Gransnet forums

News & politics

Disability benefits and Mel Stride

(19 Posts)
MadeInYorkshire Fri 10-May-24 13:15:47

In case you actually are "outraged of Tunbridge Wells," I would like to set the record straight regarding Mr Mel Stride's (Secretary of State for Work and Pensions) appearances on tv in the last couple of weeks.

He appeared on both Good Morning Britain and BBC Breakfast and repeated the LIE that "the disabled get thousands of pounds a month"

This is grossly incorrect - and if the Secretary of State for Works and Pensions didn't know what the disabled actually got, then very sadly, it must have been a deliberate act so that they can bring in their New Disability Green Paper, giving us 'vouchers' to pay for things, and reducing the amount of money we will get to live on. They seem to think that providing an 'aid' will reduce our level of disability. It might help, but it doesn't take it away!

I am on the maximum benefit and get just over £1400 per month, and that includes my NHS Pension.

Out of that I have to pay my:
Housing costs (own home but still paying Support for Mortgage Interest back)
Energy costs - minimum as have had no heating on for 2 winters as can't afford to put it on. It's still £100/month to cover electricity and water heating.
Internet costs (basic)
Phone cost (basic)
House insurance
Mobility scooter insurance
TV Licence
Water costs
Pet insurance
Food
Dog food
Amazon Prime as cannot 'go' shopping
Debt
Care Contribution to the Council

On top of all that I also have to find the money to pay a cleaner, a gardener and someone to do odd jobs I can no longer manage, basically someone to do everything for me or risk surgery number 25 and death.

As for house repairs, I do not have a functioning accessible toilet, or an oven, and my gutter is leaking so badly that it is causing my brickwork to go black.

On £1400 a month? How?

Scope in 2023 did a report on disability and costs called The Disability Price Tag. They state in that report, that in order for a disabled person to live a life equal to that of a non-disabled person, on 'average', they would need a EXTRA £975 per month!

So, if you are 'outraged of Tunbridge Wells' (sorry I picked there!) it is no life, it is merely an existence ... and it's abut to get far, far worse. I expect like they do in Canada, should the Assisted Dying Bill gets through, we will be offered that, a slippery slope indeed.

Cossy Fri 10-May-24 13:28:50

I completely agree. It’s awful to spread these rumours. No doubt he will be able to dig up someone, who would have to be part of a family related group all sharing the same household, so in theory Mum and Dad could both be in receipt of Universal Credit and not working and living in council accommodation, and both have conditions that allow PIP to be awarded AND have two or three children, also disabled or have a condition allowing them to be awarded Disability Living Allowance. There are such families, but believe me they are very few and far between.

NanaBabs1 Fri 10-May-24 13:41:23

Without directly referring to your comments I’d just like to say that there are no more ‘disgusted’ of Tunbridge Wells than there are in any other large town in many other parts of the country. Those days are long gone yet the term is still bandied around, to resident’s huge irritation. Many are just about existing, certainly not living a life of comfort.

MadeInYorkshire Fri 10-May-24 13:52:38

NanaBabs1

Without directly referring to your comments I’d just like to say that there are no more ‘disgusted’ of Tunbridge Wells than there are in any other large town in many other parts of the country. Those days are long gone yet the term is still bandied around, to resident’s huge irritation. Many are just about existing, certainly not living a life of comfort.

I did apologise for that! But it just felt that that was what he was doing! Maybe should have said Chipping Norton, home of the bringer of austerity, Cameron!

JaneJudge Fri 10-May-24 13:56:32

Is his role model, Hitler?

Mouseybrown60 Fri 10-May-24 14:15:37

The green paper suggests that PIP is replaced with a voucher system. This would mean that claimants would send receipts for things they have bought to the DWP to claim a refund
One off grants for equipment and home alterations.
Therapy or respite care instead of cash.
Also the cost of PIP be passed on to local authorities or the NHS.
How would people come up with the cash to buy items to help with disability in the first place?

LizzieDrip Fri 10-May-24 14:53:15

I’m so sorry that you, and many others, are having to go through this MadeinYorkshire.. I too am sick to death of this government demonising the vulnerable. The measure of a decent society is how it treats its most vulnerable - clearly this government does not hold with this concept. Hopefully things will be better after the GE - I’m confident that the Labour Party believes in social justice.

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 10-May-24 15:12:13

For those who haven’t read it, here is the Green Paper

www.gov.uk/government/consultations/modernising-support-for-independent-living-the-health-and-disability-green-paper/modernising-support-for-independent-living-the-health-and-disability-green-paper

Vouchers and reimbursement for items already purchased are separate suggestions mouseybrown.

