Gransnet forums

News & politics

Another Tory MP defects to Labour!

(124 Posts)
LizzieDrip Wed 08-May-24 13:14:06

Yet another defection by a Tory MP today. Natalie Elphick has obviously done this to make a point. She’s already said she’s standing down at the next GE but clearly wanted to cause a rumpus for the Tories. Her statement is scathing about Sunak. At this rate we won’t need a GE - all the Tory MPs will just voluntarily move over to the Labour seatsgrin

Oreo Wed 08-May-24 16:25:57

My enemy’s enemy is my friend wink

Urmstongran Wed 08-May-24 17:20:00

Mrs Elphicke is a bit of a loser who was given her seat by her local party because they felt sorry for her because her husband couldn't keep his fellow in his trousers and assaulted other women.
She should never have been selected .
There were no grounds other than pity for selecting her. She wasn't qualified in any way other than being an ex civil servant.
The Conservatives continue to be caught out by the old saying that Conservatives fall on sex scandals and Labour falls on money scandals (Angela?)
They continue to appoint candidates who aren't conservative but whose face fit with the left leaning One Nation Group - which is run by a porn addict.

Casdon Wed 08-May-24 17:24:21

Only you would describe the One Nation Group as left leaning Urmstongran. Moderate conservatism is nearer the mark.

Wyllow3 Wed 08-May-24 17:40:31

LizzieDrip

I think the fact that neither of the defectors will be standing at the next GE was important in KS’s decision making here. Perhaps, if either had been intending to stand (particularly Elphick) there might have been a different outcome. As things stand, it’s all politicking! That said, if KS had turned them away, I dare say some would accuse him of being ‘holier than thou’. Tories are masters at playing the politics game; Labour has to do the same … whether we like it or not.

Necessary but not desirable. Not trustable.

Wyllow3 Wed 08-May-24 17:44:27

Urmstongran

Mrs Elphicke is a bit of a loser who was given her seat by her local party because they felt sorry for her because her husband couldn't keep his fellow in his trousers and assaulted other women.
She should never have been selected .
There were no grounds other than pity for selecting her. She wasn't qualified in any way other than being an ex civil servant.
The Conservatives continue to be caught out by the old saying that Conservatives fall on sex scandals and Labour falls on money scandals (Angela?)
They continue to appoint candidates who aren't conservative but whose face fit with the left leaning One Nation Group - which is run by a porn addict.

"Labour falls on money scandals (Angela?)"

Had to laugh. the £1.500 compared with Conservative rip offs out of the public purse.

Whitewavemark2 Wed 08-May-24 17:56:19

Elphicke isn’t left leaning😄😄.

Cossy Wed 08-May-24 18:03:05

Goodness the “lefty” “lefties” and “left leaning” comments on this site are actually hilarious atm!

Casdon Wed 08-May-24 18:03:13

Wyllow3

LizzieDrip

I think the fact that neither of the defectors will be standing at the next GE was important in KS’s decision making here. Perhaps, if either had been intending to stand (particularly Elphick) there might have been a different outcome. As things stand, it’s all politicking! That said, if KS had turned them away, I dare say some would accuse him of being ‘holier than thou’. Tories are masters at playing the politics game; Labour has to do the same … whether we like it or not.

Necessary but not desirable. Not trustable.

They are quite different scenarios though. Dan Poulter is not a ‘difficult’ MP, he made the choice based on his own conscience, and hasn’t courted publicity. Had he been keen to continue as an MP presumably Labour would have accommodated him.

Wyllow3 Wed 08-May-24 18:57:07

Yes I agree - Dan Poulter is a different case altogether.

HousePlantQueen Wed 08-May-24 19:21:59

Well I think the best comment on this has to be from Count Binface on Twitter/X. He said that Ms. Elphicke had attempted to defect to his party, but he prefers to take rubbish out, not bring it in. 🤣

MissInterpreted Wed 08-May-24 19:24:13

I honestly believe that if an MP defects from one party to another, then there should automatically be a by-election. After all, the electorate is voting for a particular party at the ballot box.

Whitewavemark2 Wed 08-May-24 19:25:53

HousePlantQueen

Well I think the best comment on this has to be from Count Binface on Twitter/X. He said that Ms. Elphicke had attempted to defect to his party, but he prefers to take rubbish out, not bring it in. 🤣

Yes I saw that - brilliant - and can’t help but agree.

