Gransnet forums

News & politics

The “yes” vote in Australia

(158 Posts)
Whitewavemark2 Wed 13-Sept-23 08:21:14

I am interested in any Australian posters and their thought on the yes vote.

I’ve read a bit about it and listened to TRIP which featured it this week.

The vote is about the indigenous population choosing 24 representatives to be able to allow their voices to be heard at national level.

My initial thoughts are “why not?” Given the fact that they only represent 3% of the total population in Australia, and on every single measure have the worst outcomes, from health to education to employment etc.

I suspect that their voices are always drowned out as a result of almost certainly there being a tiny minority (if any) returned to parliament. It can only be a good thing to have a vehicle through which your voice can be heard.

Katie59 Sun 15-Oct-23 15:34:31

I’m not surprised by a no vote, a great deal of money and effort has been expended in recent years trying the help the indigenous population, Your average Australian thinks it’s mostly been wasted because very little progress has been made, they don’t want to change their lifestyle

Quokka Sun 15-Oct-23 15:37:16

Why should indigenous peoples be expected to integrate?

Callistemon21 Sun 15-Oct-23 15:47:21

Aboriginal people and Torres Strait Islanders are disparate groups of people with different heritage.

Those people who want to live in the original ways can do so, although children must be schooled, but many do not. Many Aboriginal people do go on to university, (not a representative proportion) TAFE, work in jobs and professions and are part of the diverse communities. However, there is still a long way to go and the hope is that there are other ways forward now.
Let's hope that holding the referendum has not been a backwards step.

mokryna Thu 19-Oct-23 10:19:53

I read somewhere that some people voted no because they were worried about being charged land taxes. Which people would they be talking about?

Callistemon21 Thu 19-Oct-23 18:46:16

mokryna

I read somewhere that some people voted no because they were worried about being charged land taxes. Which people would they be talking about?

Farmers who bought their farms in good faith worrying about paying land taxes to the people who say they are the original owners of that land.

A volunteer group which wished to plant thousands of trees along a river in WA were threatened with a $2.5 million tax for approval of the scheme by the newly formed Whadjuk Aboriginal Corporation, who claimed the land was of cultural significance.

The new Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Act, which came into force this year in WA, has now been repealed, I think (but don't quote me!).

mokryna Thu 19-Oct-23 19:28:03

Thank you

Callistemon21 Thu 19-Oct-23 20:37:47

mokryna

Thank you

Perhaps an Australian Gransnetter might be along to say that I've got it all wrong! but this is just a precis of what I have heard from people I know who have been pondering about which way to vote in the referendum,.