Gransnet forums

News & politics

Penny Mordaunt's credibility is destroyed by her lies

(170 Posts)
varian Wed 13-Jul-22 21:46:21

In a letter to The Guardian, former UK Ambasssador to Turkey calls out Penny Mordaunt for her persistent lies about Turkey joining the EU.
www.theguardian.com/politics/2022/jul/12/penny-mordaunts-credibility-was-destroyed-by-her-claims-about-turkey

MayBee70 Fri 15-Jul-22 11:17:42

Now being interviewed by Beth Rigby. Only wants to talk about the economy.

Dickens Fri 15-Jul-22 11:11:54

Oh what a tangled web we weave, when first we practice to deceive...

£350 million, an influx of Turkish immigrants (millions of 'em I think).

The biggest deception of all though is encouraging the electorate to believe that the economy is run like a household budget and that there's no 'magic money tree' (well, we know there isn't a tree growing money, but there is the BoE and a keyboard)...

maddyone Fri 15-Jul-22 11:10:52

Mordaunt is a lightweight from what I’ve read about her.

Casdon Fri 15-Jul-22 10:10:50

There was a good one liner about Liz Truss on Twitter yesterday - She’d be out of her depth on a damp pavement.

There are a lot of dirty tricks being tried to discredit Mordaunt because she’s an unknown quantity - but surely a known quantity that is incompetent and supported by the people who got us into this mess, Lord Frost included, is much, much worse than an unknown quantity.

MayBee70 Fri 15-Jul-22 10:01:52

Jane43

The lie about Turkey joining the EU originated from Cummings, he encouraged MPs to repeat the mantra ‘NHS and Turkey’. I’m sure she wasn’t the only one to follow his advice.

That doesn’t make it ok though….and they were all happy to continue to defend Johnson’s lies for 3 years. I’m pretty sure they would have known about the goings on at No 10 as well.

Jane43 Fri 15-Jul-22 09:40:42

The lie about Turkey joining the EU originated from Cummings, he encouraged MPs to repeat the mantra ‘NHS and Turkey’. I’m sure she wasn’t the only one to follow his advice.

Ladyleftfieldlover Fri 15-Jul-22 09:33:40

I can’t warm to any of them. None have said that the Rwanda plan is a dreadful idea or properly condemned Boris Johnson for his lying or even admitted that the Brexit adventure is a total disaster. All they have to do is appeal to a bunch of Middle England Tory members. This is the first time I’ve thought there should be a GE in cases of a change of leader of the party in power.

Lovetopaint037 Fri 15-Jul-22 09:32:29

Also Frost hasn’t been elected and he isn’t an MP having been parachuted into the House of Lords and given a cabinet job by Johnson. Don’t know what he has contributed other than discord in the EU.

Lovetopaint037 Fri 15-Jul-22 09:28:18

Urmstongran

Oh heck .... this - just now from the Telegraph:

“Lord David Frost, the former Brexit chief negotiator, has told Talk TV he would have "grave reservations" about Penny Mordaunt becoming Prime Minister.

Citing his time working alongside her during the Brexit negotiations, when Mordaunt served as his junior, Lord Frost said she "wasn't fully accountable or always visible".

"To be honest, I'm quite surprised she is where she is in this race. She was my deputy - notionally more than really - in the Brexit talks last year," he said.

"I'm sorry to say this, she did not master the necessary detail in the negotiations last year. She wouldn't always deliver tough messages to the European Union when that was necessary and I'm afraid she wasn't fully accountable or always visible. Sometimes I didn't even know where she was."

"I'm afraid this became such a problem that after 6 months I had to ask the PM to move her on and find somebody else to support me."

"From the basis of what I saw, I would have grave reservations."

Anyone got any idea what Lord Frost has achieved with his Brexit negotiations? Just seems to me that it isn’t much. So for him to attempt to scupper Penny Mordaunts chances is a bit rich. More likely it is an attempt for the far right to put Truss in place. With Nadine and Reese backing the Foreign Secretary she needs all the help she can get.

MaizieD Thu 14-Jul-22 12:42:42

The article argued that the Tory members countrywide, want to see a clean sweep of the government and an entirely new set of faces.

That's as may be, but do they not realise that the PLP is dominated by the ERG and all the contenders for the leadership are bent on placating them?

Or does the membership want to see deregulation of food standards, worker's rights, austerity, privatised NHS, more sewage in our waterways, a failing court system, etc. etc.?

And the little matter of the NIP, which the ERG wants to destroy. And further disruption of trade with the EU when the TCA is fully implemented?