Casdon Wed 08-May-24 19:29:34

MissInterpreted

I honestly believe that if an MP defects from one party to another, then there should automatically be a by-election. After all, the electorate is voting for a particular party at the ballot box.

I agree with that, but not just for those who change party. I think those who are forced for whatever reason to leave their party and are therefore independents should also be subject to a by election. There are currently 17 of them, that can’t be right.

MissInterpreted Wed 08-May-24 20:25:39

Yes, I agree on that score too, Casdon.

growstuff Wed 08-May-24 20:39:45

Cossy

Goodness the “lefty” “lefties” and “left leaning” comments on this site are actually hilarious atm!

It's the GN equivalent of McCarthyism.

growstuff Wed 08-May-24 20:44:17

Urmstongran

Mrs Elphicke is a bit of a loser who was given her seat by her local party because they felt sorry for her because her husband couldn't keep his fellow in his trousers and assaulted other women.
She should never have been selected .
There were no grounds other than pity for selecting her. She wasn't qualified in any way other than being an ex civil servant.
The Conservatives continue to be caught out by the old saying that Conservatives fall on sex scandals and Labour falls on money scandals (Angela?)
They continue to appoint candidates who aren't conservative but whose face fit with the left leaning One Nation Group - which is run by a porn addict.

According to Wiki, she's done more than many MPs have:

"Elphicke was the author of the 2010 report Housing People; Financing Housing for the conservative think-tank Policy Exchange.[4] She led the Conservative Policy Forum when it was launched in 2011.[5] Elphicke worked for Stephenson Harwood, becoming a partner in their banking practice. She left in 2013 to found Million Homes, Million Lives, with Calum Mercer, a former finance director at Circle Housing.[6][7] However, this company was dissolved in 2016.[8] She was a non-executive director of the Student Loans Company, and chair of its Audit and Risk Committee. She was also an independent member of the Audit and Risk Committee at the Department for Education."

She doesn't sound like a loser.

Cossy Wed 08-May-24 20:46:11

MissInterpreted

I honestly believe that if an MP defects from one party to another, then there should automatically be a by-election. After all, the electorate is voting for a particular party at the ballot box.

I agree.

Casdon Wed 08-May-24 21:00:39

growstuff

Cossy

Goodness the “lefty” “lefties” and “left leaning” comments on this site are actually hilarious atm!

It's the GN equivalent of McCarthyism.

I’m proposing that we form a LLL support group, this is my suggestion for our anthem. I guarantee you’ll like it all you LLLs out there.
m.youtube.com/watch?v=UMVjToYOjbM

vegansrock Wed 08-May-24 21:06:31

I guess it’s politicking to further embarrass the Tories. She’s never going to be standing as a Labour candidate so making Sunak squirm is just a game.

Wyllow3 Wed 08-May-24 21:13:21

growstuff

Cossy

Goodness the “lefty” “lefties” and “left leaning” comments on this site are actually hilarious atm!

It's the GN equivalent of McCarthyism.

I recall McCarthyism all too well (parents were strong socialists)

So I propose all the population be subject to:

"Are you, or anyone you know, has ever been a member or sympathiser of One Nation Conservatives, that dangerous crypto communist body"

growstuff Wed 08-May-24 21:23:52

Casdon

growstuff

Cossy

Goodness the “lefty” “lefties” and “left leaning” comments on this site are actually hilarious atm!

It's the GN equivalent of McCarthyism.

I’m proposing that we form a LLL support group, this is my suggestion for our anthem. I guarantee you’ll like it all you LLLs out there.
m.youtube.com/watch?v=UMVjToYOjbM

Sad that only Jeff Lynne is still alive.

Casdon Wed 08-May-24 21:25:46

Bob Dylan is too I think/hope - they were just so brilliant.

grumppa Wed 08-May-24 22:03:09

With all these Conservative defections, Labour is in danger of making itself unelectable.

MaizieD Wed 08-May-24 22:06:43

Yes, Bob Dylan is still with us.

Callistemon21 Wed 08-May-24 22:50:01

Grantanow

'... and then there were none'!

I did say a while ago that with all the by-elections (plus now the defections) we won't need to bother with a General Election 😃