Gransnet forums

News & politics

Bonus Holes..as an alternative to a vagina.

(189 Posts)
DiamondLily Sun 09-Jul-23 09:36:42

From a Woman's charity, dedicated to women's health,

What a revolting name, for a vagina. Who thinks up this nonsense?🙄

Julie Bindell has written an article for the DM:

"As holes go, they are arguably the most important in the world. Every man and woman ever to have lived – except those born by caesarean section – has sprung forth into this world from one.

And yet a charity dedicated to women's health, Jo's Cervical Cancer Trust, is suggesting that the word 'vagina' could be referred to as the 'bonus hole' to avoid offending or excluding trans men or 'non-binary' people.

As a feminist campaigner, I am appalled. I've spent time over the decades trying to raise awareness among women about our bodies.

I've encouraged women to unlearn the shame associated with our biology.

So the idea that we should stop referring to the vagina by its name is grossly offensive.

I grew up absorbing the message that our bodies were dirty.

We would use euphemisms to describe its parts, because 'vagina' and even 'breast' were considered unpleasant.

I recall, back in the Eighties, buying tampons only to have the shopkeeper quickly put the box in a brown paper bag as if it were a porn magazine. But we feminists learned to take pride in our physical form.

I would shake the tampons out of the bag to make the point that I was not ashamed of menstruating. After all, it's a reality for half the population.

It's worth noting that this form of McCarthyite censorship is reserved for descriptions of female anatomy only. That's why this is nothing short of misogyny.

There is no such suggestion, of course, to swap words that men use to describe their biology.

Perhaps, to be fair, we should change 'penis' to 'flesh roll' to avoid offending trans women? I'm sure men won't object. Just a thought."

www.dailymail.co.uk/columnists/article-12278639/JULIE-BINDEL-says-womens-health-charity-guilty-short-misogyny-again.html

FarNorth Mon 10-Jul-23 08:46:26

Here's how things are going for the Vagina Monologues.

www.andreajames.com/photos/all-transgender-vagina-monologues/

www.buzzfeed.com/1demerith/performing-in-the-vagina-monologues-as-a-transgender-woman

DiamondLily Mon 10-Jul-23 08:42:59

It is a woman's charity, aiming to give health information to women. All women.

I don't even understand the logic - as adult humans, we know what most body parts are called, regardless of whether we've got one or not.

Biological men understand what a vagina is, and biological women know what a penis is.

A biological man, regardless of identifying, will not have the same medical issues as a biological woman.

A biological man does not need cervical smears, fibroid ops, hysterectomies or anything along those lines.

A biological woman will not need prostate tests, or need scans for any testicular swelling.

Surely, if someone considers themselves well balanced and intelligent enough to change gender, they can cope with body parts being given their long held and traditional names?

This country seems like a parallel universe at times..🙄

NotSpaghetti Mon 10-Jul-23 08:20:41

I think VS was saying that this was an option put forward for a particular group of trans people to use if they wished.

I don't believe the idea was to use it instead of "vagina" for anyone else!

nanna8 Mon 10-Jul-23 08:17:12

I wonder which revolting specimen dreamed up that term ? Can’t be a human, surely? Must be a robot..

Iam64 Mon 10-Jul-23 08:03:03

Nan Kate I think we know the answer to that one 😕

NanKate Mon 10-Jul-23 07:58:25

I agree Maddyone.

And who is this ‘Bonus’ for ?

maddyone Sun 09-Jul-23 19:53:10

Bonus hole or front hole? How damned condescending! It’s a vagina!

Iam64 Sun 09-Jul-23 19:49:43

Women need to feel confident seeking medical treatment. Why should the medical term for vagina be changed to something misogynistic ? Trans people, like women, will be familiar with the complexities of discussing intimate details

Are we to dismiss the groups of women whose culture make these intimate examinations and discussions even more difficult. Women who were subject the female genital mutilation as children for example? They’re in physical and emotional need of effective support during pregnancy and childbirth. English may not be their first language, the may be expected to be chaperoned by a male relative.

GrannyGravy13 Sun 09-Jul-23 19:35:02

DiamondLily

VioletSky

The actual context is trying to find a term trans men and non binary people feel comfortable using in order to help them feel confident seeking medical treatment.

But why accept a rational explanation when you can just get all angry about it, assign lots of untruths to the whole situation and use it as another stick to beat trans people with even though they aren't directly responsible anyway

The GC are creating their own distruction by pandering to what amounts to conspiracy theory nonsense and will eventually find no place to be heard an I'm not sure that's necessarily a good thing when there are actual real issues that need to be resolved

That's why there is no place for me on these threads... I'm not interested in being swept up in hysteria and want resolutions to real issues...

So I don't really bother any more

But you are on here and bothering...😉

Your first sentence,

to make them feel confident seeking medical treatment

Trans are informed adults, they know the terminology to describe how they feel in the wrong body ergo they must also know the correct terminology for anatomy.

It’s not all about the trans community it is about women who have had vaginas since Eve, and should continue to have vaginas until the demise of the human race…

GrannyGravy13 Sun 09-Jul-23 19:31:11

Iam64

There’s a tv prog I believe - the vagina monologues. I wonder if some poor, demented producer is considering a rebrand - bonus hole monologues?

Im so fed up with this nonsense

I have seen the stage production of The Vagina Monologues, I cried and laughed equally.

Esmay Sun 09-Jul-23 18:47:59

DiamondLily - that's a totally brilliant reaction to your hysterectomy .

My father says odd things all the time .

