Gransnet forums

News & politics

A certain book

(586 Posts)
AussieGran59 Wed 11-Jan-23 08:48:53

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Joseanne Wed 11-Jan-23 15:59:14

My DD is currently reading it. She is inquisitive -- nosy-- like her mother! Not that we are particularly bothered, you understand. DD thinks the book is a mixture; that Harry has rather "enjoyed" telling the juicy bits (as if he is the only person alive to have experienced x, y, z), that he might have gained some satisfaction closure from opening himself up, and that he is having a good laugh at his readership.
The book will be coming my way shortly, though I may have to disinfect it first. DD has covid you understand!
PS she rather likes Meghan and thinks a lot of the book is "written" by her.

Germanshepherdsmum Wed 11-Jan-23 16:02:23

The payments to charity are reported to have been made out of the advance. So as regards H’s receipt and his payments, not apples and oranges. I haven’t seen any assertion that the publisher will donate to charity. The advance is clearly H’s profit from ‘writing’ the book at this stage.

Shropshirelass Wed 11-Jan-23 16:02:28

You mean this one?

Germanshepherdsmum Wed 11-Jan-23 16:03:15

Is there any other?

Siope Wed 11-Jan-23 16:24:45

Germanshepherdsmum

The payments to charity are reported to have been made out of the advance. So as regards H’s receipt and his payments, not apples and oranges. I haven’t seen any assertion that the publisher will donate to charity. The advance is clearly H’s profit from ‘writing’ the book at this stage.

I see Harry has said the $1.8m will be a donation from him. I’d never looked before having zero interest.

I now have no idea why people are wittering about profit, when an author’s advances and royalties are, for tax and accounting purposes, income.

Germanshepherdsmum Wed 11-Jan-23 16:45:18

I don’t suppose posters are looking at the niceties of accounting practices. H has received income amounting to millions of dollars by way of an advance and H has paid out of that income a relatively pitiful sum to charity. Accounting practices are irrelevant to the principle that has been the subject of comment.

Smileless2012 Wed 11-Jan-23 16:48:08

Exactly GSM.

Maggiemaybe Wed 11-Jan-23 17:33:57

Seconded. How it happens is irrelevant.

The brilliant doctor and epidemiologist, John Wright, worked on the Covid ward of Bradford Royal Infirmary from the start of the epidemic. He somehow managed at the same time to do a regular podcast for the BBC in the form of a journal, documenting those dark days from his own experience. From that he’s written a book, The Coronavirus Doctor’s Diary, and it states on the first page that All proceeds from the sale of this book are donated to the Against Malaria Foundation who provide simple bed nets to help protect children and parents from malaria. All proceeds.

LucyLocket55 Wed 11-Jan-23 17:43:38

My daughter has just sent me a PDF copy of the book, apparently it was leaked from a supplier and is going out via WhatsApp. So no payment at all.

I read the first chapter all soft focus and syrupy and won’t read any further.

volver Wed 11-Jan-23 17:45:30

Oh, no concern or guilt about breaking the law in your family then?

varian Wed 11-Jan-23 17:46:56

Unfortunately poor Harry does not have the qualifications and experience to do the day-job John Wright does.

Selling his "true story" appears to be the only way he can earn a living and he obviously needs the money as his Dad has stopped the handouts and his wife has given up acting - or has she?

Germanshepherdsmum Wed 11-Jan-23 17:48:19

Who in the family is breaking the law volver?

vegansrock Wed 11-Jan-23 17:49:46

I trust all of those who say they’ll never read it also did not read any of the sensationalised extracts in the papers.

volver Wed 11-Jan-23 17:50:48

I would have thought that former legal folks would know about copyright laws. Maybe not.

Germanshepherdsmum Wed 11-Jan-23 17:54:40

Well volver, as you talked about someone in the family breaking the law I thought you would know who ’in the family’ had done that. Don’t be coy!

volver Wed 11-Jan-23 18:30:00

No I didn't. I asked whether their was any concern or guilt in the family in question, about breaking the law.

I'm developing a real worry about people being able to understand simple sentences, without just adding a bit that nobody ever said but that they have invented. Lot of it about at the moment.

volver Wed 11-Jan-23 18:30:31

There, not their!

FannyCornforth Wed 11-Jan-23 18:54:46

volver

There, not their!

Don’t worry. It’s not a biggie. A typo / autocorrect doesn’t mean that you are an imbecile

Silvergirl Wed 11-Jan-23 19:57:46

I am really enjoying this book on audio. I recommend audio as you can hear the emotion and sincerity in Harry’s voice. It is very easy to misinterpret the written word if you have preconceived ideas about a person. There is no doubt that he and Megan have had an extremely raw deal from the press.

Normandygirl Wed 11-Jan-23 21:08:40

Silvergirl

I am really enjoying this book on audio. I recommend audio as you can hear the emotion and sincerity in Harry’s voice. It is very easy to misinterpret the written word if you have preconceived ideas about a person. There is no doubt that he and Megan have had an extremely raw deal from the press.

Why is there "no doubt" ?
Speaking "with emotion" has no bearing on whether something is factual or not. It only confirms how they feel about it.

Sarah75 Wed 11-Jan-23 21:16:28

There is no doubt that he and Megan ( perceive themselves to ) have had an extremely raw deal from the press.

Callistemon21 Wed 11-Jan-23 22:09:52

Joseanne

My DD is currently reading it. She is inquisitive -- nosy-- like her mother! Not that we are particularly bothered, you understand. DD thinks the book is a mixture; that Harry has rather "enjoyed" telling the juicy bits (as if he is the only person alive to have experienced x, y, z), that he might have gained some satisfaction closure from opening himself up, and that he is having a good laugh at his readership.
The book will be coming my way shortly, though I may have to disinfect it first. DD has covid you understand!
PS she rather likes Meghan and thinks a lot of the book is "written" by her.

that Harry has rather "enjoyed" telling the juicy bits (as if he is the only person alive to have experienced x, y, z)

😂
I did say at the weekend that teenage DGC think they invented the wheel 😂😂😂

Oops, yes, I know, Harry is not a teenager.
But his children will be one day.

Callistemon21 Wed 11-Jan-23 22:11:39

Germanshepherdsmum

Siope

I understand that a fixed sum is going to charity, so whether it’s a small percentage of overall profit depends on how many are sold, and at what price.

It has been reported that H received a $20m advance for his book and has paid £1.5m to two charities (in total).

Right - firstly what is the exchange rate?

Joseanne Wed 11-Jan-23 22:35:31

I'm so sorry, but this just occurred to me.

Callistemon21 Wed 11-Jan-23 22:38:35

But Paddington is so sensible!