This is of course a consultation paper. Nothing is set in stone.

Cossy Fri 10-May-24 15:14:31

Mouseybrown60

The green paper suggests that PIP is replaced with a voucher system. This would mean that claimants would send receipts for things they have bought to the DWP to claim a refund
One off grants for equipment and home alterations.
Therapy or respite care instead of cash.
Also the cost of PIP be passed on to local authorities or the NHS.
How would people come up with the cash to buy items to help with disability in the first place?

They wouldn’t, that’s the whole point.

Cossy Fri 10-May-24 15:25:59

Basically since PIP was introduced 10 years ago, under the Conservatives, it’s proved more costly than they anticipated so now they essentially wish to change the criteria for being awarded PIP, to let less people “pass” the already very strict criteria. It’s not easy to get PIP. For many it’s a fight, and this will simply be more of a fight AND result in increased costs as more will appeal through the tribunal services, once one has been through the laughable DWP “Mandatory Reconsideration” process.

Ultimately the aim is to save money, bu***r the disabled!

keepcalmandcavachon Fri 10-May-24 15:30:09

LizzieDrip

I’m so sorry that you, and many others, are having to go through this MadeinYorkshire.. I too am sick to death of this government demonising the vulnerable. The measure of a decent society is how it treats its most vulnerable - clearly this government does not hold with this concept. Hopefully things will be better after the GE - I’m confident that the Labour Party believes in social justice.

Very well expressed LizzieDrip.
Good grief, how sickeningly low will they go? I hope you are OK MadeinYorkshire, sending hugs to you and your little dog flowers

Mouseybrown60 Fri 10-May-24 15:49:37

I agree with you Cossy; the poor never have a voice.
Thanks for the link GSM.

mazzie66 Fri 10-May-24 16:05:36

MadeInYorkshire
Like you I am in receipt of maximum PIP for both daily care and mobility though I use this to lease a drive from wheelchair vehicle.
Many of the expenses you have itemised are those that have to be paid by everyone, disabled or not. We all have housing, food and utility bills to pay and if you are a home owner the cost and responsibility for maintaining the fabric of your property falls on you. PIP is intended to help towards additional costs incurred through being disabled, things like your contribution towards your care costs, scooter insurance, gardening, cleaning and additional heating costs. Certainly for me, the current £434 a month goes a long way towards it. I hooves alone and have 30 hours of care each week which I have to contribute towards and the amount I pay is re-assessed every April. It is very clearly laid out in the assessment guidelines that allowances have to be made for these kinds of additional costs when calculating how much your contribution will be and can lower it considerably. The local authority doesn’t advertise this and you have to be very persistent in insuring that all allowable expenses are included. It’s an annual battle.

An assessment by an Occupational Therapist from your local authority housing department could help you resolve the issue of an accessible toilet. I have an all singing, all dancing Closomat toilet which enables me to maintain full independence in that regard. It was paid for with a Disabled Persons Facilities Grant which, again, not all disabled people are aware of.

I am sorry that you feel your life is just an existence. Everyone deserves better than that, disabled or not.

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 10-May-24 16:08:02

I think people should read the link I posted. As I said, it is only a green (consultation) paper inviting comments. The proposed vouchers would be given to enable people to buy things such as aids. The receipt idea is quite separate, to reimburse in whole or in part expenditure already incurred. I find it is always useful to go to the original source (in this case the green paper) rather than rely on what is reported in the media which can only ever give part of the picture - or on the propaganda which people put out without knowing the full story.

DiamondLily Fri 10-May-24 18:04:12

I think they’re trying to change disability benefits to those with mental health issues, more than anyone else:

www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cn0ry09d50wo

But, I can’t see anything changing now before the GE, and no one knows what Labour might do.

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 10-May-24 18:06:28

Have you read the green paper?

Dickens Fri 10-May-24 18:38:00

Germanshepherdsmum

Have you read the green paper?

... thanks for the link GSM, always best to go straight to the horse's mouth. I shall now read it as I couldn't find it earlier.

JaneJudge Fri 10-May-24 19:06:45

Cossy

Mouseybrown60

The green paper suggests that PIP is replaced with a voucher system. This would mean that claimants would send receipts for things they have bought to the DWP to claim a refund
One off grants for equipment and home alterations.
Therapy or respite care instead of cash.
Also the cost of PIP be passed on to local authorities or the NHS.
How would people come up with the cash to buy items to help with disability in the first place?

They wouldn’t, that’s the whole point.

it is unbelievable

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 10-May-24 19:27:41

Please read the link.