:13

Migrants risking their lives (mostly men) in the busiest waters and some drown. Gang masters raking it in - a highly lucrative business. Like buying in modern day slavery. Rubber dinghy passages paid to people smugglers who use high tech sophisticated methods to run their very profitable enterprises from Europe. This cannot be allowed to continue.

Urmstongran Sat 11-Jun-22 17:45:04

There was an article from an immigration official I read. He'd dealt with hundreds of asylum seekers who can't speak the language of the country they claim to be fleeing, can't name the capital or even the currency of that country. Others have impressive packages hoping to prove they are genuine but he said that was until you'd seen dozens of migrants with the same package but a different photo.

We are being taken for fools by some. We are too soft.

volver Sat 11-Jun-22 17:47:46

In the Telegraph was it?

RichmondPark Sat 11-Jun-22 17:49:57

Can you please provide a link to the article
Urmstongran?

Urmstongran Sat 11-Jun-22 17:52:31

You still posting volver? Thought you’d gone?

Might have been. They have articles written by individuals who write as a ‘secret’ somebody or other. They make for an interesting read. ‘Straight from the horse’s mouth’ so to speak.

Hmm. Might have been the Guardian though. I can’t remember but the job details were pretty darned illuminating.

RichmondPark Sat 11-Jun-22 17:55:26

They are economic migrants who think they’ll get a better deal here in the UK.

Migrants:-
Increase our labour force
Provide labour force flexibility
Create an increase in aggregate demand and Real GDP
Have a positive effect on the dependency ratio in our ageing population.

We benefit.

volver Sat 11-Jun-22 17:57:11

Ah well. Can't be bothered looking this up either? Forgotten where you saw it?

Let me explain this to you. There are people on here who actually know what they are talking about, that provide information from authoritative sources and who have the facts and figures at their disposal, and can back them up with verified research.

And there are some people that base their attitudes on unverifiable and exaggerated ideas from unnamed sources, that bear no relation to the truth, but they still expect people to believe them.

Pick your side.

Maudi Sat 11-Jun-22 17:59:25

?

Urmstongran Sat 11-Jun-22 18:00:47

I have thank you. I watch the news on tv. I read the papers written by journalists who witness events (some horrific and sad).

VioletSky Sat 11-Jun-22 18:01:12

Every one who is up for this should be the ones to actually do it.

Go look them in the eye, watch their tears, listen to their fears and their worries. Shake your head no when they ask you if they will ever see their families again.

Help them pack up their small belongings, tell them that the phone in their hands that holds all the connections to their previous life may no longer work.

Support them onto the transport, fly them to their unwanted unchosen destination and then turn your backs on their frightened bewildered faces in a country where they dont know the culture or speak the language.

And then come home to your privelidged life.

Lucky you

Kandinsky Sat 11-Jun-22 18:01:47

Can't be bothered any more

End of

Lasted all of 2 minutes grin

Urmstongran Sat 11-Jun-22 18:02:55

No relation to the truth? You jest beau.
???

Maudi Sat 11-Jun-22 18:03:48

They are fit young men who've paid thousand of euros to people smugglers don't be so naive.