I think any attempt to defy the ERG would split the tory party... There's little hope for it, really.

winterwhite Thu 14-Jul-22 12:23:15

Can well believe that, Whitewave, but do they mean a GE which their party might not win or do they mean a new set of tory faces?
If the former, Yippee, but if the latter they're crying for the moon. A new PM does need significant experience and common sense and the best (e.g Dominic Grieve, Rory Stuart) were cast out in 2019 so no longer MPs.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 14-Jul-22 11:35:34

Reading an article today which I hope has an element of truth in it.

The article argued that the Tory members countrywide, want to see a clean sweep of the government and an entirely new set of faces.

Isn’t going to happen with this lot though.

Callistemon21 Thu 14-Jul-22 11:32:23

Whatever it is, though, this was money 'created' by the Bank of England; not 'borrowed' from anyone and therefore doesn't have to be paid back by anyone, least of all by taxpayers. So karmalady, and anyone else who persists in worrying about this entirely spurious belief, can relax. It's cost us or our descendants nothing at all

That's what I meant, Maizie but I was waiting for you to come along and explain it as I wasn't sure.

But is this what is called quantitative easing so in fact it does cost us all quite a lot in the longterm?

AGAA4 Thu 14-Jul-22 10:56:21

AGAA4

I don't think it matters which one becomes MP as none of them as far as I can see has integrity which for me along with other qualities necessary in a PM is essential.

PM*!

MaizieD Thu 14-Jul-22 10:51:42

Callistemon21

karmalady

I know someone who went to school with RS, what a slime ball he was then and still is. Spent the wealth that the future generation will needs to pay back. Personally, I received not one penny. Any of the women would be better than him

What wealth?

I believe that karmalady might be referring to the £37billion spaffed on the failed Test & Trace during the height of the covid pandemic. Or, perhaps the few £billion handed out to businesses for furlough or support on the basis of fraudulent claims. Or is it the excessive prices paid for useless PPE in contracts awarded to friends, families and tory donors...

Whatever it is, though, this was money 'created' by the Bank of England; not 'borrowed' from anyone and therefore doesn't have to be paid back by anyone, least of all by taxpayers. So karmalady, and anyone else who persists in worrying about this entirely spurious belief, can relax. It's cost us or our descendants nothing at all.

But it does raise the question of , if the government could create £billions to cover these things, and make many of its wealthy supporters even wealthier, why can't it create a £billion or so to invest in the NHS, which is at breaking point?

maddyone Thu 14-Jul-22 10:46:18

I agree karmalady.

MaizieD Thu 14-Jul-22 10:42:51

Casdon

I’m coming to the conclusion that the best candidate is Truss. She’s so transparently clueless and self serving that the government will fail quicker under her than any of the others. It will be painful for us all, but mercifully short and will guarantee the Tories fade into the wilderness for years. The campaign from the right within the party against Sunak makes me think he is the most capable candidate.

?

AGAA4 Thu 14-Jul-22 10:29:37

I don't think it matters which one becomes MP as none of them as far as I can see has integrity which for me along with other qualities necessary in a PM is essential.

Callistemon21 Thu 14-Jul-22 10:28:01

karmalady

I know someone who went to school with RS, what a slime ball he was then and still is. Spent the wealth that the future generation will needs to pay back. Personally, I received not one penny. Any of the women would be better than him

What wealth?

karmalady Thu 14-Jul-22 10:22:14

I know someone who went to school with RS, what a slime ball he was then and still is. Spent the wealth that the future generation will needs to pay back. Personally, I received not one penny. Any of the women would be better than him

NotSpaghetti Thu 14-Jul-22 10:19:52

Callistemon21 grin

Callistemon21 Thu 14-Jul-22 10:16:52

^I hear her launch went well^:

Continuing the Naval connections ?

Callistemon21 Thu 14-Jul-22 10:14:22

MayBee70

She’s named after a battleship that was torpedoed by a German submarine which sunk without trace with great loss of life.

There was a subsequent HMS Penelope, Leander class frigate which survived the Falklands war and was sold on to Uruguay, I believe.

I wonder if she was named after that one?

Casdon Thu 14-Jul-22 09:35:35

I’m coming to the conclusion that the best candidate is Truss. She’s so transparently clueless and self serving that the government will fail quicker under her than any of the others. It will be painful for us all, but mercifully short and will guarantee the Tories fade into the wilderness for years. The campaign from the right within the party against Sunak makes me think he is the most capable candidate.

Urmstongran Thu 14-Jul-22 09:13:11

David Frost is very highly thought of in Tory circles and amongst supporters MaizieD. His revelations will harm Mordant’s chances now. The fact that he asked Boris to remove her (which he did) will add credence to his viewpoint in my opinion.