Once in the middle of a restaurant , he asked very loudly , what's an orgasm ?

I am convinced that I was conceived by immaculate conception .

DiamondLily Sun 09-Jul-23 18:29:33

VioletSky

The actual context is trying to find a term trans men and non binary people feel comfortable using in order to help them feel confident seeking medical treatment.

But why accept a rational explanation when you can just get all angry about it, assign lots of untruths to the whole situation and use it as another stick to beat trans people with even though they aren't directly responsible anyway

The GC are creating their own distruction by pandering to what amounts to conspiracy theory nonsense and will eventually find no place to be heard an I'm not sure that's necessarily a good thing when there are actual real issues that need to be resolved

That's why there is no place for me on these threads... I'm not interested in being swept up in hysteria and want resolutions to real issues...

So I don't really bother any more

But you are on here and bothering...😉

Iam64 Sun 09-Jul-23 18:28:23

There’s a tv prog I believe - the vagina monologues. I wonder if some poor, demented producer is considering a rebrand - bonus hole monologues?

Im so fed up with this nonsense

DiamondLily Sun 09-Jul-23 18:28:21

Esmay

More nonsense !

Here's a brilliant word for vagina - fun factory !

My father is really up tight and peculiar about things and that's what he called it the other day !

I'm with you. I needed a full hysterectomy at age 30, and a nurse came around, complete with sad/sympathetic voice/face on, to ask me if I felt I'd be traumatised by this....I just told her I was fine with the nursery going as long as they left the playground intact lol 😉

But, with this thread - I find the term "bonus hole" to be revolting.🥴

Any transman might want to feel like a man (all fine), but surely they have the intellectual and emotional wherewithal to still be able to address their biological female organ by its proper name? 🤔

Esmay Sun 09-Jul-23 18:13:40

More nonsense !

Here's a brilliant word for vagina - fun factory !

My father is really up tight and peculiar about things and that's what he called it the other day !

Ilovecheese Sun 09-Jul-23 17:59:47

Lathyrus

It’s a vagina VS. Like a pancreas is a pancreas or an appendix is an appendix. It’s a medical term for a body part.

If you’ve got one that’s what you’ve got. No need for baby talk with adults surely.

Very succinctly put.
Besides, it's not a hole is it, more of a passage.

Lathyrus Sun 09-Jul-23 17:54:48

Why do people come onto threads to say they’re not going to bother coming onto the thread?🙄😂

Lathyrus Sun 09-Jul-23 17:52:37

It’s a vagina VS. Like a pancreas is a pancreas or an appendix is an appendix. It’s a medical term for a body part.

If you’ve got one that’s what you’ve got. No need for baby talk with adults surely.

Galaxy Sun 09-Jul-23 16:21:54

GC people are doing fine VS. Dont you worry.
Another successful court case this week.

VioletSky Sun 09-Jul-23 16:17:51

The actual context is trying to find a term trans men and non binary people feel comfortable using in order to help them feel confident seeking medical treatment.

But why accept a rational explanation when you can just get all angry about it, assign lots of untruths to the whole situation and use it as another stick to beat trans people with even though they aren't directly responsible anyway

The GC are creating their own distruction by pandering to what amounts to conspiracy theory nonsense and will eventually find no place to be heard an I'm not sure that's necessarily a good thing when there are actual real issues that need to be resolved

That's why there is no place for me on these threads... I'm not interested in being swept up in hysteria and want resolutions to real issues...

So I don't really bother any more

Pammie1 Sun 09-Jul-23 15:25:11

So basically it’s not acceptable to use ‘vagina’ because it offends male to female transgender people. But it’s perfectly fine to offend natal women by suggesting that using this terminology is somehow wrong and offensive in itself. OK then.

And while we’re at it, why does the term ‘cis’ need to be applied as a prefix to either a man or woman whose gender identity corresponds to their sex assigned at birth ? They are men and women, no further explanation necessary.

Smileless2012 Sun 09-Jul-23 15:16:52

Saying 'down there' if someone's embarrassed to use the correct terminology is one thing, referring to a vagina as a 'bonus hole' is something else entirely and has only been suggested to pander to the trans gender community.

NanKate Sun 09-Jul-23 15:11:56

I’m absolutely sickened. As I have said before we are living in an alternative universe. Yes spot on Auntieflo ‘The King’s New Clothes’ has now become a frightening reality.

A year or two back I had some sympathy for the trans community, but this has been totally demolished by the militant members.

As I regularly repeat on GN my much loved Women’s Institute has been infiltrated by the militant trans community and when I wrote to our governing body asking why as a democratic group we hadn’t been given an opportunity to vote, they replied if I wasn’t happy I could leave! Outrageous IMO.

I have signed the Women’s Institute Declaration online (anyone can vote and anonymously too) demanding a vote by members. We need 5,000 votes for a moratorium, we are currently on 2,888, we need more support.

I think we need to band together like our grandmother suffragettes did all those years ago or we will be living in a permanent trans world.

nexus63 Sun 09-Jul-23 14:53:06

being brought up by my elderly grandmother she always said privates and when asking about my periods she always said, have you come on. i am not really bothered what people call it, most children grew up having names for it. telling a male neighbour/friend i had cancer again, instead of vulva cancer i just said it's down there, some people still get embarrassed saying vagina and vulva...don't know why, if you are female you know you have a vagina and a vulva so why get bothered about someone else using another name.

Smileless2012 Sun 09-Jul-23 14:50:31

If were your GC's parent Spninnaker I'd be going in to the school and asking what on earth is going on.