BBC presenter allegations.

No matter what happens in my life the last thing I would do would be to approach The Sun for help.

Germanshepherdsmum

I don’t see depression as an excuse.
If this hadn’t been made public would he still be carrying on as before? Would he be in hospital?

I have had a total breakdown and I agree with ug your private and public persona behaviour is entirely different. Do not assume my private behaviour involved sexual behaviour.

Because none of us know quite why the mother of the first young person decided to approach The Sun, we are speculating based on what we think we probably would've done under the same circumstances Dickens

Most of you have been speculating all along Dickins and I have no doubt the Sun loved you for it. It really would be good if it stopped now until we a given more facts by those officially investigating this.

Some cannot accept depression is a serious illness GSM

DaisyAnneReturns

So we have been given a clear example of mankind not changing from the days when the beautiful girl was beaten out of the village because somebody swore they saw her use witchcraft to kill their cow. This would then be piled on by other villagers building the story from their imaginations.

I feel so sorry for Huw Edward's and equally his family. Seeing a loved one with severe depression is terrible and incredibly distressing.

I also feel very sorry for the young person at the centre of this. Their life has also been used by others to their own ends.

Hopefully we will now let those with the power to do so continue and complete their investigations.

To be fair, the young man's parents threw it all into the red top arena.

I can, perhaps, see why they have been estranged by their son.🙄

Time to let it be, and move on now.

Urmstongran

This used to be known as a nervous breakdown. A clash between his public persona and his private activities. Whilst these were ‘under wraps’ Huw was stable. Then a seismic shock has taken him under. But he is a very wealthy man and will be extremely well looked after.

Enough now.
Time to move on.

👍 yes you are right.

I don’t see depression as an excuse.
If this hadn’t been made public would he still be carrying on as before? Would he be in hospital?

This used to be known as a nervous breakdown. A clash between his public persona and his private activities. Whilst these were ‘under wraps’ Huw was stable. Then a seismic shock has taken him under. But he is a very wealthy man and will be extremely well looked after.

Enough now.
Time to move on.

Someone on Facebook described how an interview with them by the Sun was totally fabricated but done in such a clever way that legally they were beyond reproach. And that that person has suffered ever since from the fact that no one believed that he didn’t say the things that The Sun reported.

Yes thats what a discussion about the issues relating to the purchase of sexual services is like.

I’m surprised that some people on here appear not to have known who it was. It’s been unofficially known for some time.

I feel sad for him and his family. My anger is reserved for The Sun newspaper - what a rag.

If Huw is ill, I hope he gets well. He will get the best care. I suffer with severe depression. It is hell. However, I agree with Doodledog that all too often celebrities cite mental health when they are found out as not being what they project on screen.

So we have been given a clear example of mankind not changing from the days when the beautiful girl was beaten out of the village because somebody swore they saw her use witchcraft to kill their cow. This would then be piled on by other villagers building the story from their imaginations.

I feel so sorry for Huw Edward's and equally his family. Seeing a loved one with severe depression is terrible and incredibly distressing.

I also feel very sorry for the young person at the centre of this. Their life has also been used by others to their own ends.

Hopefully we will now let those with the power to do so continue and complete their investigations.

tickingbird

I Hope he’s receiving the help he needs and this judging will stop. Only someone with MH issues would be so open when using these sites. It’s very sad.

Terribly sad, terribly complex all round, messed up with social media and god know what behind the lives involved tickingbird

I hope all in need get the help needed and I wish the Sun could be shut down on this.

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

I’m totally stunned. The Richard Dimbleby of our age. I feel for his wife & family how horrendous for them this must be. He will retire with mental health pressure now I should imagine. He will be in a precarious state. A tragic situation for all concerned including the troubled young man. Two families shattered.

I Hope he’s receiving the help he needs and this judging will stop. Only someone with MH issues would be so open when using these sites. It’s very sad.

Yes I think it's almost impossible to solve. The government announced an enquiry into porn and its impact on young people, but if that actually happened I missed it.

I don't know what else the BBC has to carry on investigating.
Time will tell, I suppose. There is a difference between what an employer needs to know and what will interest the police.

I realise that this will not be a popular point of view, but Phillip Schofield also claimed that the exposure was bad for his mental health and the press backed off. I am not minimising the impact of MH on an individual, but it can't be used as an excuse for bad behaviour, or as a way of avoiding consequences, can it? Obviously while he is in hospital his treatment has to be given priority, but later?

NanaDada, if I could be bothered to go through 27 pages on this thread alone, and drag up comments made by you, I think it would be clear who is doing the judging of others. My remark was in response to whoever said he needed help. You will no doubt be pleased that he is getting it now. Let others worry about the possible impact of all of this on the young men who are also part of the story, and of the mother in the case.

Galaxy, I agree that something should be done about the impact of porn in general and maybe sites such as Only Fans in particular. I have no idea what, though, as it seems that it is endemic.

Such a shock to me. Seemingly suffered with deep depression for years. Currently in hospital again and is receiving treatment. He always seems competent calm and very accomplished broadcaster. Not expected him at all - a few others sprung to mind though.

Because none of us know quite why the mother of the first young person decided to approach The Sun, we are speculating based on what we think we probably would've done under the same circumstances. I think it's a normal response, but it might imply criticism of the mother - however she obviously had her reason for doing this... and that is the important thing.

But speculating on it is not necessarily idle gossip. We all like to make sense of what is happening around us - on any issue, and when reliable information and facts are thin on the ground, this is how we deal with it... if it's an issue that we are interested in, or which bothers us.

The legality or otherwise of what actually happened between the presenter and the young person will eventually be established. For some, that will be the end of the matter, others may still have questions or concerns if indeed it turns out that no law has been broken.

As for the others that have now come forward with complaints of their own - for me, this muddies the waters to the extent that I'm now going to mentally switch off. This kind of thing happens when someone well-known has had accusations made against them. And the truth will only be established when there has been a thorough and proper investigation.

Apparently, certain sections of social media are buzzing with hints and the actual name of the person accused. Sleuthing would probably reveal who the presenter is. But I have no intention of being a sleuth because that does feel like delving into the 'prurient'. And if this all comes to nought, I'd feel rather ashamed of being so idly curious. Also, it's depressing enough without knowing the identity - just the simple fact of the possibility of yet another person in a powerful position abusing it - it's enough for the moment.

The media is making a meal of the affair - par for the course unfortunately. Click-bait and revenue. I've lost my appetite.

Casdon

Mollygo

Now he’s been named, will they also name the other person concerned?

I sincerely hope not. The young person deserves privacy as they have had this brought on their head without their permission.

The young man never wanted this to happen so I hope he won’t be named.
I expect Huw Edwards will retire now, no criminal charges to be brought.

Hugh Edwards. I feel sorry for him too.

Foxygloves, i think this sort of thing is a lot more common than we realise, we just don't usually find out about it.

I feel sorry though for his wife and family.