Can a woman have a penis?

In answer to the OP, no she can't. What's more, who can I vote for? I will never vote Tory, even if the Angel Gabriel stood in my constituency, and how can I vote for a party whose leader doesn't know what I am? (Hint, I'm a woman, adult human female, and I don't have a penis).

No.

People who have genital surgery acquire a facsimile of an organ, but not the real thing, imo.

FannyCornforth

Sago

A woman can have a penis but it doesn’t make her a man.

We’re getting into riddle territory here!

It's down to chromosomes not physical appearance a woman has xx a man has xy no kind of treatment or surgery can change that as far as I am aware.
Some babies can be difficult to decide what sex they are by just looking but the chromosome test shows.
Riddle or widdle Fanny?

A big no.

Why cannot trans women be content to be simply - trans women. Given the same respect as any other human being. With or without surgery or hormone treatment, beards, penis. Wearing a dress if they feel like it, or joggers, leggings or even a grass skirt if the mood takes them.

But allow that XX and XY is the ultimate arbiter of biological sex. And that in certain settings - all described many times on GN, women do not want to share the same space... for reasons also outlined many times also.

Trans women and women share various interests - I'm sure. But our lived experiences will be different.

TW, with full male genitalia who insist they are women are, IMO, practising another form of misogyny - by defining womanhood - to their advantage. And it gives them power over women which they wouldn't otherwise have.

NO, a woman cannot have a penis.

I do not think a woman can have a penis however I will refer to someone by whatever title, pro noun, or gender they want to be, it doesn’t affect me but may be a big deal to them.

AmberSpyglass

Yes. 100%, unqualified, wholehearted yes. I love and respect my trans sisters, and their genitalia is as female as mine is.

This is a joke right? Otherwise what planet are you on.

Here we go again (ad nauseam). Are we talking about biological sex - or gender? Why do so many on here not know the definitions - or the difference?

mrsgreenfingers56

A big no.

An even bigger NO

Well I'm talking about biological sex as the vast majority of respondents are doing.

A woman cannot have a penis and a surgically manufactured appendage doesn't qualify which is why there are women and trans women.

No.

I can’t say that I blame Starmer for sitting on the fence.

Whatever the bloke says will only stir up the ghastly business again.

I think that we can all guess what he really thinks.

I know that he should be standing up for women, but he’s got an awful lot on his plate.

As I’ve said before, in relation to Brexit, I just want Labour to get over the line next year

99.9% of women are born without a penis. FACT

Let's flip the question. Can a man have a vagina?

99.9% of men are born without a vagina.

So the fact is that a tiny minority of babies are born with both genitalia intact. The parents usually decide the sex of the baby with the help of the doctors.

So the fact is that a female can have a penis. I don’t know what all the fuss is about tbh.

How are you defining women Whitewavemark2? And men?

🤦‍♀️

Sorry? Is it not obvious from my posts?

No babies are born with a formed penis and a formed vulva. A tiny percentage of babies are born with indeterminate genitalia. Nowadays advance testing methods allow the medics to know what sex the baby is, male or female.

Whitewavemark2

So the fact is that a tiny minority of babies are born with both genitalia intact. The parents usually decide the sex of the baby with the help of the doctors.

So the fact is that a female can have a penis. I don’t know what all the fuss is about tbh.

In the past the decision was often made by medical staff- and the 'easiest' was to cut off the penis and/or scrotum- and designate baby as female.

WWm2 'So the fact is that a female can have a penis. I don’t know what all the fuss is about tbh.'

it is amazing that so many here, and elsewhere, are obsessed with this ?!?

Whitewavemark2

So the fact is that a tiny minority of babies are born with both genitalia intact. The parents usually decide the sex of the baby with the help of the doctors.

So the fact is that a female can have a penis. I don’t know what all the fuss is about tbh.

I remember reading a great deal in the 1960's about babies in some parts of the world whose gender was not clear at birth. As WWM says doctors would help parents to decided on the sex which sometimes led to psychological anguish in later life. I found these links on line whilst trying to locate the literature I had studied and found these:
8. The clitoris can form a penis – and vice versa
In some forms of gender confirmation surgery, the clitoris can be enlarged with hormones to form a penis. In other cases, the penile glans can be reduced in size and relocated to create a clitoris.
www.theguardian.com/society/2017/jan/23/clitbait-10-things-you-didnt-know-about-the-clitoris
www.pbs.org/independentlens/content/two-spirits_map-html/ This map gives links to countries where this phenomenon may be more of an issue. Of course it may all just be AI these days...

Rosie51

No babies are born with a formed penis and a formed vulva. A tiny percentage of babies are born with indeterminate genitalia. Nowadays advance testing methods allow the medics to know what sex the baby is, male or female.

I thought that is what I said. But honestly I really really have no inclination to get into conversation about this, as I think there is a lot of nonsense talked.

maddyone

AmberSpyglass

Yes. 100%, unqualified, wholehearted yes. I love and respect my trans sisters, and their genitalia is as female as mine is.

Did you do O Level Biology?

How do you know AmberSpyglass?
Actually, don't answer that question please!

And saying their genitalia is as female as mine is is meaningless as we know nothing about you.